You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

‘Broadchurch’ Finale Exposes Challenge Season 2 Presented (SPOILERS)

After a lukewarm critical reception in the U.K., “Broadchurch” has finished its second season, with a third already in the planning stages. Yet the griping about the just-concluded arc would seem to say more about the limitations of extending this sort of concept than the execution itself.

The BBC America show’s considerable popularity in the U.K. especially, coupled with a rapturous critical response, made a second season an inevitability. The problem was that the story had come to something approaching a logical and satisfying conclusion, with a solution to the central mystery in the case of who had killed a young boy, triggering shock waves across the small town in which he lived.

Season two sought to address that challenge by extending the first story – through a bitter trial of the killer, which reopened still-fresh wounds – and introducing a second plot, with the tormented inspector Alec Hardy (David Tennant) revisiting an old unsolved case in which he was convinced the perpetrator had gone free.

The series certainly loaded up in terms of casting this time around, with Charlotte Rampling and Marianne Jean-Baptiste as the dueling barristers in the court case – the former her rival’s mentor – while James D’Arcy and Eve Myles played the central couple in the long-simmering murder mystery, which involved the disappearance of two young girls.

As with the first “Broadchurch,” however, the resolution – emotionally shattering as it was in laying the crime on the doorstep of one of the detectives, Ellie Miller (the brilliant Olivia Colman) – felt secondary to the journey and the various red herrings sprinkled along the way. As for the trial, much of the kick for an American audience came from differences in the rules of evidence and judicial discretion in reaching a verdict, while the outcome (and SPOILER ALERT if you haven’t watched) proved sobering but somewhat anticlimactic.

Ultimately, the boy’s killer, Joe Miller (Matthew Gravelle), walked free, but not without consequences, as the town essentially orchestrated an old-fashioned banishing. And if that didn’t bring closure to the boy’s devastated family, it at least spared them from the constant reminder of this miscarriage of justice – or worse, doing something to settle accounts and seek justice on their own that only would have escalated the tragedy.

Taking a (pardon the expression) broader view, “Broadchurch’s” second season underscores the challenge that goes with producing limited series that tell self-contained stories and, in success, introduces the daunting question of how to then keep the franchise alive. In this case, creator Chris Chibnall chose to try splitting the difference between starting over (a la the second seasons of “True Detective” and “Fargo”) and concocting new wrinkles to keep the existing cast together, even if it would have been just as logical for Hardy and Miller (or as he called her, “Miiiiiiiill-er!”) to simply go their separate ways.

In the final analysis, there was still enough to recommend season two to make it enjoyable and worthwhile – certainly compared with the ill-advised U.S. version, “Gracepoint,” which aired between these seasons – although watching it has also somewhat dampened enthusiasm for a third installment. With the benefit of hindsight, the second-guessing that surrounded this second iteration perhaps highlights just how hard it is to thread the needle between returning to “Broadchurch,” the place and those who inhabit it, as opposed to just “Broadchurch” the state of mind.

More TV

  • How the 'Rich Eisen Show' Mixes

    How the 'Rich Eisen Show' Mixes Sports and Showbiz in an Entertaining Mix

    Walking through the El Segundo studio where veteran sportscaster Rich Eisen tapes his daily “Rich Eisen Show,” the sheer density of sports memorabilia is overwhelming — everything from game balls to jerseys, gear, autographs and uncountable photos are crammed onto every inch of wall and desk space. But step into Eisen’s dressing room, and the [...]

  • Whiskey Tango Cavalier

    TV Review: 'Whiskey Cavalier'

    The crux of “Whiskey Cavalier” can be found right in its protagonist’s name. “Will Chase” is a purposefully ridiculous wink of a name that tries to be both debonair and very silly all at once, just like the FBI agent (played by Scott Foley) to which it belongs. This isn’t a regular spy drama, “Whiskey [...]

  • Brody Stevens Dead

    Comedian Brody Stevens Dies at 48

    Prominent Los Angeles comedian Brody Stevens died Friday in Los Angeles, Variety has confirmed. He was 48. “Brody was an inspiring voice who was a friend to many in the comedy community,” Stevens’ reps said in a statement. “He pushed creative boundaries and his passion for his work and his love of baseball were contagious. [...]

  • Editorial use onlyMandatory Credit: Photo by

    Malik Yoba to Reprise Role in 'New York Undercover' Reboot at ABC

    Malik Yoba, who starred as Detective J.C. Williams in the 90s show “New York Undercover,” is set to reprise the role in the ABC reboot, sources tell Variety. Picking up 20 years after the end of the original series, “New York Undercover” will follow detectives Nat Gilmore and Melissa Ortiz as they investigate the city’s [...]

  • Chris Burrous dead KTLA anchor

    KTLA Anchor Chris Burrous' Cause of Death Released

    An investigative report on KTLA anchor Chris Burrous has determined that his cause of death was attributed to methamphetamine toxicity, according to the Los Angeles County Coroner’s Office. Burrous, 43, was found unconscious at a motel in Glendale, Calif on December 27, and later died at the hospital. The death has been ruled as accidental. [...]

  • Editorial use only. No book cover

    'Crazy Rich Asians,' 'Late Show With Stephen Colbert' Win Publicity Campaign Awards

    Hollywood publicists have selected “Crazy Rich Asians” as the top movie publicity campaign for 2018 and “The Late Show With Stephen Colbert” as the best television campaign. Warner Bros.’ “Crazy Rich Asians” topped the campaigns for Disney’s “Black Panther,” Fox’s “Bohemian Rhapsody,” Paramount’s “A Quiet Place,” Sony’s “Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse,” and Universal’s “Halloween” for [...]

  • THE MASKED SINGER: Rabbit in the

    Live+3 Ratings for Week of Feb. 11: 'Masked Singer' Easily Tops Competition

    Fox’s “The Masked Singer” was the highest-rated broadcast show of the week in both Live+Same Day and Live+3. For the week of Feb. 11, the unscripted singing competition series went from a 2.4 rating in adults 18-49 to a 3.4, a rise of 42%. In total viewers, the show went from 7.8 million viewers to [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content