×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘One Cut, One Life’

Diagnosed with a fatal disease, documentarian Ed Pincus, father of the first-person film, teams up with sometime collaborator Lucia Small for his last film.

With:
Ed Pincus, Jane Pincus, Lucia Small.

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3846324/

When Ed Pincus (“Black Natchez,” “Diaries 1971-76”), the oft-proclaimed father of the first-person documentary, was diagnosed with a lethal bone marrow disease, he decided to chronicle his post-diagnostic existence from two separate but intersecting points of view: his own and that of his sometime muse/collaborator Lucia Small, herself still reeling from the violent deaths of her two closest friends.  Unlike more generally philosophical, life-affirming autobiographical docus about dying, “One Cut, One Life” rehashes old problems and tries to resolve multiple unresolved issues already exposed in previous films, proving as exasperating as it is weirdly compelling.

Several structural threads loosely tie the film together. First and foremost there is the odd man or, rather, odd woman out: Jane, Pincus’ wife, whose constant presence serves as the irritant around which the film essays to construct a pearl. Jane, herself a painter and a formidable feminist author, makes no bones about the fact that she greatly resents the camera’s constant closeup intrusions into her private life, even though she played a very large role in Pincus’ “Diaries.” Nor do these intrusions let up for a second in “One Cut, One Life,” as Jane’s emotional responses to the ongoing drama are ruthlessly tracked. Pincus intimates that his wife was partly responsible for his abandonment of a successful filmmaking career, as founder and teacher of first-person cinema, to become a commercial flower farmer in Vermont for 30 years.

Here co-director Small (“My Father, the Genius”) enters the picture. She revived Pincus’ passion for filmmaking, and in 2007 they embarked on a docu together, “The Axe in the Attic,” following Katrina-displaced inhabitants of New Orleans. But the obvious objective virtues of “Axe” are almost obscured by the filmmakers’ personal bickering over opposing ideas about the appropriatenss of white Northerners making a film about poor Southern blacks, a dialogue that feels more poorly placed and self-indulgent than sensibly theoretical. The filmmakers cut the docu while staying at the Pincuses’ Vermont house.

Popular on Variety

Apparently the “Axe” experience not only undermined Pincus and Small’s deep if nonsexual relationship, but awakened old insecurities and jealousies that a decades-younger blonde workmate does little to dispel. Large sections of “One Cut, One Life” are devoted to the women’s rehashing of this past, Small feeling guilty about being the “other woman,” and Jane now even more unwilling to share her husband’s final days with not one but two cameras. The two women struggle to accommodate Pincus, who shruggingly evokes artistic necessity as if pleading the Fifth.

The third structuring principle, typical of films about terminal illness, is that of time itself, as intertitles announce the changing seasons.  Though Pincus is a poor candidate for it, a bone-marrow transplant holds his only chance for long-term survival. Yet the procedure would lay him low for a good while and might even hasten his demise. He makes a deal with the devil and postpones the operation so he can make his film and enjoy life in relative comfort. Rounds of doctors, discussions of platelet counts and various medical procedures keep the life-and-death drama alive without consuming much screen time.

Instead, copious footage of two gamboling dogs, one owned by the Pincuses and the other a canine legacy of Small’s slain friend Suzanne, visually stand in for the passage of time. Numerous shots of nature and blossoming flowers, visits from his lively, irreverent family and a willingness to risk all for a chance at another spring attest to Ed’s unquenchable zest for life, yet cannot quite disguise the messiness, even pettiness that are often the consequences of a truly first-person cinema. Unlike, say, dying Portuguese director Joaquim Pinto in his whimsically titled “What’s Next? Remind Me,” Pincus seeks not to refamiliarize himself with life’s possible meanings as much as to obsessively seek justification for life choices, past and present.

Film Review: 'One Cut, One Life'

Reviewed on DVD, New York, May 12, 2015. Running time: 107 MIN.

Production: A First Run Features release of a Small Angst production. Produced by Mary Kerr, Ed Pincus, Lucia Small. Executive producer, Neal Baer.

Crew: Directed by Ed Pincus, Lucia Small. Camera (color, HD), Small, Pincus; editor, Small; music, P. Andrew Willis.

With: Ed Pincus, Jane Pincus, Lucia Small.

More Film

  • Richard Jewell

    The Big Lie of 'Richard Jewell' (Column)

    For a man who was so enraged at the administration of Barack Obama that he spent his 2012 Republican Convention speech lecturing an empty chair, Clint Eastwood has made a number of conventional, level-headed — one might even say liberal — political dramas. Films like “Invictus” and “J. Edgar” and “Midnight in the Garden of [...]

  • Oscar Isaac Star Wars The Rise

    Oscar Isaac Has Never Felt Like a 'Star Wars' Insider

    Unlike his “Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker” co-stars Daisy Ridley and John Boyega, Oscar Isaac had already established a long and acclaimed acting career before J.J. Abrams cast him as ace X-wing pilot Poe Dameron in 2015’s “Star Wars: The Force Awakens,” including standout roles in 2006’s “The Nativity Story” and 2011’s “Drive,” and [...]

  • Les Arcs to Showcase New Projects

    Les Arcs to Showcase New Projects by Jonas Alexander Arnby, Agnieszka Smoczyńska

    Denmark’s Jonas Alexander Arnby, France’s Alain Gagnol and Jean-Loup Felicioli, and Poland’s Agnieszka Smoczyńska are among up-and-coming directors from across Europe whose latest projects will be presented at the 11th Coproduction Village of Les Arcs Film Festival. This edition of Les Arcs Coproduction Village will showcase a total of 22 European projects spanning 19 countries. [...]

  • 'Chez Jolie Coiffure' Review: Hair Salon

    Film Review: 'Chez Jolie Coiffure'

    Shortly before the credits roll on “Chez Jolie Coiffure,” a customer in the eponymous hair salon asks her stylist, Sabine, if she has any plans to go home this year. Out of context, this sounds like the kind of standard, empty small talk one often makes while having one’s hair cut: what good movies you’ve [...]

  • Best Netflix original movies

    The 10 Best Netflix Movies of 2019

    This time last year, Netflix estimated that it would release 90 original movies in 2019. At the time, the number seemed outrageous: That’s more than four times the number Warner Bros. made in the same 12-month period — and more than any human would ever care to watch. Guess what: Turns out that 90 was a [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content