Emmys: Andy Samberg Gets Boxed in by Host Role

Andy Samberg said in advance that he wouldn’t read reviews of his Emmy Awards performance. With the benefit of hindsight, that’s probably not a bad idea – not because the “Brooklyn Nine-Nine” star was bad, exactly, but merely because he felt somewhat miscast for this role, a preconception that was borne out as the night dragged on.

Samberg certainly started on an energetic note, but that was almost a foregone conclusion. A taped song bit in which he locked himself away to watch every show on television (even “Castle”) capitalized on his “Saturday Night Live”-honed strengths and the digital shorts with which he’s been associated. As the number finished, he was prompted by Bob Odenkirk to go out and tell some “culturally relevant but not too edgy jokes.”

Standup, however, isn’t necessarily Samberg’s foremost skill, as anyone who saw him at Fox’s upfront presentation might have concluded. And while his self-consciously exaggerated, wildly sunny disposition came across well enough, the mix of topical jokes about presidential candidates Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders, or Kim Davis, the Kentucky clerk who has refused to sanction gay marriages, felt somewhat shoehorned in alongside the TV-specific material.

What mostly came across, gradually, was that Samberg’s approach just didn’t wear especially well. He plays better in bite-sized bits, and his sprightly setup/joke rhythms yielded diminishing returns over the course of the evening. That somewhat undercut, say, a funny sight gag – with him cozying up to an over-sized Emmy statue, in what he called an homage to “Girls” – by following it with a flat tribute to “SNL” patriarch Lorne Michaels that paid off with giving him a “World’s Best Boss” mug.

Similarly, a canned sketch that came toward the midway point spoofing the “Mad Men” finale felt unnecessary. The same goes for a let’s-see-what’s-happening-on-the-red-carpet gag that involved Tony Hale and Tatiana Maslany.

Of course, the host’s presence is invariably less than meets the eye. At almost every awards presentation, hosts disappear for stretches as the show gets into the meat of the ceremony. Yet even when Samberg popped up, there was seldom a sense of spontaneity in many of his gags. (A shout out to Kyle Chandler, after Jon Hamm won, was a rare exception.)

The presenter introductions, always a challenge, were somehow more lame than usual. As for lengthier moments, it sometimes gave the impression of material that could have gone into the opening monologue simply being tossed in to fill time, which was clearly becoming precious as more of the acceptance speeches ran long.

The emphasis on comedy was also such that the telecast kept bringing people to the stage that frankly might have been better suited to this particular task, including several of those late-night hosts (as well as HBO’s John Oliver) who inevitably get the call when their network broadcasts the Emmys.

Samberg was a relatively modest part of what is always, by simple construction, a pretty long sit. But for anyone who hoped the guy behind “Dick in a Box” would somehow manage to shake up the Emmys, the host instead found himself pretty well boxed in.

More TV

  • The Ultimate Guide to 2019 Comic-Con

    The Ultimate Guide to 2019 Comic-Con Parties and Activations

    Hollywood is heading down the California coast to San Diego because It’s time for 2019 Comic-Con International. The annual cosplay celebration officially kicks off tomorrow, July 18, with a preview happening tonight. Here, Variety gives you a guide to this year’s parties and activations. Make sure to check back for updates. Wednesday, July 17Amazon Prime [...]

  • Ken Ehrlich Jane Ortner Education Award,

    Grammy Awards Producer Shuffle: Ben Winston to Take Over From Ken Ehrlich in 2021

    As Variety reported in December, Ben Winston will take the reins of the Grammy Awards as executive producer in 2021 after longtime telecast leader Ken Ehrlich completes his 40th ceremony next year. Winston has become a prolific producer for CBS and other outlets since he moved to the U.S. nearly five years ago to launch [...]

  • Sarah Wright Takes Charge of Sky

    Sarah Wright Takes Charge of Sky Cinema After Management Shuffle

    Sarah Wright, Sky’s top acquisitions exec, will take on responsibility for Sky Cinema after a management shuffle at the pay-TV giant. Wright fills a role vacated by Ian Lewis, who recently left Sky after 20 years. He was one of several Sky staffers to leave after its takeover by Comcast. As director of Sky Cinema [...]

  • Jodi Long Running for SAG-AFTRA Secretary-Treasurer

    Jodi Long Running for SAG-AFTRA Secretary-Treasurer on Matthew Modine Slate

    Veteran actress and union activist Jodi Long is running for secretary-treasurer of SAG-AFTRA as a member of Matthew Modine’s progressive Membership First slate. She is facing Camryn Manheim, who announced her candidacy on July 9 as part of the Unite for Strength slate for the re-election of union president Gabrielle Carteris. Unite for Strength and United [...]

  • BAFTA Backs BIFA’s Unconscious-Bias Training for

    BIFA’s Unconscious-Bias Training Rolls Out to BAFTA Voters, Wider Industry (EXCLUSIVE)

    The British Independent Film Awards is opening up its unconscious-bias training to BAFTA voters and, more widely, to anyone who judges the work of others in the film and TV business in the U.K. With the makeup of award-nominee and -winner lists under close scrutiny, BIFA introduced its unconscious-bias training last year. Its voters, jurors, [...]

  • New U.K. Film and TV Studio

    New U.K. Film and TV Studio Proposed for Leeds, in Northern England

    With studio space in high demand, a sizable new film and TV complex has been proposed for Leeds, the city in northern England that is fast becoming a major U.K. media hub outside of London. It has already been selected as the base for Channel 4’s new national headquarters, and companies such as pay-TV giant [...]

  • Jody Madden Replaces Craig Rodgerson as

    Jody Madden Replaces Craig Rodgerson as CEO of VFX Firm Foundry

    Jody Madden has been upped to CEO at U.K.-based VFX outfit Foundry. She steps up fromchief product officer and replaces Craig Rodgerson, who joined the company in late 2017. Foundry was bought by U.S. tech firm Roper Technologies earlier this year in a £410 million ($509 million) deal. The London-based business provides software and technology [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content