New York Theater Review: ‘The Tempest’ With Sam Waterston

Sam Waterston, Francesca Carpanini, Chris Perfetti, Louis Cancelmi, Charles Parnell, Frank Harts, Rodney Richardson, Jesse Tyler Ferguson, Danny Mastrogiorgio.

“The Tempest” and Central Park were made for each other, so it must have taken a Herculean effort on the part of director Michael Greif to drain Shakespeare’s most mysterious play of all its magic in his current outing for Shakespeare in the Park. Despite some thunderous sound-and-light effects, this plodding production lacks the power of enchantment. And little wonder, since Sam Waterston’s terribly diminished Prospero has been denied all the accouterments of his high office. His magic wand is a skinny stick, his vast library of ancient tomes has been reduced to one old book, and his magician’s cloak looks like a torn bedsheet. 

Despite his worthy aspiration to tackle the formidable role of Shakespeare’s great necromancer, Waterston is doomed to play nice guys. He’s thoroughly likable at the end of the play, as Prospero the benevolent healer who frees his slaves, matches up the young lovers and repairs the broken lives of the lost sailors. But he’s less than believable as Prospero the raging master of the dark arts, who engineers the frightful storm at sea — the coup de theatre of designers Riccardo Hernandez (sets), David Lander (lighting), Acme Sound Partners and Jason Crystal (sound), and Matt Tierney (soundscapes) — that breaks up a mighty ship at sea and tosses the survivors onto the magician’s enchanted isle.

Aside from that opening spectacle, there’s little to tickle our fancy in this downbeat production.

A black metal catwalk and exposed lighting towers lend a cold, hard edge to the fecund island where Prospero fled to raise his daughter Miranda (Francesca Carpanini, fair of face, shrill of voice) after being rousted from his kingdom by his treacherous brother, Antonio (Cotter Smith). On this barren stage, there’s no sign of the great library that Prospero built to ease his exile and no sense of the mystical aura that enfolds the island.

Not even Ariel (Chris Perfetti), the true source of magic, is allowed to toss some fairy dust around. By some ill-conceived notion, this other-worldly spirit (inexplicably trussed up in leather bindings by costumer Emily Rebholz) is rendered as a grim and brooding soul who might be Caliban’s baby brother. The monstrous Caliban himself (“this thing of darkness I acknowledge mine,” as Prospero finally acknowledges) is appropriately fierce and frightening in Louis Cancelmi’s forceful perf. His brutish scenes with those creepy clowns Trinculo and Stephano (played, respectively, by Jesse Tyler Ferguson and Danny Mastrogiorgio, both excellent) are as dark as the comedy gets in this play.

But everything about this earthbound production, from the stiff military garb of the royal visitors to the flat cyclorama of a raging sea, is presented in such literal terms that even the lyricism of the language is dashed upon the rocks and left to drown.

New York Theater Review: 'The Tempest' With Sam Waterston

Delacorte Theater; 1800 seats; free. Opened June 16, 2015. Reviewed June 11. Running time: TWO HOURS, 45 MIN.

Production: A presentation by the Public Theater, in cooperation with the City of New York, of a Shakespeare in the Park production of a play in two acts by William Shakespeare.

Creative: Directed by Michael Greif. Sets, Riccardo Hernandez; costumes, Emily Rebholz; lighting, David Lander; sound, Acme Sound Partners & Jason Crystal; soundscapes, Matt Tierney; hair & makeup, J. Jared Janas; music, Michael Friedman; choreography, Denis Jones; production stage manager, Michael McGoff.

Cast: Sam Waterston, Francesca Carpanini, Chris Perfetti, Louis Cancelmi, Charles Parnell, Frank Harts, Rodney Richardson, Jesse Tyler Ferguson, Danny Mastrogiorgio.

More Legit

  • The dark Manhatten skyline, seen from

    StubHub Refunds $500,000 to Customers Shut Out by New York Blackout

    Saturday’s blackout in New York had an outsized effect on the city’s nightlife, with Madison Square Garden and the entire Broadway district seeing multiple shows cancelled due to the the power outage. As a result, StubHub has refunded more than $500,000 worth of tickets for cancelled events. According to a statement from the company, the StubHub [...]

  • Warner Music Group Logo

    Warner Music Acquires Musical Theater Indie First Night Records

    Warner Music Group has acquired First Night Record, an independent record label for West End and Broadway musical theatre cast recordings. The company will be overseen by WMG’s Arts Music Division, led by President Kevin Gore. First Night co-founder John Craig will join the Arts Music team under a multi-year consulting agreement to identify and record musical theatre productions in [...]

  • Broadway

    Broadway Back In Biz After Power Outage Ends

    The bright lights of Broadway were back on Sunday morning as midtown Manhattan recovered from a power outage that lasted nearly seven hours in some areas. Social media was full of examples of how New Yorkers rose to the occasion after the power went out on a hot Saturday night shortly before 7 p.m. ET. [...]

  • The dark Manhatten skyline, seen from

    Power Restored in New York City After Massive Outage Hits Broadway

    UPDATED: Power has gradually been restored to Midtown Manhattan and the theater district after what New York City officials described as a rolling blackout that darkened Times Square and other high-traffic areas on Saturday night. Officials said all power should be restored to the 73,000 customers affected by the outage by midnight ET. Local media [...]

  • Slave Play

    Controversial 'Slave Play' Is Broadway Bound

    “Slave Play,” a controversial drama that examined race and sexuality, is moving to Broadway for a limited run. Written by theatrical wunderkind Jeremy O. Harris, “Slave Play” was a sensation when it ran at the New York Theatre Workshop, drawing such bold-faced names as Madonna, Scarlett Johansson, and Tony Kushner. The show will debut at [...]

  • Mary Said What She Said

    Critic's Notebook: Seeing Isabelle Huppert and Dimitris Papaioannou in Paris

    “Do you miss Paris?” I get that question a lot, but never know what to say. How could I not? The two years I spent in that splendid city covering international cinema for Variety changed my life. “What do you miss most about Paris?” That’s a tough one too. The booksellers on the sidewalk in [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content