×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘Lost Soul: The Doomed Journey of Richard Stanley’s Island of Dr. Moreau’

A blow-by-blow account of one of cinema's most celebrated train wrecks.

With:
Richard Stanley, Fairuza Balk, Marco Hofschneider, Graham Humphreys, Rob Morrow, Edward R. Pressman, Robert Shaye, Tim Zinnemann, Hugh Dickson, Oli Dickson, Peter Elliott, Bruce Fuller, Michael Gingold, David Grasso Jr., David Hudson, Kier-La Janisse, Paul Katte, Fiona Mahl, Emile Nicolau, James Sbardellati, Robert Shaye, Tim Sullivan.

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3966544/

One of the all-time greatest cinematic train wrecks is given blow-by-blow chronicling in “Lost Soul: The Doomed Journey of Richard Stanley’s Island of Dr. Moreau.” The creation of the H.G. Wells’ story’s third official screen incarnation was beset by disasters even more bizarre than the delirious mess of a feature finally released in 1996, with stars Marlon Brando and Val Kilmer reportedly rivaling even Mother Nature as destructive on-set forces. Though not so imaginatively packaged as another recent unmaking-of docu, “Jodorowsky’s Dune,” David Gregory’s pic can hardly help but fascinate with its mix of archival materials and surviving-collaborator testimonies. A hit at genre fests, the pic should do well in specialized cable sales and home formats.

Writer-helmer Stanley was a South African horror/sci-fi prodigy who’d attracted favorable fan notice with modestly budgeted thrillers “Hardware” (1990) and “Dust Devil” (1992). A fan of Wells’ tale since childhood, he was not yet 30 when New Line greenlit his proposed remake, following in the footsteps of 1932’s memorable (if not particularly faithful) Charles Laughton vehicle “Island of Lost Souls” and the middling Burt Lancaster/Michael York “Moreau” of 1977. He imagined an updated version at once more faithful to the original author’s vision and full of baroque new ideas for the mad doctor’s experimental humanoid “beasts” — glimpsed here in elaborate pre-production pitch illustrations and design sketches.

Already an ambitious project by the studio’s usual thrifty standards, the film saw its budget balloon when it attracted the notoriously difficult Brando, and a Kilmer just coming off his box office apex of “Batman Forever.” Kilmer’s script demands immediately cut loose James Woods, whose planned co-lead role was more or less absorbed into the bigger star’s part. Then, still before shooting had actually started, Brando’s daughter Cheyenne committed suicide, causing him to drop out of another film mid-shoot. His arrival on the set of “Moreau” delayed for an unguessable length, shooting began nonetheless on the picturesque but remote coastal location found near Cairns in northeastern Australia.

Executives were already fretting over whether fanboy Stanley could handle the big-budget, high-pressure endeavor this had become. Within just a few days, they decided he couldn’t, given his near-paralytic reaction to two disasters: first, a hurricane that flooded nearly all the sets; second, Hurricane Kilmer, whose “prep-school bully” behavior (as one witness puts it) seemed hellbent on undermining the young director’s confidence and authority. Having needed the studio’s deep pockets to attain the material’s rights in the first place, Stanley had no legal means of opposing being sacked from what had been his project from the start. To the dismay of sympathetic cast and crew members (notably actress Fairuza Balk, one of the principal interviewees here), he was simply fired, and then simply disappeared amid rumors of a possible personal vendetta and/or suicide watch.

Scrambling to save its investment, New Line was turned down by numerous replacement directors before settling on John Frankenheimer, a 65-year-old veteran who (being at a low career ebb) came cheap and was willing to sign up on extremely short notice. He also brought to the table a reputation for successfully “wrangling difficult actors.” After a couple of conciliatory first days on the job with a shaken crew, he revealed himself as “one of the last old-school screamers,” taking out his frustrations on lesser personnel while his two marquee stars continued to wreak havoc  —their incessant changes on top of the director’s own rewrites (he confessed scant affinity for the fantasy material) leaving little left of Stanley’s imaginative concept.

In its place was a surreal, semi-self-parodying circus that many here call “the worst movie ever made,” though that description underserves what finally emerged from the struggle between Frankenheimer’s grizzled professionalism and the stars’ bemusedly contemptuous improv. Their “Moreau” is bad, but also undeniably, unpredictably entertaining. Alas, it was no guilty pleasure for Stanley, who it turned out had retreated to a nearby secluded retreat, eventually sneaking back onto the set undetected as an extra.

Thus he witnessed such craziness as Brando’s insistence on playing his role in “mime-white” pancake makeup; his childlike fascination with the 2’4” Nelson de la Rosa, a “mini-me” he indulged to the despair of German thesp Marco Hofschneider, whose painstakingly prepared-for role shrank to near-nothing as a consequence; and his apparent disdain toward Kilmer, whose expectations of working with the great Brando were squelched when the latter axed almost all their dialogue exchanges. Other actors spent onerous daily hours having beast makeup applied, only to frequently have it removed without a moment oncamera. The extra ranks, swelled by local beach hippies, found the few production weeks they’d planned on stretching to half a year, boredom turning their encampment into a long-running, all-expenses-paid bacchanal.

These anecdotes are related in most colorful fashion through a combination of archival materials (including much behind-the-scenes footage) and interviewees that also include actor Rob Morrow (who begged his agent to rescue him from this “complete insanity” after just four days), execs and tech/design principals. With Brando and Frankenheimer having passed on, the most conspicuous no-shows here are (unsurprisingly) Kilmer and third-billed David Thewlis. To heighten the drama, it’s suggested that the still-youthful Stanley was so traumatized he dropped out of the industry entirely. But in fact, he’s made several documentary features and omnibus segments since.

A veteran of DVD-extra documentaries (and co-founder of the specialty DVD imprint Blue Underground), Gregory might have done a bit more to differentiate this more extensive investigation from those earlier pics’ conventions. But the richness of the tale told here makes this competently packaged feature a keeper nonetheless.

Film Review: 'Lost Soul: The Doomed Journey of Richard Stanley’s Island of Dr. Moreau'

Reviewed on DVD, San Francisco, Feb. 7, 2015. (In San Francisco Independent Film Festival; 2014 Fantastic Fest; FrightFest.) Running time: 97 MIN.

Production: (Documentary – U.S.-U.K.) A Severin Films production. (International sales: Severin Films, Los Angeles.) Produced by Carl Daft, David Gregory. Executive producers, John Cregan, Daft, Gregory.

Crew: Directed by David Gregory. Camera (color, HD), Jim Kunz; editor, Douglas Buck; music, Mark Raskin; motion graphics, Kyle Broom, Eva Mozey Etoll, Michael Etoll, Bobby Hacker, Kunz; re-recording mixer, Brian San Marco.

With: Richard Stanley, Fairuza Balk, Marco Hofschneider, Graham Humphreys, Rob Morrow, Edward R. Pressman, Robert Shaye, Tim Zinnemann, Hugh Dickson, Oli Dickson, Peter Elliott, Bruce Fuller, Michael Gingold, David Grasso Jr., David Hudson, Kier-La Janisse, Paul Katte, Fiona Mahl, Emile Nicolau, James Sbardellati, Robert Shaye, Tim Sullivan.

More Film

  • Franco Zeffirelli Remembered

    Franco Zeffirelli: An Artist and a Paradox

    When popular artists pass on, it can often be a surprise to learn just how old they were. But the news of Franco Zeffirelli’s death, at 96, inspired a major double take. The extravagant Italian maestro of theater, opera and film lived to a vibrant old age. Yet for many of us, the name Zeffirelli [...]

  • Evan Tanner, Professional mixed martial arts

    UFC Fighter Evan Tanner Biopic ‘The Power of 1’ in the Works (EXCLUSIVE)

    Producers Christopher Scheimann and Olcun Tan have partnered with top sports director Bobby Razak on “The Power of 1,” a feature biopic of UFC fighter Evan Tanner. Co-written by Scheimann and Razak, the movie is slated to go into pre-production toward the end of this year, with principal photography planned for early next year. Tanner, [...]

  • The Grove Introduces Drive-In Rooftop Movie

    The Grove Introduces Drive-In Rooftop Movie Theater Level 8

    The Grove is ringing in summer with a new rooftop movie theater. The popular Los Angeles shopping mall, located between Fairfax and La Brea, announced today the launch of their new cinema experience titled Level 8 Drive-in, which will kick off with a screening of “Grease” on June 26 and will run through September. Inspired [...]

  • China, Shanghai Exhibition Centre, Soviet-style Facade

    Shanghai: China Market 'Has Always Been a Turbulent One,' Says Infotainment Chief (EXCLUSIVE)

    Movie sales and distribution company Infotainment China comes to the Shanghai International Film Festival optimistic about Chinese audience trends, but gloomy about current business conditions. “The market is bad and industry players are very pessimistic. I just hope it doesn’t get worse,” said Infotainment CEO Cindy Lin, though she noted that such periods of trouble [...]

  • Billy Eichner Power of Pride Variety

    Billy Eichner on the Homophobia He Still Sees in Comedy and Hollywood

    On “Billy on the Street,” Billy Eichner has made a name for himself running up and down Manhattan’s sidewalks, ambushing clueless New Yorkers and interrogating them about pop culture. A brash physical comedian, Eichner has no qualms about asking perfect strangers embarrassing questions, hectoring pedestrians about their willingness to have a threesome with Jon Hamm [...]

  • State of Pride Full

    How Hollywood Is (and Isn't) Getting Better at LGBTQ Inclusion

    Brandon Flynn, one of the breakout actors from Netflix’s “13 Reasons Why,” has spent the last two years fielding questions about his personal life. In 2017, he wrote a passionate post on Instagram, advocating for an Australian vote that allowed for same-sex marriage. Soon enough, news sites such as HuffPost and E! News were reporting [...]

  • Prince Mohammed bin Salman Abdulaziz al

    Saudi Crown Prince Should Be Investigated Over Khashoggi Killing, U.N. Report Says

    Mohammed bin Salman, the crown prince of Saudi Arabia, should be investigated in connection with the killing of Jamal Khashoggi because of “credible evidence” that the prince is among those liable for the dissident journalist’s death, a United Nations report said Wednesday. While no “smoking gun” has yet been found that directly incriminates the prince [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content