TV Review: ‘The Lizzie Borden Chronicles’

Christina Ricci, Clea DuVall, Cole Hauser, Jonathan Banks, Jessy Schram

Having chopped up the ratings with a 2014 movie, Lifetime shrewdly returns to the scene of the crime with “The Lizzie Borden Chronicles,” an eight-episode limited series whose success seems virtually assured on the strength of those blood-soaked billboards alone. Christina Ricci reprises her role as the notorious parent-slayer who became the subject of a children’s rhyme, now dealing with the aftermath of having been exonerated while still finding, ahem, permanent solutions to the impediments life throws her way. Joining series like “Hannibal” and “Bates Motel,” also built around antiheroes, “Lizzie” somewhat dubiously gives female psychopaths equal time.

Like the movie, the series derives some of its kick from the period, while giving Ricci a chance to play a role uniquely suited to those great big eyes of hers, offering the audience a chance to see what Wednesday Adams would look (and probably act) like all grown up.

Picking up four months after the trial in 1893, these “Chronicles” find Lizzie and her doting sister Emma (Clea DuVall) trying to move on, which begins with securing the estate that she worked up such a sweat trying to inherit. Seemingly determined to carve the point into the audience’s skin, the producers keep replaying the murders as if Ricci, as star and executive producer, were being paid for each swing of the ax.

In the early going, Lizzie is challenged by her father’s former business partner (John Heard) and her half-brother (Andrew Howard), both of whom stand in her way. There’s also the little matter of a Pinkerton detective (Cole Hauser) who has arrived in town, and taken an interest in Lizzie’s case for reasons unknown, much to the chagrin of the local constables.

The series has a good deal of fun with what such notoriety might have been like in the late-19th century, with children jumping rope to Lizzie’s name, and all the locals casting sideways glances at her in church. Really, though, it’s all an excuse to do a gothic-style tale while setting up a cat-and-mouse game pitting the detective against the sweetly smiling Lizzie, who, as played by Ricci, mixes her homicidal tendencies with a hint of seduction.

FX has clearly found an audience for such fare with the “American Horror Story” franchise, and the promise of a limited run — as opposed to trying to drag this out beyond its expiration date — makes “The Lizzie Borden Chronicles” all the more appealing.

Granted, this might not be the most elevated fare in Lifetime’s lineup. But based on reaction to the movie and the prospect of reuniting a star with such a promotable concept, it’s hard to fault the network for taking another whack at it.

TV Review: 'The Lizzie Borden Chronicles'

(Series; Lifetime, Sun. April 5, 10 p.m.)

Production: Filmed in Nova Scotia by Peace Out Prods. in association with Sony Pictures Television.

Crew: Executive producers, Judith Verno, Christina Ricci, Stanley M. Brooks; co-executive producers, Greg Small, Rich Blaney; supervising producer, David Simkins; producer, Michael J. Mahoney; director, Stephen Kay; writers, Small, Blaney; camera, Francois Degenais; production designer, Eric Fraser; editor, Ian Silverstein; music, Tree Adams; casting, Susan Edelman. 60 MIN.

Cast: Christina Ricci, Clea DuVall, Cole Hauser, Jonathan Banks, Jessy Schram

More TV

  • A.P. BIO -- Pilot -- Pictured:

    'A.P. Bio' Revived for Forthcoming NBCUniversal Streaming Service

    “A.P Bio” has made the grade after all, with NBCUniversal reviving the comedy for its unnamed, still-unlaunched streaming service. The NBC series, which ran for two seasons before getting canceled, performed well online, according to the network, with ratings showing a long tail on streaming platforms as new viewers came to the show late. Nearly [...]

  • Jeffrey Epstein

    'Morning Joe' Airs Archival Footage Linking Jeffrey Epstein and Donald Trump

    President Donald Trump told reporters recently that he hasn’t spoken to disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein in more than a decade and that he was “never a fan” of the one-time banking wunderkind and accused sex-trafficker. But footage aired Wednesday morning on “Morning Joe” appears to suggest some of what Trump said wasn’t accurate. The footage [...]

  • Veronica Mars -- "Spring Break Forever"

    'Veronica Mars' Team Talks Leaning Into Noir Mystery for Hulu Series

    After three seasons on broadcast television in the mid-aughts, followed by a fan-funded feature film, “Veronica Mars” is heading to Hulu with an eight-episode standalone season and, most importantly, a new mystery. “I don’t want it to be a nostalgia show,” creator Rob Thomas tells Variety. “Kristen [Bell] says she would do it until it’s [...]

  • Alicia Keyes Kyle Jarrow

    Alicia Keys, Benj Pasek, Justin Paul to Exec Produce Showtime Musical Drama

    There’s music in the air for Showtime. The premium cable network has made a series commitment to a yet-to-be-titled musical drama series executive produced by Alicia Keys, Benj Pasek and Justin Paul. The series, which will be produced by Fox 21 Television Studios, “traverses generations to tell an emotionally complex family story that interweaves modern-day [...]

  • ‘Eisenhorn’ Series Based on ‘Warhammer 40,000’

    ‘Eisenhorn’ Series Based on ‘Warhammer 40,000’ in the Works From Frank Spotnitz

    “Eisenhorn,” a live-action series based on the “Warhammer 40,000” game and books is in the works. “The X-Files” exec producer Frank Spotnitz will be showrunner. His shingle, Big Light, has teamed with Games Workshop, which owns “Warhammer 40,000” to develop the property. Billed as a genre-bending sci-fi and fantasy series, “Eisenhorn” is set in the [...]

  • gordon-ramsay-masterclass-review

    Gordon Ramsay and Studio Ramsay Return to WME for Representation

    Superstar TV chef Gordon Ramsay has returned to WME for representation after eight years with CAA. WME will represent Ramsay and his production company, Studio Ramsay, in all areas. Ramsay is one of the most recognizable names in the culinary world after establishing himself as a TV star in the U.K. and U.S. Studio Ramsay [...]

  • Daphne Oz leaving the chew

    Fox Renews 'MasterChef Junior,' Adds Daphne Oz as Judge

    “MasterChef Junior” will return for an eighth season with new judge Daphne Oz. Oz will replace Christina Tosi on the judges’ panel, joining chefs Gordon Ramsay and Aaron Sanchez to crown the next winner in the new season. In the upcoming season, the young contestants will cook up meals at locations including a renaissance fair [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content