You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘The Surface’

Sean Astin and Chris Mulkey are lost at sea (well, Lake Michigan) in this well-intentioned but unmemorable drama.

Sean Astin, Chris Mulkey, Mimi Rogers, Robert A. Smith, Chike Johnston, Jeff Gendelman, Rachel Renee.

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3074578/

“The Surface” boasts a thriller premise, albeit one that leads not to a suspense narrative, but rather to a spottily involving two-hander that’s borderline stagy despite being set in the middle of Lake Michigan. Opened on a dozen Midwestern screens May 15, this well-intentioned but unmemorable drama from helmer Gil Cates Jr. and producer/scenarist Jeff Gendelman is more likely to make modest inroads as a smallscreen item.

Mitch (Sean Astin) is an average Joe living in Milwaukee, though we quickly sense he’s dragging around above-average degrees of depression and loneliness. After visiting his senile mother in a nursing home, he drives the less-than-spruce family speedboat to the dock for a Lake Michigan outing on this hot summer’s day. His intent is not recreational, however. Just as he appears to be commencing a suicide plan, he’s interrupted by the vessel’s plowing into some aquatic debris. There’s been a small-plane crash — and there’s a barely conscious man clinging to a wing.

Mitch hauls the stranger out of the water. Yet once he comes around, seriously injured Kelly (Chris Mulkey) is far from grateful; in fact, he brandishes a knife, demands to know who his rescuer is, and seems inordinately concerned about a small daypack he’s managed to cling to. He claims he was flying from Michigan to an airshow in Wisconsin and misjudged his altitude amid morning fog.

But that story turns out to be something of a ruse: After a time we learn Kelly was really on a rather shadier mission, one he’d been forced into by his family’s economic straits. (Mimi Rogers appears briefly in flashbacks as his devoted wife.) Meanwhile, the belligerent pilot wrestles some truths from Mitch regarding why he was in the middle of Lake Michigan with little food, not enough gas, and some ominous cargo. More flashbacks eventually reveal the sources of the despair that led the younger man here.

Though the script by theater-trained thesp/scribe Gendelman quickly retreats from any “Dead Calm”-like stranger-danger-at-sea, there remains a suspense element in Kelly’s fear that his life is still at risk from employers his crash prevented him from rendezvousing with. But that’s lackadaisically handled by Cates’ direction, and the rambling dialogue is no help. With both characters sporting different kinds of expertise, their sometimes mildly comical, argumentative banter often digresses into such interesting (but narrative-momentum-killing) trivia as the legal treatment of suicide attempts in different states, and the head-injury risks of rollerblading. Nor does much tension develop from the fact that our duo is stranded far from shore in a disabled boat (even once it’s sprung a leak).

Instead, the primary emphasis is on the gradual warming between protagonists, who move from hostile wariness to grudging confidences and finally wind up caring about each other’s disparate plights. There is a sweet, slightly whimsical ending that feels somewhat out of character with the prior going, but hits a tenor the film might have benefited from threading in much earlier. As is, “The Surface” is earnest but not atmospheric or insightfully written enough to attain the heartfelt poignancy it aims for.

Performances are decent, with Astin solid in a schlumpy character role, although the normally reliable Mulkey sometimes pushes Kelly’s cantankerousness to the brink of ham. Packaging is pro but rather nondescript, with little personality to Jimmy Sammarco’s location lensing and a blandly pleasant, occasionally too-twee soundtrack of original instrumental music and various-artist songs.

Film Review: 'The Surface'

Reviewed online, San Francisco, May 10, 2015. Running time: 86 MIN.

Production: An Entertainment One release of a Shoreline Entertainment presentation in association with Good Note Productions and JimmyMakesMovies. Produced by Jeff Gendelman. Executive producers, Sean Astin, Ken Delman, Jim Kacmarcik. Co-producer, Jimmy Sammarco.

Crew: Directed by Gil Cates Jr. Screenplay, Jeff Gendelman. Camera (color, HD), Jimmy Sammarco; editor, Sherwood Jones; music, Jeff Russo; music supervisor, Mason Cooper; production designer, Jessica Kaminski; costume designer, Bethany Michaels; set decorator, Shannon Rosenthal; sound, Mick Fowler; re-recording mixer/supervising sound editor, Michael J. McDonald; assistant director, Michael Judd; casting, Danielle Aufiero, Amber Horn.

With: Sean Astin, Chris Mulkey, Mimi Rogers, Robert A. Smith, Chike Johnston, Jeff Gendelman, Rachel Renee.

More Film

  • Loureiro’s Abano, Aragón’s Caribe Music Team

    Chelo Loureiro, Emilio Aragón Team on Animated ‘Valentina’ (EXCLUSIVE)

    CANNES – Spanish producer-turned director Chelo Loureiro of Galicia’s Ábano Producións has teamed with Spanish multi-hyphenate Emilio Aragón at Caribe Music to produce the upcoming animated feature “Valentina.” Valentina turns on a girl who is tired of having Down syndrome, and believes it to be the reason she’ll never be a trapeze artist. But Valentina’s [...]

  • Morelia Brings Four Shorts To Cannes

    Morelia’s Daniela Michel Presents Four Standout Mexican Shorts at Critics' Week

    Since 2005, the Cannes Film Festival Critics’ Week and Mexico’s Morelia Intl. Film Festival (FICM) have enjoyed a reciprocal relationship. Each year, a selection of short competition films from Morelia is shown in a special selection at Critics’ Week, with the features from the Cannes section screening five months later in Morelia. The short film [...]

  • Fedor Bondarchuk Drops Teaser for ‘Attraction

    Fedor Bondarchuk Drops Teaser for ‘Attraction 2’ (EXCLUSIVE)

    CANNES–Russian director Fedor Bondarchuk and his Art Pictures Studio have released the English-subbed teaser to “Attraction 2,” the sequel to Bondarchuk’s 2017 sci-fi blockbuster, which Variety has acquired exclusively. The director behind record-breaking Russian films such as World War II epic “Stalingrad” was in Cannes this week, where he presented footage from Art Pictures’ slate of upcoming [...]

  • Gkids Takes North American Rights for

    Gkids Takes North American Rights for ‘Weathering With You’

    CANNES–Gkids, the U.S. distributor of 11 best animated feature Oscar nominees, has acquired North American rights for “Weathering With You,” the new film from director Makoto Shinkai and producer Genki Kawamura. Gkids has set an awards-qualifying run for 2019 with a theatrical release in early 2020, in both the original Japanese and a new English-language [...]

  • Transilvania Film Fest Launches New SVOD

    Transilvania Film Fest Launches New SVOD Platform

    CANNES–The Transilvania Intl. Film Festival has announced a new SVOD service, TIFF Unlimited, which will launch during the festival’s 18th edition, which bows May 31 in Cluj, Romania. The service will curate titles from current and previous editions of the festival, while also showcasing other hand-picked auteur-driven productions, presented in partnership with local distributors. It [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content