×

TV Review: ‘Downton Abbey,’ Season 5

With:
Hugh Bonneville, Maggie Smith, Laura Carmichael, Jim Carter, Raquel Cassidy, Michelle Dockery, Elizabeth McGovern, Joanne Froggatt, Allen Leech, Robert James-Collier, Penelope Wilton, Phyllis Logan, Lily James, Brendan Coyle, Lesley Nicol, Sophie McShera, Samantha Bond, Ed Speleers, Kevin Doyle, David Robb, Tom Cullen, Julian Ovenden, Daisy Lewis, Douglas Reith, Jeremy Swift, Andrew Scarborough

At this point, a new season of “Downton Abbey” is much like a visit from old friends. Sure, the stories are familiar — perhaps even just variations on what you’ve heard before — but it’s more about sharing their company and the feelings they rekindle. So after some awkward aspects to season four, the new year returns exploring many of the same issues while adding wrinkles to old ones, as Julian Fellowes continues to masterfully juggle a vast assortment of players upstairs and downstairs. Modernity is the overarching theme, but that won’t prevent admirers from dutifully returning to savor “Downton’s” Old World charms.

In some respects, the latest episodic flight (all but the Christmas episode were made available) feels less like Season 5 than Season 4, Part B, what with so much unfinished business to transact. That’s not a serious knock on the show, necessarily, although the latest storyline doesn’t contain the sort of signature events that have dictated the course for past runs.

It’s 1924, meaning roughly a dozen years have passed since the narrative officially began, with the devastation of World War I in the middle.

Yes, the Earl of Grantham (Hugh Bonneville) still presides over a sweeping estate, but the encroachment of progress can be seen everywhere, including that new-fangled radio (or “wireless”) that everyone’s prodding him to acquire, which becomes practically mandatory when the King agrees to speak via the contraption.

Beyond that, the Labor Party is in power, which adds to apprehensions among the aristocracy while stirring democratic and socialist impulses, brought into focus by one-time chauffeur Tom (Allen Leech) having befriended a teacher (Daisy Lewis) who harbors scarcely hidden contempt for all that his lordship and the great manor represent.

Romance, meanwhile, preoccupies several generations of the women in the house, with Lady Mary (Michelle Dockery) still sorting out her suitors since becoming a widow; Isobel (Penelope Wilton) being courted — much to the amusement of her frequent sparring partner, the Dowager (Maggie Smith); and young Rose (Lily James) finding her own potential beau, albeit with the inevitable complications. Even Lady Cora (Elizabeth McGovern) finds distraction in the form of a visiting art critic, played by Richard E. Grant.

Elsewhere, poor Edith (Laura Carmichael) pines for the child she was forced to give up, having placed her with a local farmer, who says sympathetically — in a perfect demonstration of Fellowes’ poetic dialogue — “We need a way for you to live the truth without telling the truth.”

Therein lies much the intrigue upstairs, while the downstairs is still primarily roiled by the season-four rape of Anna (Joanne Froggatt), and the mysterious circumstances surrounding the death of the brute that victimized her, while Thomas (Robert James-Collier) once again appears intent on stirring up trouble.

Without counting lines, there seems to be even more of the Smith-Wilton pairing this time around, and every scene featuring them is an absolute gem, worthy of its own “Golden Girls”-esque spinoff. There are also an abundance of lavish dinners, several of which become uncomfortable, evidence of the kind of biting exchanges Fellowes can conjure even when everyone’s clad in fabulous gowns and tuxedos.

For all its greatness, “Downton” is partially a victim of its success: It’s become such a cottage (or make that castle) industry that grumbling about the property looking a bit run-down is inevitable. PBS will even air a one-hour special presented by historical adviser Alistair Bruce, “The Manners of ‘Downton Abbey,’ ” immediately after the premiere.

Actually, it’s kind of cute watching PBS behave like a commercial enterprise, endeavoring to cash in on its highest-rated property. Yet having set the standard for British costume dramas commercially and artistically, “Downton” also must bear the weight of expectations associated with the rarefied strata it occupies — a high-class problem, certainly, but as the program’s central family might attest, its own kind of burden nonetheless.

Popular on Variety

TV Review: 'Downton Abbey,' Season 5

(Series; PBS, Sun. Jan. 4, 9 p.m.)

Production: Filmed in Berkshire by Carnival and Masterpiece and presented by WGBH Boston.

Crew: Executive producers, Julian Fellowes, Gareth Neame, Liz Trubridge, Nigel Marchant, Rebecca Eaton; producer, Chris Croucher; Rupert Ryle-Hodges; director, Catherine Morshead; writer, Fellowes; camera, Nigel Willoughby; production designer, Donal Woods; editor, Al Morrow; music, John Lunn; casting, Jill Trevellick. 75 MIN.

Cast: Hugh Bonneville, Maggie Smith, Laura Carmichael, Jim Carter, Raquel Cassidy, Michelle Dockery, Elizabeth McGovern, Joanne Froggatt, Allen Leech, Robert James-Collier, Penelope Wilton, Phyllis Logan, Lily James, Brendan Coyle, Lesley Nicol, Sophie McShera, Samantha Bond, Ed Speleers, Kevin Doyle, David Robb, Tom Cullen, Julian Ovenden, Daisy Lewis, Douglas Reith, Jeremy Swift, Andrew Scarborough

More TV

  • Sinclair

    Sinclair Closes Purchase of Fox Regional Sports Networks From Disney

    Sinclair Broadcast Group and the Walt Disney Company have closed their $9.6 billion deal for Sinclair to buy 21 Fox Regional Sports Networks and Fox College Sports. The deal was announced in May after Disney bought the networks as part of its acquisition of Twenty-First Century Fox. The portfolio, which excludes the YES Network, is described [...]

  • Michael Shannon

    Michael Shannon to Play Jerry Buss in HBO's 'Untitled Showtime Lakers Project' Pilot

    Michael Shannon has been cast to play self-made millionaire and former Los Angeles Lakers owner Jerry Buss in HBO’s “The Untitled Showtime Lakers Project” pilot, based on the Jeff Pearlman book “Showtime: Magic, Kareem, Riley, and the Los Angeles Lakers Dynasty of the 1980s.” The series, which chronicles the professional and personal lives of the [...]

  • Luna Nera Netflix Italy

    Netflix Eyes More Italian Productions

    Since Netflix entered the Italian market in 2015, it’s steadily gained ground in terms of subscriptions, which are expected to reach 2 million by the end of 2019, according to independent analyst Ovum. The streaming giant recently announced a €200 million ($222 million) investment in Italian original productions over the next three years. Variety spoke [...]

  • 'Serendipity': NBC Developing Series Inspired by

    'Serendipity': NBC Developing Series Inspired by Kate Beckinsale, John Cusack Movie

    NBC has given a script commitment to a prospective series inspired by the 2001 Kate Beckinsale and John Cusack movie “Serendipity.” The project hails from Miramax Television, whose film division produced the original film, and writer Jonny Umansky. The idea for the show seems like a romantic one, here’s the logline: Harry and Claire fall [...]

  • The Bachelor frontrunners

    Who's the Next 'Bachelor'? Here Are Season 24's Three Frontrunners (EXCLUSIVE)

    When last season of “The Bachelorette” wrapped up, many viewers would have guessed the next “Bachelor” would be runner-up Tyler Cameron. But oh, how things change in a month’s time. Cameron, the runner-up in Hannah Brown’s season, who stopped by “The Bachelorette” finale’s live after show to quickly reconcile with Brown and discuss meeting for [...]

  • Thom Zimny, Bruce Springsteen and Martin

    Bruce Springsteen's Director, Thom Zimny, on the Move from 'Broadway' to 'Western Stars'

    Director Thom Zimny is due for a big September: Come Sept. 22, he’ll find out whether he’s winning an Emmy Award for directing “Springsteen on Broadway” for Netflix. Ten days before that, he’ll be at the Toronto Intl. Film Festival to premiere a theatrical feature, “Western Stars,” which he co-directed with his muse and subject, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content