Dr. Oz Attacks Critics in Sweeps-Timed Episode

Dr. Mehmet Oz isn’t a journalist. But his response to 10 doctors who have lobbied Columbia University to drop him from its staff didn’t come close to passing any test of basic fairness.

If Oz wanted to deflate the image that he is now more of a TV personality than a physician, the timing of the presentation – which took up the first half of his program Thursday – was also suspect. Specifically, this news-making hour was scheduled to coincide with the start of the May rating sweeps, which – even in the fading world of daytime TV – still means something to stations that carry his program, and thus felt conspicuously designed to focus attention on the show.

Labeled a “Dr. Oz Exclusive,” the hour opened with an extended taped piece that sought to impugn the motives of those who had signed the letter. Oz suggested that the central issue was his support of labeling genetically modified foods, and that the doctors involved were in the pockets of that industry, benefiting from “personal financial gain” by publicly criticizing him.

For those new to this controversy, it’s worth noting that Oz’s endorsement of miraculous weight-loss aids previously led to him being invited to testify before Congress regarding “quack treatments.” Yet he stressed the latest criticism was wholly unrelated to that matter, and that he has ceased touting such products.

In the letter sent to Columbia, the doctors cited Oz’s “disdain for science and for evidence-based medicine, as well as baseless and relentless opposition to the genetic engineering of food crops.”

Oz suggested the timing of those assertions had to do with legislation that would relax labeling on genetically modified organisms, or GMOs, enlisting a representative from the Environmental Working Group to buttress his point.

“Who should you believe? You be the judge,” said the reporter who prepared the opening segment.

Yet to “judge,” in the most common use of the term, would require the presentation of evidence on both sides. Notably, there was no indication any effort had been made to provide Oz’s critics with an opportunity to respond or rebut his claims. And while nobody would confuse “The Dr. Oz Show” with “60 Minutes,” the one-sided nature of the argument at the very least should have left viewers wondering exactly where the truth lies.

Not that this dust-up promises to damage Dr. Oz among his fans and regular viewers, although it does seem likely to raise questions about his brand among those casually acquainted with his program. Even so, he cast this as a free speech issue, stating that he would not be silenced in his commitment to provide information to consumers. Oz also blamed the media — some of which has been highly critical — for not being more skeptical in its reporting on the letter.

Clearly, this story isn’t over, but based on the “shoot the messenger” approach and tone of Thursday’s episode, “The Dr. Oz Show” won’t be the place where the issue is resolved. Then again, Oz’s original champion, Oprah Winfrey, was periodically drawn into controversies over products, causes and authors she endorsed, and all she has to show for it is a huge bank account – and her OWN network.

More TV

  • Al Burton

    Al Burton, 'Jeffersons' and 'Diff’rent Strokes' Producer, Dies at 91

    Television producer and executive Al Burton, known for his work on “The Jeffersons” and “Diff’rent Strokes,” died Tuesday at his home in San Mateo, California. He was 91. Burton leaves behind a six-decade legacy of hit television shows that also included “One Day at a Time,” “Silver Spoons,” “Square Pegs” and “Facts of Life.” However, long [...]

  • Dwyane Wade Sets Multi-Year Development Deal

    Dwyane Wade Sets Multi-Year Development Deal at WarnerMedia

    Dwayne Wade is bouncing his way into WarnerMedia’s court. The retired NBA All Star has signed a multi-faceted, multi-year deal with the company, including a development deal via his 59th & Prairie Entertainment production banner. Part of the deal sees Wade sign on as a commentator at Turner Sports. He is set to make appearances [...]

  • Katie Couric Sheryl Sandberg

    Katie Couric Steamrolls Sheryl Sandberg in Roving Vanity Fair Summit Interview

    Sending a jolt through a luxurious and excessively polite afternoon in Beverly Hills, veteran journalist Katie Couric delivered a relentless series of hardball questions to Facebook chief operating officer Sheryl Sandberg on Tuesday. Speaking in conversation at the sixth annual Vanity Fair New Establishment summit at the Wallis Annenberg Center for the Performing Arts, Couric’s [...]

  • EVIL is a psychological mystery that

    CBS Renews 'Evil,' Orders Full Seasons of Four Other Freshman Shows

    CBS is doubling down on all its new shows. The network has renewed “Evil” for a second season, and handed out full-season orders to its other four freshman series, namely “All Rise,” “Carol’s Second Act,” “The Unicorn,” and “Bob Hearts Abishola.” “Evil” is set to conclude its 13-episode first season (creators Michelle and Robert King [...]

  • Jamie Lee Curtis

    Jamie Lee Curtis to Produce Military Drama With Put Pilot Order at Fox

    Jamie Lee Curtis is teaming up with April Fitzsimmons and Berlanti Productions for a drama project that has received a put pilot order at Fox. Titled “Chain of Command,” the one-hour project follows a young Air Force investigator with radical crime-solving methodology who returns to her hometown to join a military task force that doesn’t [...]

  • Michael MannLACMA: Art and Film Gala,

    TV News Roundup: Michael Mann to Direct and Executive Produce HBO Max's 'Tokyo Vice'

    In today’s TV news roundup, HBO Max names MIchael Mann as a director and executive producer of “Tokyo Vice” and Chip and Joanna Gaines announce the first original series coming to the couple’s Magnolia Network. DATES Netflix announced a six-episode docuseries centered on Nasty Cherry, the latest all-female group signed to Charli XCX’s label will [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content