Off Broadway Review: ‘Shear Madness,’ the Long-Running Boston Hit Arrives in New York

Kate Middleton, Adam Gerber, Jordan Ahnquist, Jeremy Kushnier, Patrick Noonan, Lynne Wintersteller.

Extended out-of-town tryouts are the stuff of legend — but 36 years?  “Shear Madness,” the audience-participation murder mystery with franchises all over the country and beyond, was originally intended to open in New York after a 1980 Boston tryout. But Beantown audiences were so receptive that the show just kept running … and running … and running. The comedy still isn’t sharp enough for Gotham, but the show’s improvisational nature demands constant topical updates — and New Yorkers won’t be shy about telling the company where to go.

After all these years (and productions in cities including D.C. and Chicago), the show has finally landed at Off Broadway’s New World Stages, a five-stage multiplex designed for young audiences and casual theatergoing. It’s the ideal venue for this freewheeling comedy, which depends on active participation from fully-engaged audiences, who are hereby advised to take notes on all the comings and goings in the first act.

That means keeping a sharp eye on all the characters on stage, including their exits and entrances and the props they pick up, put down, and throw out. One of them — and none of the performers knows which one — will be voted the murderer by the audience. But not before they are all grilled by a plainclothes detective who has been hiding in plain view, and who depends on you to call them out when they lie to him about where they were and what they were doing when an offstage murder took place.

That’s the fun part of the show, and it owes a lot to Patrick Noonan, a broad-chested, big-voiced actor who plays Nick O’Brien, the undercover cop who makes the suspects in this farce re-enact their movements leading up to the murder, and who also orchestrates the Q&A session with the audience. The veteran performer has played this pivotal character in a number of cities, and he holds the show together.

The not-so-fun part of the show is the first act, which sets up the murder and introduces us to all the slippery suspects.

The mise en scene is the same as in the 1963 play by German author Paul Portner from which this comic farce was adapted by director Bruce Jordan, who was also the show’s original producer. We’re in a unisex hairdressing salon, supposedly right around the corner from the theater at 50th and Ninth Avenue. Set designer Will Cotton has done the place up in appropriately tacky style, and the furnishings and props are so realistic you can practically feel your eyes watering from the toxic chemicals in the air.

Shear Madness, the name of the salon, might also apply to its owner, a throwback gay screamer named Tony Whitcomb (Jordan Ahnquist, so irritating he got my vote as the murderer). His assistant, Barbara DeMarco (Kate Middleton, who knows exactly what she’s doing), may look like a hooker from the olden days of Hell’s Kitchen, but she’s a smart cookie and she obviously runs this business pretty much single handedly.

Outside of Lieutenant O’Brien and his undercover colleague, Mike Thomas (Adam Gerber), the remaining characters are stereotypical patrons doubling as suspects. Unfortunately, none of them is murdered; the victim is the concert pianist in the apartment above the shop.

There’s no story to speak of, just a lot of frantic coming and going (very well paced by Jordan) to confuse the audience (second reminder: take notes!) and lots of lousy jokes. Lots and lots of lousy jokes. Some of them, like the double entendres and the corny burlesque routines, are supposed to be bad.

But there’s also topical comedy that’s meant to get real laughs. And maybe it will, once the company settles into the city and gets a better feel for the local humor. (Hint: we’re nastier than Boston, not as politically plugged-in as Washington, and we’re flattered when you call us cynical). The game-playing structure of the show is cleverly designed and very well executed. And the audience participation is silly fun. But if you want to stick around town for a while, you really have to get to know us better.

Off Broadway Review: 'Shear Madness,' the Long-Running Boston Hit Arrives in New York

New World Stages; 299 seats; $79.50 top. Opened Nov. 11, 2015. Reviewed Nov. 7. Running time: TWO HOURS.

Production: A Manny Kladitis, Jeffrey Chrzczon, Terry Schnuck, Kathleen K. Johnson, Jack Lane, Radio Mouse Entertainment, Schaffert / Hummel, Driemeyer-Sills Productions, David Gersten, Erach Screwvala, and Shubert Organization presentation, by special arrangement with Cranberry Productions, Inc., of a play in two acts by Paul Portner.

Creative: Directed by Bruce Jordan. Set & lighting, Will Cotton; costumes, Rodney Harper; sound, Bruce Langdon Yauger; production stage manager, Danny Maly.

Cast: Kate Middleton, Adam Gerber, Jordan Ahnquist, Jeremy Kushnier, Patrick Noonan, Lynne Wintersteller.

More Legit

  • Broadway Bounty Hunter review

    Off Broadway Review: 'Broadway Bounty Hunter'

    Anyone wondering what genre-hopping composer-lyricist-book writer Joe Iconis would do as an encore to the Broadway run of Tony-nominated “Be More Chill” need look no further than his immediate past. Written for veteran stage actress Annie Golden and initially produced by Barrington Stage Company in Pittsfield, Mass. in 2016, “Broadway Bounty Hunter” is both an [...]

  • Because of Winn Dixie review

    Regional Theater Review: 'Because of Winn Dixie,' the Musical

    Watching the musical “Because of Winn Dixie” at Goodspeed Musicals in East Haddam, Conn., it’s hard not to think of another show that premiered in the same regional theater 43 years ago. It, too, featured a scruffy stray dog, a lonely-but-enterprising young girl and a closed-off daddy who finally opens up. But “Winn Dixie,” based [...]


    Off Broadway Review: 'Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow'

    There’s something about Anton Chekhov’s whiny sisters that invites comic sendups of “Three Sisters” like the one Halley Feiffer wrote on commission for the Williamstown Theater Festival. Transferred to MCC Theater’s new Off Broadway space and playing in the round in a black box with limited seating capacity, the crafty show feels intimate and familiar. [...]

  • the way she spoke review

    Off Broadway Review: 'The Way She Spoke' With Kate del Castillo

    Since the 1990s, scores of women in Juarez, Mexico have been mutilated, raped, and murdered at such a rate that some have called it an epidemic of femicide—killing women and girls solely because they are women. Isaac Gomez’s play “the way she spoke,” produced Off Broadway by Audible and starring Kate del Castillo, confronts the [...]


    Brian Cox Playing LBJ in Broadway Run of 'The Great Society'

    Brian Cox will play President Lyndon Johnson in the Broadway run of “The Great Society,” playwright Robert Schenkkan’s follow-up to “All the Way.” The role of Johnson, a crude, but visionary politician who used the office of the presidency to pass landmark civil rights legislation and social programs, was originally played by Bryan Cranston in [...]

  • Paul McCartney Has Penned Score for

    Paul McCartney Has Been Secretly Writing an 'It's a Wonderful Life' Musical

    The pop superstar who once released a movie and album called “Give My Regards to Broad Street” really does have designs on Broadway, after all. It was revealed Wednesday that Paul McCartney has already written a song score for a stage musical adaptation of the 1946 Frank Capra film classic “It’s a Wonderful Life.” The [...]

  • The Night of the Iguana review

    West End Review: 'The Night of the Iguana' With Clive Owen

    If Tennessee Williams is the poet laureate of lost souls, none of his characters as are off-grid as the restless travelers trying to make it through his little-seen 1961 play, “The Night of the Iguana.” Holed up in a remote Mexican homestay, its ragtag itinerants live hand-to-mouth, day by day, as they seek refuge from [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content