×

Watch: Jon Stewart Skewers Media Hypocrisy In Brian Williams Coverage

No, Jon Stewart did not punt or “soft glove” covering the Brian Williams story, as it was suggested he might on Salon, citing his friendly relationship with the NBC News anchor. But the Comedy Central host did widen the lens and, as some other voices have, refract the pile-on over Williams’ inaccurate account back onto the media in general.

On Monday’s show — Stewart’s first since Williams pulled himself off the air, while NBC investigates the misleading claims he made regarding his reporting from Iraq — “The Daily Show” host labeled Williams’ differing versions of what happened “Infotainment Confusion Syndrome,” citing the conflicting roles Williams occupies as a celebrity, yukking it up with David Letterman, and a newsman.

The Daily Show
Get More: Daily Show Full Episodes,Indecision Political Humor,The Daily Show on Facebook

Spinning yarns in those talk settings, Stewart noted, stimulates the brain’s “applause center,” which might explain why a news account would get inflated and distorted in a more entertaining, self-aggrandizing way.

Notably, Stewart made no apologies for Williams (the piece was chyron-ed “Bri Wi Hot Spot”), who also was ribbed on Larry Wilmore’s companion Comedy Central half-hour and by Conan O’Brien (“Brian Williams won the Grammy for Best Spoken Word in the Fiction category. At least I think he did — that’s what he told me”). Bill O’Reilly also defended Williams on “Jimmy Kimmel Live.”

Still, it was Stewart who turned the discussion back upon those media outlets expressing righteous indignation about Williams’ transgressions, essentially asking where they were when so many dutifully repeated Bush administration spin during the run-up to invading Iraq. Or as Stewart put it, pointedly, referencing Williams, “Finally, someone is being held to account for misleading America about the Iraq war.”

Stewart’s clips included former New York Times editor Bill Keller and CNN’s Wolf Blitzer, both giving themselves passing grades for Iraq coverage in hindsight, with Blitzer suggesting that journalism is merely a first draft of history.

The media frenzy surrounding Williams has hardly subsided, but it has given way to additional reflection that goes beyond the particulars of this case. Some of that, admittedly, can sound naive, such as the New York Times’ David Brooks, citing the “barbaric” nature of the modern reaction to scandals; or National Journal’s Ron Fournier, who lamented the “charge of the bile brigade” unleashed in response to such stories before moving on to some new outrage. “My hope is that as the new platforms evolve, the public will adapt and technology will be used as it has so many times in the past: To educate and unite the masses,” Fournier wrote, overlooking that we’re still largely in the peasants-with-pitchforks phase.

Stewart could easily be accused of the same kind of idealism in trying to shift the focus off Williams, just a bit, to one of his favorite topics: journalism’s broader failings.

To some, attempting to turn the spotlight simply represents a means of defending Williams, but Stewart didn’t offer any alibi for the anchor. Instead, he seemed to be intent on injecting a level of perspective into the coverage that, frankly, remains one of the program’s invaluable strengths in these situations.

Because the truth is if media outlets want to fairly capture all the implications of the still-unfolding Williams story — beyond the specifics of whether the NBC News star has irrevocably damaged his career through an unnecessary lie — they’re going to need a bigger mirror.

More TV

  • Tony Romo

    CBS Sports Re-Signs Tony Romo in Deal Valued Around $17 Million Per Year

    CBS Sports signed prize football analyst Tony Romo to a new deal, a major step in parent company ViacomCBS’ efforts to strike a new rights pact with the National Football League as its current contract heads toward the end of its term. CBS Sports said the company had signed Romo, the former Dallas Cowboys quarterback [...]

  • WGA Agents Contract Tug of War

    Writers Guild Says It Helped Negotiate 100 Deals for Agent-Less Members

    The Writers Guild of America has asserted that it has assisted in negotiating more than 100 deals in recent months for members without agents. The missive from the WGA West board of directors comes nearly a year after the guild leaders ordered their 15,000 members to fire their agents if the agents had not agreed [...]

  • Hilary Duff

    Hilary Duff Asks Disney to Move 'Lizzie McGuire' Revival to Hulu

    Hilary Duff has posted a statement asking that the planned revival of “Lizzie McGuire” be moved from Disney Plus to Hulu. “I’d be doing a disservice to everyone by limiting the realities of a 30 year old’s journey to live under the ceiling of a PG rating,” Duff wrote on Instagram. “It’s important to me [...]

  • Tan France Jameela Jamil

    TV News Roundup: Tan France, Jameela Jamil Among OZY Fest Headliners

    In today’s TV news roundup, OZY Media announced Tan France, Jameela Jamil and others as headliners of OZY Fest, and Netflix dropped the official trailer of “On My Block” Season 3. DATES Disney Channel‘s second season of “Just Roll With It” will premiere on Sunday, March 15 at 8:45 p.m. The sitcom follows the Bennett-Blatt family [...]

  • Lorraine Toussaint

    Queen Latifah's 'Equalizer' Reboot Pilot at CBS Casts Lorraine Toussaint

    Lorraine Toussaint has joined the CBS’ reboot pilot for “The Equalizer,” Variety has learned. She joins previously announced series lead Queen Latifah and recently announced cast member Liza Lapira. In the reimagined version, Queen Latifah stars as Robyn McCall, an enigmatic figure who uses her extensive skills to help those with nowhere else to turn. Toussaint [...]

  • Ben Schnetzer

    'Y: The Last Man' Series at FX Casts Ben Schnetzer as Yorick

    Ben Schnetzer has stepped into the role of Yorick Brown in FX’s upcoming “Y: The Last Man” series, Variety has learned. He takes over the role from Barry Keoghan, who exited the series at the beginning of this month. The show is based on Brian K. Vaughan and Pia Guerra’s award-winning DC Comics graphic novel series [...]

  • Herb Dorfman Obit Dead

    Herb Dorfman, Orion Pictures Home Video Executive, Dies at 77

    Herb Dorfman, former Orion Pictures executive and a home video industry veteran, died Feb. 25 of complications from Parkinson’s disease and dementia. He was 77. Dorfman served as head of home entertainment for Orion Pictures from 1987 to late 1996. Orion was a prosperous independent studio in those days that turned out a steady stream [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content