×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘Accused’

A killer of children or a miscarriage of justice? The Oscar-shortlisted Dutch thriller retells a chilling true story with David Fincher-like intrigue.

With:
Barry Atsma, Sallie Harmsen, Ariane Schluter, Fedja Van Huet, Annet Malherbe, Amanda Ooms, Marwan Kenzari, Bas Keijzer, Isis Cabolet, Marcel Musters, Maartje Remmers.

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1800338/

It’s one thing to be imprisoned for a crime you didn’t commit, but in the unique case of unlucky pediatric nurse Lucia de Berk, the woman was labeled a serial killer by the media and locked away for a series of suspicious deaths that, upon closer inspection, probably weren’t crimes at all. The shortlisted Dutch entry in this year’s ultra-competitive Oscar foreign-language race, “Accused” is by far the category’s most conventional — and by extension, its most commercial — contender, a taut procedural that boasts solid Hollywood remake potential in its streamlined retelling of de Berk’s incredible and unnerving true story.

“Accused” marks the second time director Paula van der Oest has been selected to represent the Netherlands at the Academy Awards, following her incomparably upbeat 2001 romantic comedy, “Zus & Zo,” which went on to earn an Oscar nomination. In both cases, apart from the language difference, the films hardly feel foreign at all, playing out like well-made American studio fare, albeit ones made on dramatically tighter budgets.

This time, the resulting project sits squarely between the psychological thriller and courtroom drama genres, exploring the mystery of what must have been going through de Berk’s mind against a backdrop of zealous prosecutors and callous hospital executives who manipulated her fate for their own personal gain. With the benefit of hindsight, Moniek Kramer and Tijs van Marle’s screenplay is free to suggest that de Berk was a victim of the system — a credible scapegoat at a moment when hospital management didn’t want to take accountability for the death of one of its infant patients. But it lets the other players off easy (especially the media, who dubbed her the “Angel of Death”) in what played out akin to a modern-day witch trial, where “profiling” becomes a fancy new word for guilty by suspicion.

For dramatic purposes, van der Oest holds de Berk at arm’s length for much of the film, inviting audiences to prejudge her, too, at first. As played by Ariane Schluter (whose non-glam appearance matches the real de Berk), she is simultaneously cold and concerned, showing extra care for the critical-case infants to whom she attends, but an austere and somewhat unfriendly attitude toward the other hospital staff. When a baby dies as a result of doctor negligence, de Berk’s colleagues are the first to turn suspicion toward her, their hunches reinforced by the startling number of patients who have died under de Berk’s watch.

If de Berk is indeed killing them (whether out of empathy or malice), no one can figure out either her method or her motives. But that doesn’t stop an overeager law-school graduate named Judith Jansen (Sallie Harmsen), desperate to prove herself as an assistant prosecutor, from building an elaborate case against the nurse. In her righteous pursuit of personal glory, Judith extrapolates wild theories from the limited clues — including de Berk’s diary, which references a strange secret compulsion; the stash of overdue library books about serial killers recovered at her apartment; and the woman’s sketchy past, including work as a child prostitute — while ignoring the blatant contradictions.

Jansen is the filmmakers’ invention, but a clever one, providing a narrative arc: What began as a case to put de Berk behind bars shifts as doubt arises, and Jansen realizes that she has set in motion a process whose momentum is potentially too late to reverse. After building a compelling if largely circumstantial case labeling de Berk a serial killer, Jansen comes to believe the alleged victims may actually have died of natural causes, meaning not only that they have the wrong suspect, but that there may not have been any murders to begin with.

Audiences should be wary from extrapolating too much from the facts presented in “Accused,” given the sheer degree of creative license taken in the retelling, and yet the underlying implications are downright chilling — potentially even more so if the broad strokes were transposed to the American jury system. All these intrigues are lensed in the dark, cloak-and-dagger look we’ve come to associate with David Fincher movies. Also noteworthy is the fact that the pic’s main characters are nearly all female, as van der Oest does her part to right the gender imbalance of which so many other directors are rightly accused.

Film Review: 'Accused'

Reviewed at Palm Springs Film Festival (Awards Buzz), Jan. 4, 2015. Running time: 97 MIN. (Original title: “Lucia de B.”)

Production: (Netherlands) An Independent Films (in Netherlands) release of a Rinkel Film presentation. (International sales: Fortissimo Films, Amsterdam.) Produced by Reinier Selen. Co-producers, Klara Bjork, Martin Dewitte, Bernard Michaux, Gemma Derksen.

Crew: Directed by Paula van der Oest. Screenplay, Moniek Kramer, Tijs van Marle. Camera (color, widescreen), Guido Van Gennep; editor, Marcel Wijninga; production designer, Harry Ammerlaan; costume designer, Ellen Lens; line producer, Mardou Jacobs; casting, Leonie Luttik, Janusz Gosschalk.

With: Barry Atsma, Sallie Harmsen, Ariane Schluter, Fedja Van Huet, Annet Malherbe, Amanda Ooms, Marwan Kenzari, Bas Keijzer, Isis Cabolet, Marcel Musters, Maartje Remmers.

More Film

  • Critics Week

    Cannes Critics’ Week Unveils Its Lineup

    Lorcan Finnegan’s science-fiction thriller “Vivarium” with Jesse Eisenberg and Imogen Poots, Jérémy Clapin’s fantasy-filled animated feature “I Lost My Body,” and Hlynur Pálmason’s Icelandic drama “A White, White Day” are among the 11 films set to compete at Critics’ Week, the section dedicated to first and second films that runs parallel with the Cannes Film [...]

  • China Box Office: 'Wonder Park' Fails

    China Box Office: 'Wonder Park' Fails to Impress While 'P Storm' Rages On

    Even on one of the quietest weekends of the year, new U.S. animated release “Wonder Park” failed to inspire Chinese audiences as much as Hong Kong and Indian movies already in their third weekend in theaters. Starring the voice talents of Matthew Broderick, Jennifer Garner, Mila Kunis, and Ken Jeong, among many others, the film [...]

  • David Picker dead

    David Picker, Studio Chief Who Acquired James Bond Novels for UA, Dies at 87

    David Picker, who headed United Artists, Paramount and Columbia’s motion picture divisions and was known for forging relationships with groundbreaking filmmakers and material, died Saturday in New York. He was 87 and had been suffering from colon cancer. MGM tweeted, “We are saddened to hear that a member of the United Artists family has passed [...]

  • Abigail Disney on Bob Iger

    Abigail Disney Calls Bob Iger's $65 Million Compensation 'Insane'

    Disney chairman-CEO Bob Iger’s total compensation for Disney’s fiscal 2018 was a whopping $65.6 million. Abigail Disney, the granddaughter of Disney co-founder Roy Disney, calls that sum “insane.”  While speaking at the Fast Company Impact Council, the filmmaker and philanthropist insisted that this level of corporate payout has a “corrosive effect on society.” Disney took [...]

  • 'Curse of La Llorona' Tops International

    'Curse of La Llorona' Tops International Box Office With $30 Million

    Warner Bros. and New Line’s “The Curse of La Llorona” led the way at the international box office, summoning $30 million when it opened in 71 foreign markets. The supernatural thriller collected $26.5 million in North America for a global start of $56.5 million. “La Llorona,” based on the Mexican folklore about the Weeping Woman, [...]

  • Box Office: 'Curse of La Llorona'

    Box Office: 'Curse of La Llorona' Wins Worst Easter Weekend in Over a Decade

    Warner Bros. and New Line’s “The Curse of La Llorona” ascended to the top of domestic box office charts, conjuring $26.5 million when it opened in 3,372 North American theaters. “La Llorona” is the latest horror movie to outperform expectations, further cementing the genre as one of the most reliable box office draws. Even so, [...]

  • FX's 'Snowfall' Panel TCA Winter Press

    John Singleton Hospitalized After Suffering Stroke

    UPDATED with statements from John Singleton’s family and FX Networks John Singleton, the Oscar nominated director and writer of “Boyz N’ the Hood,” has suffered a stroke. Sources confirm to Variety that Singleton checked himself into the hospital earlier this week after experiencing pain in his leg. The stroke has been characterized by doctors as [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content