As TV Landscape Becomes More Complex, Emmy Nominations’ Snubs Come With the Territory

Winston Churchill famously said, “Democracy is the worst form of government except all the others that have been tried.” And the Emmys might very well be the worst TV awards ever devised, except perhaps for the rest of them.

Nominations for the 67th annual Emmy Awards surely had something to offend everyone. The outrages ranged from legitimately puzzling oversights (CW’s “Jane the Virgin” and “The Affair’s” Ruth Wilson among them) to those where the righteous fury probably had as much to do with pumping up Web traffic (“Empire” snubbed! “Scandal” slighted!) as anything else.

But honestly, what would those critics prefer? The Golden Globes, an organization with a small and shadowy body of voters, and a colorfully speckled history? Granted, the Emmys have inherent biases against genre shows, but the Globes have their own unique quirks, including an inordinate penchant for European talent and stars with high Q scores.

Even setting those considerations aside, the Hollywood Foreign Press Assn. thinks so little of television that it lumps every actor who isn’t a lead into a “supporting” category that encompasses series, movies and miniseries. Last year, that meant pitting performers from “American Horror Story,” “Downton Abbey,” “Orange Is the New Black,” “True Detective” and the sitcom “Mom” against each other on one side, and a miniseries, two dramas and movie on the other.

Nobody’s immune from awards-show screwups, or at least oddities. Consider the Television Critics Assn. — a group that, one would think, has a pretty good handle on the medium. Yet its nominations awkwardly tossed in HBO’s docuseries “The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst” among the movies, miniseries and specials, alongside three scripted miniseries and HBO’s “Bessie.”

As for the Screen Actors Guild Awards, its coveted honor for ensemble casts seemed influenced heavily by sheer size in honoring “Downton Abbey” and “Orange Is the New Black” – the latter a program that the Emmys have reclassified (correctly, many would argue) as a drama.

This isn’t intended to pick on other awards shows, but merely to expose the unavoidable imperfections that are part of this far-from-scientific process, one increasingly complicated by the encroachment of new players, with Netflix and now Amazon making significant inroads. And while that might be nettlesome to fans — whose ardor for individual properties, fueled and reinforced by social media, has risen along with the medium’s storytelling ambitions — it has traditionally gone down a bit easier within the industry itself, where enduring such compromises are a daily part of life.

For an analogous problem, consider the Nielsen ratings. Everyone knows that Nielsen’s methodology is a blunt instrument for measuring something as complex as the myriad ways in which people consume television content. Yet periodic efforts to replace or overhaul the existing system have invariably led back to merely tweaks intended to improve it.

The same mentality has largely applied to the Emmys. Each year, a committee meets after the awards to engage in what amounts to another round of Monday-morning quarterbacking. Changes are regularly proposed to address perceived flaws, and while that’s never enough to fix everything that ails the voting, the organization occasionally takes a few steps in the right direction.

This year, that meant seeking to curb category-shopping by producers (an area where the organization subsequently backed down, granting most high-profile appeals, except “Orange”), and creating a “limited series” award. The latter supplanted the slightly outdated “miniseries” designation, and yielded as strong a roster of contenders as this year’s awards has produced, including ABC’s “American Crime,” HBO’s “Olive Kitteridge” and PBS’ “Wolf Hall.”

Ultimately, the Emmys and the aforementioned alternative awards might be ill equipped to wrangle the ungainly and growing beast that is “television” into anything that resembles a completely satisfying award experience. They are, after all, chasing a moving target. Yet if it’s any consolation, college football still hasn’t gained a firm handle on how to anoint a national champion, and aside from providing talking heads ample fodder over which to argue, that’s seemingly done nothing to dim the sport’s popularity.

In anonymous comments — or on Websites eager to gin up page views — everything sounds like the end of the world. Yet at the risk of diminishing something that is important to a great many people (and comes with cash incentives for certain publicists), when the debate involves a subjective choice between two actresses who are almost equally deserving, only a bit of perspective is required to recognize what separates a true injustice from an oversight that fails to adequately measure blood, sweat, toil and tears.

More TV

  • Project Blue Book

    Mipcom Roundup: A+E Sells, Ovation Buys, Fremantle Dating Format Takes Off

    In Variety’s second Mipcom roundup Ovation announces a raft of series and TV movie pickups, Nelson Mandela’s autobiographical recordings will be developed into a docuseries by Zig Zag and Hipster Media, A+E sells “Project Blue Book” to Viasat World and RTL, All The Kids and El Cañonazo are set to team in Spain on new formats; “Property [...]

  • La jauría

    Lucia Puenzo Talks Fabula-Fremantle’s ‘The Pack’ - ‘La Jauria’

    CANNES —   Produced by Chile’s Fabula, headed by Pablo and Juan de Dios Larraín, and Fremantle, and showrun by Lucía Puenzo (“The German Doctor”), “La Jauria” (The Pack) cuts excruciatingly to the chase. In its very first scene, a teen girl student sits down, back to the wall, before her male drama teacher who [...]

  • Stan Lee's Kindergarten Superhero

    Alibaba's Youku Boards 'Stan Lee’s Superhero Kindergarten' With Arnold Schwarzenegger

    Youku, the video streaming platform of Alibaba Group, has signed a deal with Genius Brands International to co-produce “Stan Lee’s Superhero Kindergarten,” an animated series starring and executive produced by Arnold Schwarzenegger. The pact marks significant step in Alibaba/Youku building its footprint in the U.S. Aimed at preschoolers, the comedy adventure series “Stan Lee’s Superhero [...]

  • Michael Spierig, Peter Spierig'Jigsaw' film premiere,

    AGC Television Secures Spierig Brothers for ‘Ben Walker’ Series Adaptation

    Filmmaking brothers Michael and Peter Spierig have boarded the supernatural thriller series adaptation of the popular literary “Ben Walker” franchise, developed by Stuart Ford’s AGC Television. Rob Carlson at UTA negotiated the deal on behalf of the Spierig Brothers with AGC Television President Lourdes Diaz, AGC’s VP of Legal & Business Affairs Anant Tamirisa, and [...]

  • Trauma French TV Series

    French TV Series to Watch at Mipcom

    Streaming services are boosting French TV production. Pascal Breton, whose Paris-based company Federation Entertainment co-produced “Marseille” and most recently “Marianne,” said the biggest benefit of streaming services, and Netflix in particular, is the way in which it has created a world audience for French shows. “Netflix amplifies the appeal of French shows abroad, and we [...]

  • Wild Bunch TV Boards RubyRock’s Feminist

    Wild Bunch TV Boards RubyRock’s Feminist Horror Anthology Series (EXCLUSIVE)

    Wild Bunch TV has joined “Her Horror,” the female-led anthology series from recently-minted drama shingle RubyRock Pictures and Clipper Media Capital. “Her Horror” is billed as a feminist anthology series that will examine the female experience through the prism of horror. Zoë Rocha, former COO of Stephen Fry’s Sprout Pictures and a business affairs exec [...]

  • Bear Grylls Teams With Banijay to

    Bear Grylls, Delbert Shoopman Team With Banijay to Launch The Natural Studios

    Bear Grylls, the face of survival and outdoor adventure television, and his longtime producing partner, Delbert Shoopman, have teamed with leading global production and distribution powerhouse Banijay Group to launch production company The Natural Studios, which will produce both non-scripted and scripted adventure content. The new company’s slate includes Emmy-nominated “Hostile Planet” (Nat Geo), “Eco-Challenge” [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content