×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

TV Review: ‘Arthur & George’

With:
Martin Clunes, Arsher Ali, Art Malik, Emma Fielding, Charles Edwards, Hattie MorahanSir

While American television has shifted toward shorter series orders, it still hasn’t caught up with British productions like “Arthur & George,” which tells a self-contained story over three serialized episodes that each run about 45 minutes, so roughly the length of a feature film. Yet while this fact-based look at an episode in the life of Sherlock Holmes creator Sir Arthur Conan Doyle appears designed to cash in on interest in all things related to the fictional sleuth, it’s a slim construct, with a mystery that’s as wispy and unsubstantial as fog drifting in over the moors.

Starring Martin Clunes as Doyle, the movie operates on two related tracks: The famed author has lost his wife, and is plagued by guilt over whether she knew of his emotional attachment to another woman, Jean (Hattie Morahan), before her death. So he throws himself into investigating the case of George Edalji (“The Missing’s” Arsher Ali), a mixed-race solicitor (his father is an Indian pastor) who, in 1903, served time for mutilating animals — a crime he appears not to have committed — and is being tormented (dare one say hounded?) again upon his release.

Sir Arthur, naturally, applies Holmes-like logic to try to figure out what really happened, with his personal secretary Alfred Wood (“Downton Abbey’s” Charles Edwards) serving as his Dr. Watson. Still, it’s not a terribly compelling mystery, and proceeds hand-in-hand with Doyle’s furtive steps to advance his relationship with Jean without scandalizing his family.

Holmes is such a tremendously durable character (as evidenced by Ian McKellen’s recent turn as an aged version of him in “Mr. Holmes”) that anything trading off that franchise likely has some drawing power. That said, “Arthur & George” (adapted by Ed Whitmore from Julian Barnes’ book, and directed by Stuart Orme) is understated to the point of sleepy, and doesn’t sprinkle enough red herrings to provoke much guessing or suspense as to what actually transpired.

Those misgivings exist despite what is clearly a topnotch cast, with Ali, in particular, creating a shroud of mystery around the stiff-upper-lipped George, a barrister who dismisses out of hand any suggestions that racial animus could have possibly been responsible for inspiring a plot against him.

On its face, “Arthur & George” looks like a natural for PBS, mashing up as it does impeccable period trappings, Victorian romance and the allure of a true story (yes, there’s script about what happened at the end) with the underlying Holmes-esque mystery. As put together, though, it’s handsome enough, but ultimately feels just a trifle too elementary.

Popular on Variety

TV Review: 'Arthur & George'

(Miniseries; PBS, Sun. Sept. 6-20, 8 p.m.)

Production: Produced by Buffalo Pictures and Masterpiece for ITV.

Crew: Executive producer, Rebecca Eaton; producers, Philippa Braithwaite, Trevor Hopkins; director, Stuart Orme; writer, Ed Whitmore; based on the novel by Julian Barnes; camera, Suzie Lavelle; production designer, Anthony Ainsworth; editor, David Yardley; music, Rob Lane; casting, Toby Whale. 3 HOURS

Cast: Martin Clunes, Arsher Ali, Art Malik, Emma Fielding, Charles Edwards, Hattie MorahanSir

More TV

  • Judith Light'Transparent' TV show Musical Finale,

    'Transparent' Team Talks 'Transformative Energy' of Trans Community

    As Amazon Prime Video prepares to send off “Transparent” with a musical finale movie on Sept. 27, the cast and creative team behind the show are hoping the impact of a character such as Maura Pfefferman (Jeffrey Tambor) will not be overshadowed by the controversy that the actor who portrayed Maura caused. “I believe that [...]

  • Cherry Jones

    Cherry Jones Wins 2019 Guest Drama Actress Emmy

    Cherry Jones won the 2019 guest drama actress Emmy for her work as the titular character’s mother, Holly Osborne, in Hulu’s “The Handmaid’s Tale.” This was Jones’ second consecutive nomination for the role but first win. Interestingly, both noms were for her work in the second season of the dystopian streaming series. After a few [...]

  • Jane Lynch, Cyndi Lauper Developing 'Golden

    Jane Lynch, Cyndi Lauper Developing 'Golden Girls'-Style Comedy for Netflix

    Jane Lynch and Cyndi Lauper just wanna have fun. The comedian and the 1980s music icon have joined forces to star in a new comedy project that may be heading to Netflix. Lynch let it slip backstage at the Creative Arts Emmys that she and Lauper will co-star in a comedy that she described as [...]

  • Luke Kirby71st Annual Primetime Creative Arts

    Luke Kirby Wins 2019 Guest Comedy Actor Emmy

    Luke Kirby has been crowned the winner of the 2019 guest comedy actor Emmy for his role as the real-life comic Lenny Bruce on Amazon Prime Video’s “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel.” This was Kirby’s first-ever Emmy attention. He was nominated against a slew of “Saturday Night Live” players (Robert De Niro, John Mulaney and Adam [...]

  • Bradley Whitford photographed at the PMC

    Bradley Whitford Wins 2019 Guest Drama Actor Emmy

    Bradley Whitford won the 2019 guest drama actor Emmy for his role of Commander Joseph Lawrence on Hulu’s “The Handmaid’s Tale.” Whitford joined the cast of the streaming dystopian series at the end of its second season, in episodes that were released after the close of the 2018 Emmy eligibility window. The Television Academy agreed [...]

  • TV Review: 'Transparent' Series Finale

    TV Review: 'Transparent' Series Finale

    Amazon’s “Transparent” will have a chapter, or a section of one, in some to-be-written history of television, in part thanks to how brazen and how daring its ideas were for its moment. Some of those were ideas that came to seem simply logical in retrospect: The show was a pathbreaker for trans representation onscreen, casting [...]

  • Jane Lynch NBC Relatively Happy

    Jane Lynch Wins 2019 Guest Comedy Actress Emmy

    Jane Lynch has been crowned the winner of the 2019 guest comedy actress Emmy for her role of comic Sophie Lennon on Amazon Prime Video’s “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel.” This was Lynch’s second consecutive nomination for the role but first win. However, it is her fifth Emmy overall, after winning a short form statue in [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content