×

TV Review: ‘Arthur & George’

With:
Martin Clunes, Arsher Ali, Art Malik, Emma Fielding, Charles Edwards, Hattie MorahanSir

While American television has shifted toward shorter series orders, it still hasn’t caught up with British productions like “Arthur & George,” which tells a self-contained story over three serialized episodes that each run about 45 minutes, so roughly the length of a feature film. Yet while this fact-based look at an episode in the life of Sherlock Holmes creator Sir Arthur Conan Doyle appears designed to cash in on interest in all things related to the fictional sleuth, it’s a slim construct, with a mystery that’s as wispy and unsubstantial as fog drifting in over the moors.

Starring Martin Clunes as Doyle, the movie operates on two related tracks: The famed author has lost his wife, and is plagued by guilt over whether she knew of his emotional attachment to another woman, Jean (Hattie Morahan), before her death. So he throws himself into investigating the case of George Edalji (“The Missing’s” Arsher Ali), a mixed-race solicitor (his father is an Indian pastor) who, in 1903, served time for mutilating animals — a crime he appears not to have committed — and is being tormented (dare one say hounded?) again upon his release.

Sir Arthur, naturally, applies Holmes-like logic to try to figure out what really happened, with his personal secretary Alfred Wood (“Downton Abbey’s” Charles Edwards) serving as his Dr. Watson. Still, it’s not a terribly compelling mystery, and proceeds hand-in-hand with Doyle’s furtive steps to advance his relationship with Jean without scandalizing his family.

Holmes is such a tremendously durable character (as evidenced by Ian McKellen’s recent turn as an aged version of him in “Mr. Holmes”) that anything trading off that franchise likely has some drawing power. That said, “Arthur & George” (adapted by Ed Whitmore from Julian Barnes’ book, and directed by Stuart Orme) is understated to the point of sleepy, and doesn’t sprinkle enough red herrings to provoke much guessing or suspense as to what actually transpired.

Those misgivings exist despite what is clearly a topnotch cast, with Ali, in particular, creating a shroud of mystery around the stiff-upper-lipped George, a barrister who dismisses out of hand any suggestions that racial animus could have possibly been responsible for inspiring a plot against him.

On its face, “Arthur & George” looks like a natural for PBS, mashing up as it does impeccable period trappings, Victorian romance and the allure of a true story (yes, there’s script about what happened at the end) with the underlying Holmes-esque mystery. As put together, though, it’s handsome enough, but ultimately feels just a trifle too elementary.

TV Review: 'Arthur & George'

(Miniseries; PBS, Sun. Sept. 6-20, 8 p.m.)

Production: Produced by Buffalo Pictures and Masterpiece for ITV.

Crew: Executive producer, Rebecca Eaton; producers, Philippa Braithwaite, Trevor Hopkins; director, Stuart Orme; writer, Ed Whitmore; based on the novel by Julian Barnes; camera, Suzie Lavelle; production designer, Anthony Ainsworth; editor, David Yardley; music, Rob Lane; casting, Toby Whale. 3 HOURS

Cast: Martin Clunes, Arsher Ali, Art Malik, Emma Fielding, Charles Edwards, Hattie MorahanSir

More TV

  • WGA West Logo

    Writers Guild Sends Hollywood Agents Proposed Code of Conduct

    Leaders of the Writers Guild of America have sent Hollywood talent agencies a proposed “Code of Conduct” with tough new restrictions on how they operate as agents for writer clients. The WGA made the disclosure Thursday night in an email to its 12,000 members, a day after announcing that it will hold a March 25 [...]

  • Jussie Smollett court

    Jussie Smollett's Attorneys Say He Was Victim of Police 'Spectacle'

    Jussie Smollett’s legal team issued a defiant statement on Thursday night, saying the “Empire” actor feels betrayed by the justice system and hinting at a political motive for his prosecution. Smollett was arrested early Thursday on a felony charge of filing a false police report. He was released after a court hearing on $100,000 bond, [...]

  • Carra Patterson Sarah Levy Paola Lazaro

    Fox Casts Four Leads in 'Patty's Auto' Pilot

    Fox has announced the casting of four lead characters for its multi-cam comedy pilot “Patty’s Auto,” including the eponymous Patty. Inspired by Patrice Banks’ Girls Auto Clinic, an auto repair shop with all female mechanics, the project centers on Patty, the intimidating owner of Patty’s Auto who will be played by “Straight Outta Compton” alumna [...]

  • Adam Pally Abby Elliott

    Adam Pally, Abby Elliott Join Cast of NBC Comedy Pilot 'Uninsured'

    NBC pilot “Uninsured” has cast four of its series regulars, with Adam Pally (“The Mindy Project,” “The President Show”) and Abby Elliott (“Saturday Night Live,” “Odd Mom Out”) playing the young married couple at the center of the show. Pally will play Dave, who is described as a “natural hype man with a good heart.” Elliott [...]

  • Jussie Smollett Appeared in Documentary on

    Jussie Smollett Recently Hosted Doc on Lynching, Filmmaker Talks 'Coincidence'

    In May 2018, Jussie Smollett appeared as the narrator and correspondent in an episode of the Epix documentary series “America Divided” that explored the subject of hate crimes, specifically lynching, in the state of Tennessee. Now that the “Empire” actor has been charged with filing a false police report and Chicago police are convinced he [...]

  • TV News Roundup: CBS All Access

    TV News Roundup: 'Twilight Zone' Reboot Drops First Full Trailer (Watch)

    In today’s TV news roundup, CBS All Access has released the official trailer for the rebooted “Twilight Zone” and Sophia Bush will guest star on “Jane the Virgin.” CASTING Related PBS to Boost ‘Masterpiece’ Programming Next Year Ian McKellen on Playing Sherlock in ‘Mr. Holmes’: ‘He’s Not Who You Thought He Was’ “One Tree Hill” [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content