Film Review: ‘3 Generations’ (‘About Ray’)

Elle Fanning plays a transgender teen in this enjoyably lightweight yet occasionally contrived comedy-drama.

Elle Fanning, Naomi Watts, Linda Emond, Susan Sarandon, Tate Donovan, Maria Dizzia, Andrew Polk, Sam Trammell, Max Simkins, Mattea Marie Conforti.

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt4158624/

Though transgender issues couldn’t be more timely, it’s a shame “About Ray” didn’t open a few years ago, when its tiptoeing approach to the physical realities of gender reassignment might have been just the ticket to help ease more skittish viewers into understanding and accepting the whole idea. A crowdpleaser in the purest middlebrow mold, Gaby Dellal’s picture features Elle Fanning as a transgender teenager hoping to begin hormone treatment and start transitioning into a boy, and the film he inhabits proves much lighter and more irreverent than that premise would seem to indicate. Though the results are at times messy, and often veer too far into the standard quirky family-indie formula (producers include Marc Turtletaub and Peter Saraf, who patented that formula with “Little Miss Sunshine”), Dellal’s likably chaotic direction and a bevy of solid performances make sure the film’s beating heart outweighs most of its contrivances.

The film starts in a doctor’s office, as teenage Ray (Fanning) — nee Ramona — learns what to expect once he starts testosterone treatment. Ray’s matriarchal support system is unusually well positioned to accept his changing identity, even if the women each betray an occasional hint of discomfort: Mother Maggie (Naomi Watts) has raised him independently for years, and grandmother Dolly (Susan Sarandon) is an out lesbian in a long-term relationship with Frances (Linda Emond). The limberly dotty Dolly does wonder out loud: “Why can’t she just be a lesbian? She likes women,” and the film has fun with the idea that this may one day be a stock conservative lament.

Inhabiting a version of Manhattan that largely still exists only in the minds of indie filmmakers and MFA students, the clan lives in a wonderfully cluttered, multi-story building that used to be a sanctuary for itinerant jazzmen. Ray is desperate to start his hormone treatment in time to switch schools before the start of the next term, so as to reintroduce himself as a boy. (In one of the film’s more glaring omissions, we see Ray with a posse of male friends, but it’s never exactly clear how much any of them know about his situation.)

Maggie, however, is dragging her feet on signing the parental consent form, which suddenly presents a major complication: The form requires both parents’ signatures, and Ray’s father, Craig, hasn’t been around for years. It’s hard to imagine there wouldn’t be a standard legal route around such a dilemma, but the film needs a hook to get Maggie to reunite with her old flame, and this one works well enough.

Indeed, despite its title, ”About Ray” is just as much about Maggie, as she must confront her own highly complicated romantic past by schlepping out to the suburbs, where Craig (Tate Donovan) lives with his new wife (Maria Dizzia) and three young children. Initially seeming like a subplot, this strand comes to dominate the latter half of the film, and it’s hard not to see the core story slipping away from the filmmakers at times. But the script from Dallal and Nikole Beckwith manages to be consistently funny, and its ultimate celebration of the post-post-nuclear family is sincere enough to overlook some of its structural problems.

Activists have often decried the casting of cisgender actors in trans roles (recently on display with Eddie Redmayne in “The Danish Girl”), and often with very good reason. But considering the titular character here has not yet begun any sort of medical treatment, all that matters is that the actor playing him be believable, and Fanning certainly is. Portraying Ray as authentically awkward yet far beyond any sort of confusion over his identity, Fanning’s performance allows him to be both righteously troubled and also just a bit of a standard-issue d–khead teenager, stomping down stairwells, defying his elders and getting awkward around girls like any good All-American dude.

Tackling the Alan Arkin role, Sarandon gives a half-sarcastic glint to her line readings, even the serious ones, and her rapport with Emond is positively vaudevillian, yet smaller doses of her antics might have better served the story. Watts at times seems to struggle with a character that’s being pulled in two different narrative directions, but she finds enough small moments and idiosyncrasies to flesh her out.

Embracing the all-over-the-place nature of the script, Dallal directs with a skewed eye and a careening pace that recalls David O. Russell at its best moments, and an average skateboard video at its lesser ones. In a post-Caitlin Jenner landscape, “About Ray’s” delicate portioning of physical details — a tuft of unexpected underarm hair here, an oblique discussion of male genitalia there — can definitely err on the side of caution. But this is the rare trans-themed comedy that most viewers could safely take their grandparents to, and there is something to be said for that.

Film Review: '3 Generations' ('About Ray')

Reviewed at Toronto Film Festival (Special Presentations), Sept. 12, 2015. Running time: 87 MIN. (Original title: “About Ray”)

Production: A Weinstein Co. release, presented with Big Beach, of a Big Beach, InFilm production. Produced by Marc Turtletaub, Peter Saraf. Executive producers, Naomi Watts, Peter Pastorelli, Leah Holzer, Daniele Melia, Bob Weinstein, Harvey Weinstein.

Crew: Directed by Gaby Dellal. Screenplay, Nikole Beckwith, Dellal. Camera (color), David Johnson; editor, Joe Landauer; music, Michael Brook; music supervisor, Joe Rudge; production designer, Stephanie Carroll; art director, Meredith Lippincott; costume designer, Arjun Bhasin; sound, Jerry Stein; supervising sound editor/re-recording mixer, Lewis Goldstein; assistant director, Inna Braude; casting, Douglas Aibel, Stephanie Holbrook.

With: Elle Fanning, Naomi Watts, Linda Emond, Susan Sarandon, Tate Donovan, Maria Dizzia, Andrew Polk, Sam Trammell, Max Simkins, Mattea Marie Conforti.

More Film

  • A Star Is Born

    'A Star Is Born' Soundtrack Surpasses Global Sales of 6 Million

    Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper’s onscreen chemistry continues to be felt on the official soundtrack to “A Star is Born,” which just surpassed 6 million albums sold globally and has been certified double platinum in the U.S. Released by Interscope Records in 2018, the album debuted atop the charts and remains the highest-selling album of [...]

  • monty-python-are-fifty-in-2019

    Previously Unreleased Monty Python Audio to Get Airing for Troupe's 50th Anniversary

    Michael Palin will exec-produce series of radio specials containing never-before-released audio from Monty Python as part of the 50th anniversary celebrations for the iconic comedy troupe. They will play on the BBC in the U.K. and then go out in the U.S. Palin and his fellow Pythons – John Cleese, Terry Gilliam, Eric Idle, Terry [...]

  • The Eight Hundred (The 800)

    Huayi Brothers' Stock Falls 8% After 'The Eight Hundred' Cancellation

    Huayi Brothers’ stock fell by more than 8% on Wednesday, the day after the veteran Chinese studio announced that its new war epic, “The Eight Hundred,” will not hit Chinese theaters as scheduled next week. Shares dropped from RMB5.48 to RMB5.02 overnight after Huayi said Tuesday that its summer blockbuster’s theatrical debut would be indefinitely [...]

  • Chinese actor Xu Zheng holds his

    Golden Horse Organizers Set Clashing Date With China's Golden Rooster Awards

    The prestigious Golden Horse Awards announced Wednesday that it will hold its annual ceremony in Taiwan on the same day this year as China’s Communist-backed Golden Rooster Awards – which virtually assures that no major mainland Chinese talent will attend the event known as Asia’s Oscars on November 23. Hong Kong director Johnnie To will [...]

  • Berlin Film Festival Placeholder Berlinale

    Key Berlin Film Festival Venue Set to Close - or Is It?

    The announcement that German exhibitor CineStar would close its multiplex at Berlin’s famed Sony Center in Potsdamer Platz has thrown the cinema’s participation as a key venue for the Berlin Film Festival into doubt. Whether it actually shutters, however, remains to be seen. British-based Vue International is awaiting approval from German antitrust officials on its [...]

  • Stuber

    ‘Stuber’ Tops Studios’ TV Ad Spending

    In this week’s edition of the Variety Movie Commercial Tracker, powered by the always-on TV ad measurement and attribution company iSpot.tv, Twentieth Century Fox claims the top spot in spending with “Stuber.” Ads placed for the comedy had an estimated media value of $4.91 million through Sunday for 1,325 national ad airings on 42 networks. [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content