Off Broadway Review: ‘Placebo’ with Carrie Coon

Carrie Coon, William Jackson Harper, Alex Hurt, Florencia Lozano.

Off Broadway’s Playwrights Horizons is justifiably celebrated for its impressive 44-year record of supporting American playwrights. So it’s awkward to be heaping praise on the sterling work of director Daniel Aukin and the four terrific performers — Carrie Coon (“Gone Girl,” “The Leftovers”), William Jackson Harper, Alex Hurt, and Florencia Lozano — in Melissa James Gibson’s “Placebo,” without finding much merit in the work itself. But that’s as it must be, because whatever the scribe (“House of Cards,” “The Americans”) was going for in this relationship play, the message didn’t land.

The focus of the play is a doctoral candidate named Louise (played by the incandescent Coon) who is interning at a hospital running blind test trials on a new drug. This unnamed drug has been designed to boost sexual response in middle-aged women like Mary (played with admirable honesty by Lozano), who is burning with the urgent need to know whether she’s been given the actual drug being tested — or a placebo.

As unruffled as she appears at work, Louise is riddled with anxiety at home.  Her main worry concerns her youthful mother (younger than the women in that pharmaceutical study), who lives in another city under the care of another daughter and has just been sent home from the hospital in less than ship-shape condition.

Louise is also under pressure to be patient with and understanding of her live-in boyfriend, Jonathan (William Jackson Harper), a nerdy classics scholar who’s put seven years into his dissertation on Pliny the Elder. Jonathan is given to meltdowns that seem entirely reasonable for someone who’s down to the last chapter of his life’s work, and Harper inhabits the difficult role as comfortably as someone who lives in robe and slippers.  But when Louise tries to give her mother something to live for by telling her that they are getting married, he’s so spooked he asks her to move out of their apartment until he’s delivered and defended his dissertation.

If there’s a bright spot in Louise’s life, it’s her goofy relationship with Tom, a laid-back co-worker at the hospital played by Hurt, who is devastatingly sexy in the no-sweat manner of guys who have no trouble maintaining a two-day beard. The closest thing to intimacy these two share is the silly game they play with a vending machine in the hospital green room. But they speak the same elliptical, illogical and absurdly funny language, and their exchanges of non-sequiturs sound more like mating calls than the intellectual drolleries she shares with Jonathan.

But what this feeble love triangle has to do with the scribe’s “placebo” theme is anyone’s guess. Is brainy Jonathan the bogus love object blinding Louise to a more appropriate mate like Tom? Or is Tom the pretender, an amusing distraction until Jonathan learns to lighten up?

Director Aukin, who has directed other plays by Gibson, has an uncanny feel for the quirky nature of the scribe’s droll dialogue, which he has imparted to his smart and extremely personable cast. As for the radiant Coons, she was an eye-catching (and Tony nominated) Honey on Broadway in “Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?” before she ever appeared in “Gone Girl,” so idiosyncratic language and witty word games are her stock in trade. She’s also unafraid, in those comic exchanges with the two very different men in her life, to explore those unspoken fears hiding under the skin of a joke. But she can’t pull a meaningful play out of a sensitive character study.

Popular on Variety

Off Broadway Review: 'Placebo' with Carrie Coon

Playwrights Horizons; 198 seats; $75 top. Opened March 16, 2015. Reviewed March 14. Running time: ONE HOUR, 35 MIN.

Production: A Playwrights Horizons presentation of a play in one act by Melissa James Gibson.

Creative: Directed by Daniel Aukin. Sets & costumes, David Zinn; lighting, Matt Frey; sound, Ryan Rumery; production stage manager, Kyle Gates.

Cast: Carrie Coon, William Jackson Harper, Alex Hurt, Florencia Lozano.

More Legit

  • The Sound Inside review

    Broadway Review: 'The Sound Inside' Starring Mary-Louise Parker

    Mary-Louise Parker will take your breath away with her deeply felt and sensitively drawn portrait of a tenured Yale professor who treasures great literature, but has made no room in her life for someone to share that love with. The other thesp in this two-hander is Will Hochman, endearing in the supportive role of a [...]

  • Little Shop of Horrors review

    Off Broadway Review: 'Little Shop of Horrors'

    With its strains of kitschy doo-wop and its sci-fi B-movie inspirations, the quaint 1982 musical “Little Shop of Horrors” hardly seems a thing of modern-day revivalism, even despite its touches of S&M. Yet this year alone, not only is there an Off Broadway production of the blackly comic “Little Shop” featuring Jonathan Groff of Netflix’s [...]

  • The Lightning Thief review musical

    Broadway Review: 'The Lightning Thief,' The Musical

    “It’s a lot to take in right now,” says Percy Jackson, the teen hero of “The Lightning Thief,” the kid-centric fantasy musical (based on the popular Y.A. novel) that’s now on Broadway after touring the country and playing an Off Broadway run. You could say that’s a bit of an understatement from contemporary teen Percy [...]

  • The Rose Tattoo review

    Broadway Review: 'The Rose Tattoo' Starring Marisa Tomei

    “The Rose Tattoo” is what happens when a poet writes a comedy — something strange, but kind of lovely. The same might be said of director Trip Cullman’s production: Strange, if not exactly lovely. Even Marisa Tomei, so physically delicate and expressively refined, seems an odd choice to play the lusty and passionate protagonist, Serafina [...]

  • Obit-Roy-B

    Former NATO President Roy B. White Dies at 93

    Roy B. White, former president and chairman of the National Association of Theater Owners, died of natural causes Oct. 11 in Naples, Fla. He was 93. White ran the 100-screen independent theater circuit, Mid–States Theaters Inc. In addition to his career, he did extensive work on behalf of charities and non-profits. He was vice president [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content