Jimmy Fallon-Stephen Colbert Divide Mirrors Leno-Letterman

Don’t look now, but Jimmy Fallon appears to have entered his Jay Leno phase a bit sooner than scheduled. With the arrival of Stephen Colbert on CBS’ “The Late Show,” “The Tonight Show” host has quickly become the popular kid, but not the cool one – the big box store of late-night comedy.

Fallon has another opportunity to show himself off in a favorable light Wednesday, with Hillary Clinton scheduled, amid a primary election cycle that has made politicians the “get” guests of the moment. But this turn of current events has also exposed NBC’s late-night champ in a less flattering way, demonstrating that he’s fine staging bits with Justin Timberlake and less comfortable with substantive conversation.

See More: Hillary Clinton to Appear on Jimmy Fallon’s ‘Tonight Show’

Colbert’s program remains a bit of a work in progress, but he brought enormous goodwill with him to the job, and further cemented his reputation last week with an interview with Vice President Joe Biden that was touching and funny all at once. And while Fallon rebounded from Colbert’s big sampling numbers to reclaim the top spot ratings-wise, his woefully thin encounter with Donald Trump the next night fed the perception that his is the “safe” choice for candidates, perhaps, but also less likely to win the admiration of peers and pundits.

In that regard, the Fallon-Colbert relationship – while still in flux – already resembles the Leno-David Letterman dynamic, without the bad blood or feuding (but with a healthy dose of jockeying for guests). Fallon might be the ratings leader, as Leno was, but Colbert figures to be the choice of most critics and media elites, which might not be as easy to monetize but carries a certain cachet nevertheless.

Jon Stewart, notably, was never the most-watched late-night comic, but his footprint echoed through the media louder than anyone else. Similarly, Colbert figures to get more next-day mileage out of Monday’s thoughtful exchange with Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer — asking him why court members can disagree amicably, unlike the other branches of government — than Fallon will out of a game-show segment featuring Benicio del Toro and Jessica Alba.

While the current late-night shuffle remains fluid – including Trevor Noah’s upcoming “The Daily Show” premiere – a few more coups for Colbert coupled with content-free interviews of serious figures by Fallon and it won’t take long for those positions to calcify. As it stands, when Fallon, impersonating Trump, referred to himself as a “lightweight,” the joke struck uncomfortably close to home after watching them chat.

Fallon has clearly connected with a segment of the audience, and his ratings have given NBC’s Peacock mascot plenty to crow about, especially after the botched late-night baton pass that preceded his ascent to the “Tonight Show” throne. It’s worth noting, too, that while trailing in the ratings gnawed at Letterman, Leno always laughed off the notion that his rival was more respected in certain circles, although he acknowledged the perception. When Entertainment Weekly left him off its list of the “50 Funniest People” in the late ’90s, Leno quipped, “”It’s like your wife’s family. It’d be nice if they like you, but it’s not the end of the world.”

That certainly seems like the healthier attitude in light of the inordinate success that both enjoyed. And while Colbert and Fallon are unlikely to match their predecessors’ longevity, they could find themselves in a similar competitive predicament. Granted, late-night viewing is no longer a zero-sum game: options have proliferated, and those with DVRs so inclined can easily record more than one show. The lack of personal animus between the current hosts (compared to the ill feelings triggered by the Johnny Carson succession battle) also makes this less a late-night “war” than more of a friendly skirmish.

Much of this was fairly predictable — perhaps especially among those who admire Colbert and are less keen on Fallon — back when CBS first announced hiring him. Nevertheless, if trends continue along their present course, the new late-night divide could wind up, in a few key ways, looking a whole lot like the old one.

More TV

  • Beyonce-HOMECOMING-Netflix

    Beyoncé, Sara Bareilles Vie for First Emmys as Ramin Djawadi Looks to Reclaim Throne

    Beyoncé and Sara Bareilles could add Emmy trophies to their awards shelves this year, having been nominated in key music categories Tuesday by the Television Academy. Beyoncé’s “Homecoming” special on Netflix was nominated in six categories, and four of those include a nod for the pop superstar herself. Only one of those is in a [...]

  • Disney Content Sales President Janice Marinelli

    Disney Content Sales President Janice Marinelli to Depart

    Janice Marinelli, president of global sales and marketing at Walt Disney’s direct-to-consumer and international segment, said Tuesday that she would step down from her role after a 34-year career at the company. “It has been an honor to work for this company and a privilege to work with so many outstanding professionals,” said Marinelli in [...]

  • Dusty Slay

    Late-Night Bookers Take to the Internet in Search of Emerging Comics

    With Netflix releasing a comedy special every week and YouTube offering a portal into both cutting-edge performance and the best comedy sets in history, it’s never been easier for audiences to access an endless stream of standup. But for fledgling comics, there’s still no more game-changing showcase than a five-minute slot on a late-night talk [...]


    CBS Warns DirecTV, AT&T U-Verse May Drop Network

    Some of CBS Corp.’s biggest stations and its flagship network could be dropped from AT&T’s various cable and satellite services if a carriage agreement between the companies is not reached by July 19. “CBS has reached timely, fair agreements with hundreds of other cable, satellite, telco and internet providers to carry our industry-leading, fan-favorite programming,”  [...]

  • Billy Porter, 2019 Oscars Gown, Actors

    Watch Emilia Clarke, Billy Porter and More 2019 Emmy Nominees on Variety's 'Actors on Actors'

    What did Emmy nominee Billy Porter from “Pose” learn about women from co-nominee Rachel Brosnahan on “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel?” What does Michael Douglas respect the most about Benicio del Toro’s acting ability? And how does Maya Rudolph’s recent meditations on the afterlife in the “The Good Place” coincide with the conversations Natasha Lyonne’s thoughts [...]

  • Russian Doll

    2019 Emmy Nominations Did Right by a Great Year in Comedy (Column)

    Even before the 2019 Emmy nominations were announced, the biggest and most obvious story belonged to the fact that last year’s drama nominees almost completely cleared the way for the final season of “Game of Thrones.” But for as weak as the drama categories are overall (give or take a “Pose”), the comedy categories have [...]

  • Big Little Lies Stranger Things

    Here's Why 'Big Little Lies' and 'Stranger Things' Weren't Nominated for 2019 Emmys

    Meryl Streep joined “Big Little Lies” this season, and “Stranger Things” broke a Netflix record — so why didn’t either show score an Emmy nomination? Every year, critically acclaimed and fan-favorite shows are noticeably omitted from the Emmy nominations, but not because they were snubbed. It’s because they’re not eligible.  This year, ineligible series include [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content