×

Film Review: ‘A Sinner in Mecca’

Gay Muslim filmmaker Parvez Sharma takes a forbidden camera with him to Mecca to film his pilgrimage.

With:
Parvez Sharma. (English, Arabic, Urdu, Hindi dialogue)  
Release Date:
Sep 4, 2015

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt4666618/reference

Following “A Jihad for Love,” his docu about gay Muslims, Indian-born, New York-based helmer Parvez Sharma again looks to prove that his faith and sexuality are compatible, this time surreptitiously shooting via iPhone in the no-filming zone of Islam’s holiest city. “A Sinner in Mecca” is personal docu-making at its most strident, puffed up with righteousness as Sharma (justifiably) argues that Saudi Arabia’s Wahabi fundamentalism runs counter to the religion’s true loving precepts. Sensationalizing every moment of his hajj (pilgrimage) while calling attention to his devotion, the helmer comes across as far too pleased with himself, though countering the demonization of Islam is a necessary goal. A tiny Stateside release on Sept. 4 went virtually unnoticed, though TV sales should be more lucrative.

After the release of “Jihad,” Sharma was the target of a fatwa for apostasy, which is presumably why he approaches his hajj with such trepidation: “I am consumed by my fear of death at the hands of the Saudis,” is but one of the lines he intones, along with, “A cold, naked fear filled me as I walked towards Saudi immigration.” Ironically for a docu meant to counter the popular media perception of Islam as a religion of violence, “Sinner” indulges in blatant scare-mongering that does more to put the helmer in a heroic light than challenge anti-Muslim narratives. Curiously, it also feels distinctly anti-Shiite.

Sharma calls his pilgrimage his hajj of defiance: “I need evidence that my faith is strong enough to survive this journey.” But the real taboo he breaks, ostentatiously even if nominally hidden, is to film in Mecca, a city off-limits not just to cameras but to non-Muslims. The lure of forbidden sites has attracted those of other faiths long before Sir Richard Burton famously entered the city in disguise in the mid-19th century, so Sharma makes much of his rule-breaking; it’s his way of further critiquing Wahabism, even though restrictions on non-Muslims in Mecca predates Wahabism by multiple centuries.

Once there, he furtively films the various stages every pilgrim is enjoined to undertake, flagrantly ensuring that he gets selfies in prayer. Historians and cultural commentators have long lamented the way the Saudis have destroyed nearly all the old structures in the city, and Sharma rightly adds his voice, also complaining about the crass commercialization of the place. He criticizes how the Saudis have covered over and air conditioned the passageway Muslims must run between two hills (a ritual known as sa’yy), and then indignantly criticizes the lack of facilities and conveniences for the vigil on the plain of Arafat. His is a hajj of bitterness and anger, and yet at the end he states, “Islam’s beating heart will now forever beat in my heart.”

Ridiculous scary music accompanies Sharma’s dramatic recreation of a chat he had with a gay Saudi while waiting on line, though it’s a shame he never bothers to include an actual gay Saudi voice, even if disguised. Contrasted with the jazzy score overlaid on scenes in his Gotham apartment, the musical juxtaposition furthers Sharma’s goal of vilifying the Kingdom, always from an outsider’s p.o.v. Sequences in India allow him to reflect on his difficult post-coming-out relationship with his devout mother.

Film Review: 'A Sinner in Mecca'

Reviewed online, Copenhagen, August 25, 2015. (In Hot Docs; OutFest.) Runing time: 79 MIN.

Production: (Documentary) A Haram Films production, in association with ARTE, ZDF. Produced by Parvez Sharma. Co-producer, Alison Amron. Executive producer, Andrew Herwitz.

Crew: Directed, written by Parvez Sharma. Camera (color), Sharma, Husain Akbar; editor, Alison Amron; co-editor, Sajid Akbar; music, Akbar, M.E. Manning; sound, Ira Spiegel; line producer, White Canvas Films; associate producer, Win-Sie Tow.

With: Parvez Sharma. (English, Arabic, Urdu, Hindi dialogue)  

More Film

  • SAG-AFTRA HQ

    SAG-AFTRA Leaders Approve Proposal for New Film-TV Contract

    The SAG-AFTRA national board has approved proposals for a successor deal to its master contract covering feature film and primetime television — a key step in the upcoming negotiations cycle with companies. The board approved the package Saturday with the performers union declining to reveal any specifics — its usual policy. The board established the wages [...]

  • Cameron Crowe, David Crosby, A.J. Eaton.

    Cameron Crowe on Why He Loved Leaving David Crosby Doc on a CSNY Question Mark

    David Crosby may or may not have stuck a joint in Cameron Crowe’s mouth the first time he ever met the future filmmaker, when Crosby was peaking with Crosby Stills Nash & Young and his interviewer was a precocious 15-year-old Rolling Stone correspondent. As Crowe said to Jimmy Kimmel the other night, “I remember it [...]

  • Mokalik

    Nigeria’s Kunle Afolayan: African Audiences Shouldn’t Be ‘Second-Class’

    DURBAN–A young boy from a middle-class home gets an unconventional schooling in the ways of the world when he’s forced to apprentice at a mechanic’s workshop in a rough-and-tumble section of Lagos. “Mokalik” is the latest feature from Kunle Afolayan, a leading figure in the wave of filmmakers revitalizing the Nigerian film industry. The film [...]

  • Alicia Rodis photographed by Alicia Rodis

    SAG-AFTRA Moves to Standardize Guidelines for Intimacy Coordinators

    SAG-AFTRA is moving to standardize guidelines for intimacy coordinators as part of an effort to establish policies for union members when their work involves nudity and simulated sex. “Our goal is to normalize and promote the use of intimacy coordinators within our industry,” said SAG-AFTRA president Gabrielle Carteris. “Intimacy coordinators provide an important safety net for [...]

  • The Lion King

    Box Office: 'The Lion King' Roars Overseas With Mighty $269 Million

    Disney’s “The Lion King” certainly felt the love this weekend, generating $269 million at the international box office. Director Jon Favreau’s remake of the classic Disney cartoon now holds the eighth-biggest debut of all time overseas, and that’s not including the film’s early opening in China last weekend. Combined with a stellar $185 million start [...]

  • Scarlett JohanssonMarvel Studios panel, Comic-Con International,

    Scarlett Johansson Reveals What We'll Learn About Black Widow in Stand-Alone Movie

    Scarlett Johansson can finally talk about her upcoming “Black Widow” movie. While she can’t divulge spoilers, she let out a big sigh of relief after the film was officially announced on Saturday during the Marvel Studios presentation at Comic-Con. “I feel like a weight has been lifted,” the Oscar nominee told Variety. “Black Widow” is [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content