×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

‘Broadchurch’ Finale Exposes Challenge Season 2 Presented (SPOILERS)

After a lukewarm critical reception in the U.K., “Broadchurch” has finished its second season, with a third already in the planning stages. Yet the griping about the just-concluded arc would seem to say more about the limitations of extending this sort of concept than the execution itself.

The BBC America show’s considerable popularity in the U.K. especially, coupled with a rapturous critical response, made a second season an inevitability. The problem was that the story had come to something approaching a logical and satisfying conclusion, with a solution to the central mystery in the case of who had killed a young boy, triggering shock waves across the small town in which he lived.

Season two sought to address that challenge by extending the first story – through a bitter trial of the killer, which reopened still-fresh wounds – and introducing a second plot, with the tormented inspector Alec Hardy (David Tennant) revisiting an old unsolved case in which he was convinced the perpetrator had gone free.

The series certainly loaded up in terms of casting this time around, with Charlotte Rampling and Marianne Jean-Baptiste as the dueling barristers in the court case – the former her rival’s mentor – while James D’Arcy and Eve Myles played the central couple in the long-simmering murder mystery, which involved the disappearance of two young girls.

As with the first “Broadchurch,” however, the resolution – emotionally shattering as it was in laying the crime on the doorstep of one of the detectives, Ellie Miller (the brilliant Olivia Colman) – felt secondary to the journey and the various red herrings sprinkled along the way. As for the trial, much of the kick for an American audience came from differences in the rules of evidence and judicial discretion in reaching a verdict, while the outcome (and SPOILER ALERT if you haven’t watched) proved sobering but somewhat anticlimactic.

Ultimately, the boy’s killer, Joe Miller (Matthew Gravelle), walked free, but not without consequences, as the town essentially orchestrated an old-fashioned banishing. And if that didn’t bring closure to the boy’s devastated family, it at least spared them from the constant reminder of this miscarriage of justice – or worse, doing something to settle accounts and seek justice on their own that only would have escalated the tragedy.

Taking a (pardon the expression) broader view, “Broadchurch’s” second season underscores the challenge that goes with producing limited series that tell self-contained stories and, in success, introduces the daunting question of how to then keep the franchise alive. In this case, creator Chris Chibnall chose to try splitting the difference between starting over (a la the second seasons of “True Detective” and “Fargo”) and concocting new wrinkles to keep the existing cast together, even if it would have been just as logical for Hardy and Miller (or as he called her, “Miiiiiiiill-er!”) to simply go their separate ways.

In the final analysis, there was still enough to recommend season two to make it enjoyable and worthwhile – certainly compared with the ill-advised U.S. version, “Gracepoint,” which aired between these seasons – although watching it has also somewhat dampened enthusiasm for a third installment. With the benefit of hindsight, the second-guessing that surrounded this second iteration perhaps highlights just how hard it is to thread the needle between returning to “Broadchurch,” the place and those who inhabit it, as opposed to just “Broadchurch” the state of mind.

More TV

  • cap 08 cena 31 - Bastidor

    Globoplay’s ‘Aruanas’ Amazon Rainforest Series Bows in 150 Countries

    Globoplay, the streaming platform of Brazilian media giant Globo, is set to bow one of its most ambitious fictional series to date, “Aruanas” (“Sentinels of Nature”). The new series premieres worldwide July 2 on Vimeo-powered platform araunas.tv in more than 150 countries with subtitles in 11 languages: English, Spanish, French, Italian, German, Dutch, Russian, Arabic, Hindi, Turkish [...]

  • Spain Mediapro Studio Lola Flores Bioseries

    Spain's The Mediapro Studio Develops Bioseries on Flamenco Matriarch Lola Flores

    Spain’s The Mediapro Studio, the recently-launched content production-distribution giant, has teamed with Argentine-based company Non Stop TV to develop a bioseries on Lola Flores, the Spanish flamenco matriarch. The project is backed by The Flores Family, with Lolita and Rosario Flores, Lola Flores daughters, attached as executive producers, alongside Mariola Orellana. The series will recreate [...]

  • Mark-Paul GosselaarFOX 'The Passage' TV show

    'Mixed-ish' at ABC Adds Mark-Paul Gosselaar in Recasting

    Mark-Paul Gosselaar has boarded the upcoming ABC comedy “Mixed-ish.” “Mixed-ish,” a spinoff of “Black-ish,” focuses on the experience of Tracee Ellis Ross’s character, Rainbow Johnson, growing up in a mixed-race family in the ‘80s. Gosselaar will play the role of Bow’s father, taking over from Anders Holm, who played the role in the original pilot. [...]

  • Greg Berlanti

    Greg Berlanti on Why Movies Are Lagging Behind TV in LGBTQ Representation

    Greg Berlanti is television’s most prolific producer. With a record-breaking 18 series from his production company greenlit for the 2019-2020 season, the openly gay Berlanti is using his power to ensure the LGBTQ community is reflected on the small screen — both in front of and behind the camera. From casting the first transgender superhero [...]

  • Legion

    How Production Designer Marco Niro Created a Visual Climax for FX's ‘Legion’

    FX’s “Legion” has always drawn inspiration not only from the Marvel “X-Men” comics on which it is based, but also from the weirder corners of pop culture. When creator Noah Hawley cast “Downton Abbey” star Dan Stevens as the lead — David Haller, a mutant whose telepathic powers have been misdiagnosed as mental illness — [...]

  • DEAR WHITE PEOPLE

    TV News Roundup: Netflix Sets 'Dear White People' Season 3 Premiere Date

    In today’s TV roundup, “Dear White People” sets an August 2 premiere and Showtime acquires the six-episode comedy series “Back to Life.” DATES “Dear White People” will return for its third season on August 2. The news was announced in a comedic sketch posted to Netflix‘s Youtube channel, in which the series’ cast members debate [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content