×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

TV Review: ‘Cosby: The Women Speak’

Anyone who has followed the Bill Cosby sexual-assault allegations must feel as if there’s not much more to learn, amid a steady drip of women who have come forward, culminating with the 35 featured in New York magazine. Still, it’s bracing to see the accusers — more than a dozen of them — calmly tell their stories on camera, as they do in the A&E special “Cosby: The Women Speak.” The one-hour production slowly builds a compelling case, as the women lay out details of what they say happened, without being flanked by attorney Gloria Allred or a bank of microphones.

Cosby’s defenders (seemingly a dwindling contingent) have often suggested that this is a money grab, directed at one of the world’s wealthiest entertainers. But that argument feels weakened by the weight of actually seeing so many women explain not only how they were victimized but why they didn’t come forward at the time. As one recalls thinking, given the star’s squeaky-clean, Madison Avenue-endorsed image, “Who’s going to believe me?”

Produced by Lincoln Square Prods., an entertainment-oriented subdivision of ABC News, “The Women Speak” goes through these cases in chronological order, while documenting where Cosby was in his career at that moment — first as a breakthrough comic and Emmy-winning star of “I Spy” (hailed by Variety as “Television’s Jackie Robinson”) and later as the star/producer of “Fat Albert and the Cosby Kids” and eventually “The Cosby Show.”

The stories, moreover, gain strength as one piles upon another, echoing feelings of surprise, betrayal and confusion, as well as a sense of resignation. The women hold up pictures of their younger selves, the versions that Cosby allegedly preyed upon, usually with promises to develop or mentor their careers.

“I buried it, locked it up, moved on with my life,” one says, while another, publicist Joan Tarshis, asks simply, “Why would I lie?”

Cosby is not interviewed for the special, but there is footage of him expressing his dismay at the charges, and sidestepping the question during an AP interview. There are also clips of the star speaking out about teen pregnancy and advocating the need for greater personal responsibility in the African-American community — the sort of comments that prompted comic Hannibal Buress to peg him as a hypocrite and help revive these allegations.

“Cosby: The Women Speak” is the first of four specials Lincoln Square is producing for A&E, and it’s certainly an attention-grabbing topic. As the project notes, the statute of limitations provides a shield in most of these cases, but the court of public opinion already seems to have rendered a verdict. And while an hour is hardly enough time to fully do this story justice, as constructed it’s nevertheless a sobering account that helps humanize these women beyond just the label “accuser.”

TV Review: 'Cosby: The Women Speak'

(Special; A&E, Thurs. Sept. 17, 9 p.m.)

Production: Produced by Lincoln Square Prods.

Crew: Senior executive producer, Jeanmarie Condon; executive producers, Jim Hill Senior, Shelly Tatro, Brad Abramson. 60 MIN.

More TV

  • At Home with Amy Sedaris Documentary

    Amy Sedaris, Fred Armisen on the Art of Creating Short-Term Characters

    Few disciplines are as tough to shine in as sketch comedy. Often, being funny isn’t often enough. What makes a sketch resonate comes down to the characters. But while sitcoms build arcs over seasons, short skits require viewers to buy into new characters constantly. It’s a tricky art. For decades, “Saturday Night Live” has blended [...]

  • Desus and Mero Samantha Bee

    How Late-Night Talk Shows Avoid Political Burnout

    It may feel like late-night talk shows often overwhelmingly consist of a barrage of recounts of the most recent, or most polarizing, political headlines or tweets. It’s a subject matter that can’t, and perhaps shouldn’t, be avoided, given the changing state of local laws when it comes to health care, that families are literally being [...]

  • CBS to Launch DABL Digital Lifestyle

    CBS to Launch DABL Digital Lifestyle Channel in September

    CBS is moving into the lifestyle channel arena with the launch of DABL, a digital multicast network set to launch in September through its CBS Television Distribution unit. CBS has acquired a raft of programming from the vaults of Martha Stewart and Emeril Lagasse to help fill out the channel devoted to what it described [...]

  • Variety Portrait Studio, Beautycon Festival Los

    Tyra Banks to Star in, Executive Produce Quibi Docuseries 'Beauty'

    Tyra Banks is the latest name to join the Quibi content push. The actress and model will both star in and executive produce a new documentary series titled “Beauty,” a multi-part show which “celebrates being beautiful.” The aim of the series is to “break down barriers and challenge traditional notions” of beauty and question the societal [...]

  • GRAND HOTEL - ABC's "Grand Hotel"

    TV Shows to Watch the Week of June 17, 2019: 'Grand Hotel' Premieres on ABC

    Welcome back to Tune In: our weekly newsletter offering a guide to the best of the week’s TV. Each week, Variety’s TV team combs through the week’s schedule, selecting our picks of what to watch and when/how to watch them. This week, “Grand Hotel” premieres on ABC and season 2 of “Vida” comes to a [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content