’19 Kids & Counting’ Scandal Highlights Real Risks of Reality Television

With the Duggar family scandal still in flux at TLC, the topic of risk-taking reality television was much discussed at the RealScreen West entertainment conference this week in Santa Monica, Calif.

During his keynote discussion Monday, unscripted television creator Mark Burnett lent his opinion on “19 Kids and Counting,” which was rocked by the news that family and cast member Josh Duggar had molested children before the series debuted, according to a leaked 2006 police report. Duggar responded to the report, confessing that he acted “inexcusably.”

“I think [David] Zaslov did the right thing pulling that off,” Burnett said of the Discovery Communications prexy who oversees TLC. “Clearly, it’s an icky situation, to say the least.”

“A lesser company would have tried to profit off of it…failing to realize how many people have been hurt and emotionally scarred,” Burnett continued, giving a nod to the cabler for suspending repeat airings of the hit series, which still soared in its 10th season ratings this May. Though a final decision regarding the show’s future still remains to be made, Burnett said, “I think they should be applauded for taking it off.”

In addition to Burnett, Paul Buccieri, president of A&E and History, also delivered a keynote at RealScreen West on Tuesday, but he did not address the previous scandals (which occurred before he joined the network) revolving around A&E’s “Duck Dynasty,” which the cabler kept on its schedule despite a brief casting suspension after patriarch Phil Robertson caused a media frenzy with anti-gay comments.

During the “Living on the Edge” panel, which showcased high-risk reality television with network exec and unscripted producer panelists, the topic of uncertainty with real-life subjects was highlighted.

“One of the risks you take when you’re following real people is it’s tough to tell what you’re getting into,” said panelist Tom Forman of Relativity Television, who was a producer on A&E’s short-lived prostitution docuseries “8 Minutes,” which the network pulled before the controversial project wrapped its initial run. Forman mentioned the importance of “finding those networks that are willing to take that leap with you,” adding that showcasing unscripted talent requires a willingness to take a series wherever it may go, no matter how unexpected.

On the panel, LMN exec Laura Fleury, who worked on the network’s special “Escaping Polygamy,” also spoke about producing content with out-of-the-ordinary cast members. “We always work very closely with our legal department,” she said. GRB Entertainment’s Michael Branton, who is behind “Intervention,” admitted that high-stakes series with larger-than-life personalities can take a toll on the creative team. “Everyone on the crew could have therapy because these shows are so intense,” he said.

Of course, “19 Kids and Counting” always intended to showcase the exact opposite type of cast: a wholesome, devout Christian family with strong values. Still, real-life talent can always pose an unexpected problem — and that’s the risk with reality TV.

“You can’t know every little thing, but you can make an effort,” Burnett said of unforeseen issues, which arise with unscripted programming. Mentioning outspoken personalities Donald Trump and Sarah Palin, both of whom Burnett has worked with on their respective series, he added, “We shouldn’t have any censorship, and I really stand for that…it’s a free country. It’s what we fought for.”

To wrap up his session, Burnett pitched his new faith-based show, which he’s exec producing with his wife and producing partner Roma Downey, who will also host the series, set to bow on TLC later this year. “Let’s face it, they need a new show this week.”

More TV

  • Emmys: 'Better Call Saul' Short Loses

    'Better Call Saul' Short Loses Emmy Nominations in Light of Category Rule Violation

    Better Call AMC: Two Emmy nominations for the network’s short-form series “Better Call Saul Employee Training: Madrigal Electromotive Security” have been pulled after it was deemed ineligible for competition. The Television Academy recently discovered that the series didn’t meet the minimum required runtime of two minutes for at least six episodes — a new stipulation [...]

  • The Boys Amazon Prime

    ‘The Boys’ Lands Early Season 2 Renewal at Amazon

    Amazon has renewed “The Boys” for a second season ahead of the show’s series premiere next week. The streamer also announced that Aya Cash will join the show in the second season. Season 1 of “The Boys” will debut on July 26. It is based on the New York Times best-selling comic of the same [...]

  • Variety Cord Cutting Placeholder Cable

    Big Blackout Looms as CBS, AT&T Go Down to Wire on Renewal Talks

    A blackout affecting CBS stations in major markets throughout the country looms as CBS and AT&T executives go down to the wire on negotiations for a retransmission consent deal covering 28 O&O stations. The sides have sparred publicly during the past few days as 11 p.m. PT Friday expiration of the previous contract approached. AT&T [...]


    TV News Roundup: Netflix Releases Season 3 Trailer For 'Dear White People'

    In today’s TV news roundup, Netflix releases a trailer for the third season of “Dear White People,” and Disney casts Billy Campbell and Kathy Najimy in upcoming Disney Junior series, “The Rocketeer.” CASTING Billy Campbell and Kathy Najimy have joined the cast of forthcoming animated series “The Rocketeer.” The seasoned actors will voice character Kitana [...]

  • Andrew Lincoln as Rick Grimes - The

    Andrew Lincoln's ‘Walking Dead’ Movies to Be Released Only in Theaters

    The first planned movie centered on “The Walking Dead” character Rick Grimes will now run in theaters rather than on AMC. The announcement was made with a brief teaser video played at San Diego Comic-Con on Friday, with the video ending with the words “Only in Theaters.” The film will be distributed by Universal Pictures. [...]

  • Contract Placeholder Business WGA ATA Agent

    ICM Responds to WGA Packaging Lawsuit: Claims are 'Baseless' and 'Absurd'

    ICM Partners has asked a judge to dismiss the lawsuit filed against four major talent agencies by the Writers Guild of America as part of the larger war between agencies and the guild over packaging fees on TV series and movies. The guild sued ICM, CAA, WME and UTA in California state court in April, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content