You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

When Hunting Ratings, It’s Always Springtime For Hitler

World War II ended 70 years ago, but its hold over the collective consciousness is such that in TV, it always seems to be springtime for Hitler. Yet the way that material is handled should give students of history pause, especially as commercial pressures reshape the landscape for nonfiction programming.

This month delivers a trio of programs that trade off the Nazi regime, starting with “Hunting Hitler,” an eight-part series that recently premiered on History. Built around once-classified documents, it pursues the question of whether Adolf Hitler might have somehow escaped his bunker and fled to South America, coming close to trivializing its subject by treating the aftermath of the Holocaust as if it were just another cold case.

History might not know much about history anymore, but Nazis are an accessory that never goes out of style. In what constitutes fortunate timing, the lower-profile Smithsonian Channel counters that bloated production with a mercifully spare one, “The Day Hitler Died,” which premieres on Nov. 16. The one-hour special draws extensively on interviews conducted by Nuremberg judge and Navy lawyer Capt. Michael Musmanno with Hitler aides and military staff, seeking to determine conclusively that Hitler did indeed take his own life. That grainy footage — which was rediscovered in 2013 — paints a methodical portrait of the Nazi leader’s final days, including his growing madness, grave concern about falling into Allied hands and eventual suicide.

Those nonfiction accounts are joined by a fictionalized one, which in its own way could be every bit as illuminating: Amazon’s “The Man in the High Castle,” adapted from a novel by the great science fiction writer Philip K. Dick, imagines an early-1960s America that lost the war and has been living under divided German and Japanese rule, while mounting a counter-insurgency on U.S. soil. If nothing else, the show should be required viewing for any politician who tends to be too cavalier in using Nazi analogies or referencing totalitarianism to describe policies with which they disagree.

Viewed together, these programs reinforce a sense that while TV remains fascinated with history, the assumption lingers that straightforward presentations of such fare won’t appeal to the demographics that advertisers covet. Small wonder that History has been on the leading edge of those cable networks that feel compelled to stretch confining brands that are deemed too stodgy in an effort to reel in younger viewers.

In that vein, documentarians are warily looking for the next shoe to drop at National Geographic Channel under the control of Fox, in the wake of layoffs that included reported cuts in the department responsible for maintaining the network’s editorial standards.

Even “The Day Hitler Died,” produced for Smithsonian and ITV, makes somewhat unnecessary use of subtle reenactments to augment its archival footage. Then again, that’s a relatively modest device compared to the hybrid genre of mixing extensive dramatic recreations with experts, a style championed by Stephen David Entertainment on projects like History’s “The World Wars” and AMC’s “The Making of the Mob,” which might as well be called “’Boardwalk Empire’ On a Budget.”

Small wonder that more sober presentations of history have largely been confined to territory that lives beyond the tyranny associated with advertising, from HBO’s documentaries to the rarefied air of Ken Burns’ PBS productions. Then again, fretting about those declining standards seems almost quaint, given how far the scale has slid.

Despite the explosion of programming options, historical fare faces considerable pressure to make noise and get noticed, even if that means bastardizing topics that call for a more delicate approach. That explains something like “Hunting Hitler,” and means pushing the boundaries not only in how material is presented but the sort of outlandish claims that are advanced, under the heading “Could this be true?”

In the FXX comedy “Man Seeking Woman,” the mopey, love-struck protagonist is prone to bizarre flights of fancy, such as his understandable horror upon learning that his ex-girlfriend is dating Hitler. Yes, actually Hitler. Nobody else appears to mind much, despite the couple’s vast age gap (she’s in her 20s; he’s 136).

Granted, some find such Hitler-related humor to be in questionable taste, but that tongue-in-cheek treatment seems preferable to something like “Hunting Hitler,” which figuratively digs him up in a transparent pursuit of ratings. Put another way, going to the Hitler well too often brings to mind something Jon Stewart said back in his “Daily Show” days, in a piece that showcased politicians bandying about comparisons to Hitler or Nazis too freely: “Please stop calling people Hitler when you disagree with them. It demeans you. It demeans your opponent. And to be honest, it demeans Hitler.”


More TV

  • BBC Studios Names Anna Cronin Digital

    BBC Studios Names Anna Cronin Digital Content Director (EXCLUSIVE)

    Anna Cronin has been upped to director of digital content at BBC Studios, a new role at the production and distribution arm of the U.K. pubcaster. The position is within BBC Studios’ content partnerships division, which oversees the company’s programming and IP partnerships. Cronin will work with U.K. and international partners, and notably those in [...]

  • HBO Europe,The Mediapro Studio Lacoproductora Team

    HBO Europe, The Mediapro Studio, Lacoproductora Team On Comedy Series 'Whatever'

    MADRID — HBO Europe is adding to its growing Spanish slate with “Por H o por B,” a comedy series original produced by Globomedia, part of TV giant The Mediapro Studio and new Madrid-based company Lacoproductora. Written and directed by Manuela Burló Moreno, the 10-episode half-hour takes the characters from her Goya-nominated short film “Pipas,” [...]

  • Zombie Comedy ‘Zomboat!’ Sets Sail for

    Zombie Comedy ‘Zomboat!’ Sets Sail for ITV and Hulu

    The zombie apocalypse is coming to the U.K. and will be seen on British and U.S. TV after ITV and Hulu greenlit “Zomboat!” The upcoming comedy will star Leah Brotherhead (“White Gold”), Hamza Jeetooa (“Doctor Who”), Ryan McKen (“White Dragon”), and Cara Theobold (“Downton Abbey”). It will bow on the ITV2 channel this fall and [...]

  • Busy Philipps

    ACLU, Busy Philipps Take on Abortion Bans With #YouKnowMe Ad Campaign

    In the wake of revealing to “Busy Tonight” viewers that she had had an abortion — and creating the #YouKnowMe hashtag on social media — Busy Philipps is teaming up with the ACLU on a “You Know Me” ad campaign meant to rebut recent legislation in several states that restrict access to abortion. “You know [...]


    TV Review: ABC's Live 'All in the Family' and 'The Jeffersons'

    In retrospect, it was only a matter of time before reboot and revival fever manifested as verbatim repeats — but if TV’s gonna go there, bringing back eerily timely shows like “All in the Family” and “The Jeffersons” is the way to do it. That Norman Lear’s comedies are timely, or at least prescient, is [...]

  • WGA Agents Packaging Fight Placeholder

    Judge in Writers Guild Suit Against Agencies Replaced Again

    Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Elaine W. Mandel has replaced Craig D. Karlan to handle the Writers Guild of America’s lawsuit against Hollywood’s four major talent agencies. Mandel was appointed Wednesday. She is the third judge assigned to the case, which was filed April 17 by the WGA against CAA, WME, UTA and ICM Partners [...]

  • Andy Cohen Desperate Housewives E

    TV News Roundup: Bravo Announces First Ever BravoCon

    In today’s roundup, Bravo announces its first ever BravoCon and the trailer for the fourth season of “Queen Sugar” dropped.  DATES The buddy comedy “Partners in Wine,” starring Lauren White and Jasmine Curry, will be available for streaming on Amazon Tuesday, May 28. It follows best friends Mia and Anne, who support, challenge, and judge [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content