TV Review: MTV’s ‘Scream’

Willa Fitzgerald, Bex Taylor-Klaus, Carlson Young, Amadeus Serafini, John Karna, Connor Weil, Tracy Middendorf, Jason Wiles

“You can’t do a slasher movie as a TV series,” one of the teen characters, helpfully well versed in the conventions of the genre, explains near the outset of “Scream,” Dimension and MTV’s attempt to put that theory to the test. Arriving a few months before Fox’s confusingly similar “Scream Queens,” the series does exhibit a playful sense of self-mockery, without really answering that aforementioned conundrum — except, perhaps, that MTV’s expectations will be considerably lower than Fox’s or, for that matter, CBS’ when it tried to mine the same skewered-teenagers niche with “Harper’s Island.”

The eight-minute opening sequence is classic slasher fare, with a beautiful bikini-clad teen being stalked and stabbed, thinking for a time that it’s her boyfriend who is sending her those cheeky texts. Once the foul deed happens, though, “Scream,” perhaps out of necessity, shifts to a more conventional teen-drama mode, introducing an assortment of characters, most of whom, one suspects, should be prepared to get shish-kebabbed before it’s all over.

At the center of it all is Emma (Willa Fitzgerald), whose loyalties are tested when her friend Audrey (Bex Taylor-Klaus) is outed as a lesbian by the mean kids, one of whom has just been dispatched with great prejudice, as noted, in her backyard. Not surprisingly, the town has its own dark history involving a serial killer, leaving Emma’s mom (Tracy Middendorf) and the local sheriff (Jason Wiles) as the two adults who don’t sound entirely like Charlie Brown’s parents, left to try to sort out what’s happening.

Not that the murder comes as much of a mystery to Noah (John Karna), the nerdy movie buff who is seemingly there in part to keep reminding us what we’re watching. He joins a roster of what are generally more high-school types than fleshed-out characters, from the mysterious (but brooding and hot) new kid (Amadeus Serafini) to the haughty popular ones, whose herd is likely the first to get thinned.

Written by Jay Beattie, Dan Dworkin and exec producer Jill Blotevogel (the last a “Harper’s Island” alum), “Scream” leverages the initial murder to build suspense without much actually happening during the remainder of the hour, using a lot of dissonant strings instead of opened veins to set the mood. Yet the real trick will be teasing out the suspense as the number of viable suspects gradually dwindles, as well as making the audience see these characters as more than just chum.

Conceptually, “Scream” surely looks like a winner: The built-in name recognition is an asset, and the demographics fall squarely within MTV’s wheelhouse. Heck, even the not-really-teenagers look enough like high-school students to avoid the “Grease” effect.

That said, there really is a difference between TV and movies in dealing with such fare, a line that the “American Horror Story” franchise has commercially straddled but, if history’s any guide, one that remains perilous nevertheless.

“Slasher movies burn bright and fast,” Noah tells his pals. “TV needs to stretch things out.” If this works, and he survives it, maybe they should let him produce the next season.

TV Review: MTV's 'Scream'

(Series; MTV, Tues. June 30, 10 p.m.)

Production: Filmed in Los Angeles (pilot) and Louisiana (series) by Dimension TV.

Crew: Executive producers, Bob Weinstein, Harvey Weinstein, Jill Blotevogel, Jaime Paglia, Wes Craven, Tony DiSanto, Liz Gateley, Marianne Maddalena, Cathy Konrad; director, Jamie Travis; writers, Jay Beattie, Dan Dworkin, Blotevogel; story by Kevin Williamson. 60 MIN.

Cast: Willa Fitzgerald, Bex Taylor-Klaus, Carlson Young, Amadeus Serafini, John Karna, Connor Weil, Tracy Middendorf, Jason Wiles

More TV

  • Hulu Hopes to Make Ads Part

    Hulu Hopes to Make Ads Part of Your Binge Session

    If you just can’t keep yourself from watching another episode of “The Handmaid’s Tale” or “PEN15,” then Hulu has an ad for you. The streaming-video hub is starting a trial run of new commercials aimed specifically at binge-watchers, which the company defines as subscribers who watch three or more episodes of the same series consecutively. [...]

  • Bernie Sanders, Joe Biden, Elizabeth Warren,

    Democrats Unveil Four More Debates in 2020

    Democrats will hold four more debates among the presidential candidates, as the party continues to try to generate attention for its side in the race for the White House. On January 14, before the February 3 Democratic primary caucus in Iowa, CNN will moderate a debate in Des Moines, and partner with the Des Moines [...]

  • national lampoon's christmas vacation

    'National Lampoon's Vacation' Series in Development at HBO Max, Johnny Galecki to Produce

    HBO Max is developing a series based on the Grisworld family from the “National Lampoon’s Vacation” films, Variety has learned. Titled “The Griswolds,” the series will see the titular family home from vacation and explore their daily lives in the suburbs of modern-day Chicago. Tim Hobert is attached to write and executive produce the half-hour single-camera [...]

  • Pose The Morning Show Big Little

    Golden Globes 2020: TV Categories Broken Down With Projected Winners

    Variety examines what to expect when the Television winners’ names are announced at the 77th annual Golden Globe Awards ceremony on Jan. 5, 2020. DRAMA SERIES Last year, the Hollywood Foreign Press Assn. went all-in on shiny new series in this category (the lone exception was the eventual winner, FX’s final season of “The Americans”), [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content