You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

TV Review: ‘Sinatra: All or Nothing At All’

Luck may or may not be a lady, but Alex Gibney is on a pretty fantastic roll, following his riveting Scientology documentary “Going Clear” with “Sinatra: All or Nothing At All.” Few entertainers have lives worthy of one film, let alone this two-part, four-hour extravaganza for HBO, but Frank Sinatra can barely be done justice even then. Timed to the centennial of his birth, Gibney’s meticulous production employs an intriguing, more visually engaging style of incorporating talking heads while drawing heavily on concert footage and Sinatra interviews. Simply put, one needn’t be a huge fan to start spreading the news.

In a clever departure, Gibney features only the voice of most interview subjects – including Sinatra’s children Nancy and Frank Jr., in a film made with the participation of Sinatra’s estate – thus allowing him to keep the screen filled with footage of Sinatra in one form or another. He also frames the entire film through the prism of the singer’s retirement concert in 1971, offering a glimpse of him belting out his standards in a showcase ostensibly designed to be a personal trip down memory lane.

The first hour rather dutifully runs through Sinatra’s early biography, before becoming a star singing with Tommy Dorsey’s band and then acrimoniously splitting from him.

The project really takes off, not surprisingly, when it moves on to Sinatra at the height of his powers, from his parade of famous romances – Ava Gardner, Lauren Bacall, and later Mia Farrow – to his lobbying for racial justice, orchestration of the Rat Pack and friendship and work for then-presidential candidate John F. Kennedy. That includes footage of JFK visiting the “Ocean’s Eleven” set in Las Vegas.

Some of the best insights into Sinatra come from an interview with Walter Cronkite, asking him to address matters like his explosive temper. There’s also an interesting juxtaposition of his role with other musical icons, from Bing Crosby to Elvis Presley, who Sinatra was smart enough to host and sing a duet with despite being largely contemptuous of rock music.

Gibney deftly weaves Sinatra’s films and songs into the narrative, showing him sing “Bewitched, Bothered & Bewildered,” for example, as Sinatra and others describe his tumultuous relationship with Gardner (who, in a reading of her memoir, calls him “good in the feathers”) and how insanely smitten he was with her.

“Frank was a womanizer,” Bacall says about him matter-of-factly in an old interview. “He wanted to be in the sack with everybody.”

Like Crosby, Sinatra’s celebrity derived much of its power from his success across various media, and was then amplified by his romances with other stars, his notorious ties to the Mob and his participation in politics, which took an unexpected turn after JFK’s death when he embraced Richard Nixon. Then there were the other bizarre interludes, among them the kidnapping of then-19-year-old Frank Jr. in 1963.

With “Going Clear” having just played on HBO and his Steve Jobs doc already stirring conversation, Gibney is at the top of his game, picking off high-profile subjects that bring a strong commercial streak and event-style heft to the nonfiction form. And like the subject of this latest film, he appears to be doing it his way.


TV Review: 'Sinatra: All or Nothing At All'

(Documentary; HBO, Sun.-Mon. April 5-6, 8 p.m.)

Production: Produced by Jigsaw in association with Alcon Television Group and the Kennedy/Marshall Co.

Crew: Executive producers, Charles Pignone, Frank Marshall, Alex Gibney, Blair Foster, Andrew Kosove, Broderick Johnson, Sharon Hall; producers, Jeff Pollack, Erin Edeiken, Sam Pollard; director, Gibney; editors, Pollard, Ben Sozanski, Anoosh Tertzakian. 4 HOURS, 5 MIN.

More TV

  • Live PD A and E

    Unpredictability of 'Live PD' Delivers Real-Life Drama to A+E Networks

    The drama on “Live PD,” which tracks actual cops in the course of duty, rivals that of any scripted drama set in a police squad. One recent episode followed police as they pursued a suspect driving a car with a little girl on board. Viewers watched as the vehicle flipped over. Miraculously, the man and [...]

  • Maid book cover

    Margot Robbie, 'Shameless' Team to Adapt Stephanie Land Memoir 'Maid' at Netflix

    John Wells and Molly Smith Metzler of Showtime’s “Shameless” are teaming with Margot Robbie to adapt a best-selling memoir at Netflix. The series will be based on Stephanie Land’s “Maid: Hard Work, Low Pay, and a Mother’s Will to Survive.” It will Chronicle a single mother who turns to housekeeping to—barely—make ends meet as she [...]

  • Zac Efron'Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil and

    Zac Efron to Star in 'Killing Zac Efron' Adventure Series at Quibi

    The long list of series coming to Quibi just got whackier. Zac Efron is set to venture deep into the jungle on a remote island for a new show intriguingly titled “Killing Zac Efron,” the short form content platform has announced. “Killing Zac Efron” will see the actor go “off the grid” on this island [...]

  • Live PD A and E

    With Shows Like ‘Live PD,’ Paul Buccieri Brings A+E Networks Back to Its Roots

    “Live ‘Cops.’ ” That was the shorthand pitch-in-the-hallway that intrigued A+E Networks executive Paul Buccieri enough to respond with an immediate yes. At the time, Buccieri, 53, was about two years away from being promoted to the top job at A+E Networks, the cable programming group jointly owned by Disney and Hearst. He didn’t know [...]

  • TV Ratings: 'This Is Us' Hits

    TV Ratings: 'This Is Us' Hits Four-Week High

    “This Is Us” received a much needed boost in the TV ratings on Tuesday night, climbing to a four-week high. The NBC drama closed out its fall run with a 1.5 rating among adults 18-49 and 7.3 million total viewers, its highest viewership tally for seven weeks. NBC comfortably won the night overall, also thanks [...]

  • Armed police at the sceneAnti-terrorist police

    Probe Into Paris Terror Attacks to Be Subject of New Show From Tetra Media

    “Vernon Subutex” producer Tetra Media Studio has acquired the rights to adapt Matthieu Suc’s “Les espions de la terreur” (“The Spies of Terror”) as a high-profile spy thriller miniseries set against the backdrop of the deadly 2015 Paris terror attacks. Franck Philippon, the creator-writer and executive producer of the anticipated show “Mirage,” will be showrunner [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content