×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

From ‘The Judge’ to ‘Blended,’ Movie Stars Dimmed in 2014

Movie stars didn’t shine as brightly in 2014.

It was a year in which the big draws were Captain America, Star Lord and various CGI Transformers, giant reptiles and talking apes. The people who wore the masks or shared the screen with these special effects wonders were almost incidental.

With a few exceptions, those films that depended largely on the names above the title floundered last year, raising doubts about the value of some of Hollywood’s best-compensated men and women.

If the definition of star power is opening a picture, then Johnny Depp flunked the test with “Transcendence,” Robert Downey Jr. whiffed with “The Judge,” Adam Sandler fumbled with “Blended,” George Clooney erred with “Monuments Men,” Christian Bale blundered with “Exodus: Gods & Men” and Tom Cruise missed the mark with “Edge of Tomorrow.”

Their box office disappointments sent many of the actors in question scurrying back to their franchise mainstays. Depp is on board for sequels to “Pirates of the Caribbean” and “Alice in Wonderland,” Downey Jr. extended his commitment to play Iron Man in additional Marvel films, and Cruise returns this year for a fifth “Mission: Impossible.” Meanwhile, Sandler is seeking new opportunities in the emerging world of digital streaming after signing a multifilm pact with Netflix.

Off-screen, A-listers didn’t fare much better. Much has been made of the Internet’s ability to seize upon and pick apart careers and celebrities after a few gaffes or missteps, and last year was no exception. A trainwreck of a New York Times interview with Jaden Smith and Willow Smith, in which the two expounded upon the virtues of home schooling and the inspirational nature of the Pacific Coast Highway, made family patriarch Will Smith look clueless and dinged his brand. After stumbling with 2013’s “After Earth,” Smith will try to reinvigorate his career with this spring’s heist comedy “Focus.” He’s also signed up for sequels to “Hancock” and “Bad Boys” and a role in the DC Comics adaptation of “Suicide Squad.”

Popular on Variety

Likewise, Depp created more fireworks at the Hollywood Film Awards than he did in any of his cinematic offerings. The actor’s nearly incoherent introduction to the Shep Gordon documentary “Supermensch” seemed to channel Hunter S. Thompson and inspired passionate debate on social media about whether he was intoxicated. If only “Transcendence” had created half as much excitement.

“People are tired of head on the poster films, and that’s why those big actor paydays are fading,” said Jeff Bock, a box office analyst with Exhibitor Relations.

It’s not that household names lack importance when it comes to drawing crowds. It’s just getting more difficult to assess their contributions.

Was “X-Men: Days of Future Past” the franchise’s biggest hit because it brought Hugh Jackman and Jennifer Lawrence together? Did “Interstellar,” Christopher Nolan’s space odyssey, fail to match “Inception’s” global haul because it didn’t star Leonardo DiCaprio? Should Mark Wahlberg get credit for “Transformers: Age of Extinction” or was it all about the Autobots?

“Robert Downey Jr. in ‘Iron Man’ is pretty much a guarantee of success, but plug him into other movies, and not so much,” said Paul Dergarabedian, senior media analyst at Rentrak. “That’s not the only way you measure star power. It’s more about batting average.”

These actors are both help and hindrance. It’s probably true that “The Judge” wouldn’t have made as much without Downey Jr. as it did with him, but his presence also justified a $50 million budget for a talky film with limited box office prospects.

There were certainly fresh faces who filled the screen in an impressive way last year and could be poised for enduring careers. None showed more promise than Shailene Woodley, who scored with both “Divergent” and “The Fault in Our Stars,” proving her versatility and resonance with teen audiences. Despite her rising star, the filmmakers behind “The Amazing Spider-Man 2” saw no problem cutting her small role in the superhero film. There are limits to an actor’s appeal, clearly.

Some of the old guard also showed resilience. Denzel Washington continued his hot streak with “The Equalizer,” Scarlett Johansson delivered with “Lucy” and Seth Rogen scored with “Neighbors.”

Then there wasBen Affleck, who had a hit with “Gone Girl” but served primarily as a brand enhancement. A boatload of good reviews and the millions of readers who embraced the bestseller that inspired the mystery had just as much to do with its success.

Perhaps the biggest star of all was Angelina Jolie. After a four-year absence from the screen, she returned with the year’s third highest grossing film globally, “Maleficent.” The Oscar winner was front and center in the advertising campaign for the fantasy adventure, her name and face the big selling points.

“Angelina Jolie added credibility to that film and brought in a different demographic,” said Bock. “There are some stars that still make a film an event that has to be seen in theaters.”

For good measure, “Unbroken,” the survival story Jolie directed, has been a Christmas season winner, earning $87.8 million despite its bleak subject matter.

Jolie’s role in both of those pictures’ success is instructive. Her outsized public persona (Brad Pitt, the kids, her U.N. work, even her bout with chicken pox) brought buzz to projects that might not have received the same level of media attention.

But the concept of box office muscle may be more myth than reality.

“The star system has always been overrated,” said Phil Contrino, vice president and chief analyst at BoxOffice.com. “The notion that stars open movies no matter what is not true. Cinema history is littered with high-profile disappointments. They help guarantee publicity, but if people aren’t responding to the content of a film, they’re not going to show up because of an actor.”

The economic contributions of these actors is a source of lively debate in the executive suites of Hollywood. That’s evident in a leaked email exchange between Sony Pictures Entertainment co-chair Amy Pascal and the makers of “Jobs.” In notes to each other, the studio chief and the filmmakers behind the biopic about Apple founder Steve Jobs go back and forth weighing the appeal of Leonardo DiCaprio, Tom Cruise and Christian Bale.

In the end Michael Fassbender got the part, only to see the film get tossed into turnaround before it got picked up by Universal Pictures. Yes, it seems, stardom still matters.

More Film

  • John Boyega

    John Boyega on if He'll Do More 'Star Wars': 'You Ain't Going to Disney Plus Me!'

    If you know anything about “Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker,” it’s that the movie from director J.J. Abrams marks the official conclusion of the three-trilogy Skywalker Saga. But that does not necessarily mean that the characters created for the final trilogy — especially Rey (Daisy Ridley), Finn (John Boyega), and Poe Dameron (Oscar Isaac) [...]

  • Nathalia, Juan-pablo, Andrés (L-R)

    Magma Cine, Chemistry Unveil Strategic Production Alliance (EXCLUSIVE)

    Magma Cine, a pioneering company on the pan-Latin American co-production scene, and top Mexican post-production house Chemistry have sealed a strategic alliance to produce high-quality contents. Unveiled at Buenos Aires’ Ventana Sur, the partnership aims to respond to the strong appetite of regional OTT services as well as pan-regional studios, and forms part of an [...]

  • Agent M (Tessa Thompson) and Agent

    Karim Debbagh's Kasbah Films Lines Up 'Cherry,' 'The Forgiven,' 'Kidnapped' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Tapping into Morocco’s recently launched tax rebate, Karim Debbagh’s leading Tangier-based line producer Kasbah Films already has three major international productions in the pipeline for 2020. These include “Cherry” with Tom Holland, “The Forgiven” with Ralph Fiennes, a big-budget South Korean film “Kidnapped.” “Cherry” is an American crime drama film directed by Anthony and Joe [...]

  • Karnawal

    Juan Pablo Félix Debut ‘Karnawal’ Screens at Ventana Sur’s Primer Corte

    For his debut feature “Karnawal,” Juan Pablo Félix and his Bikini Films partner and executive producer Edson Sidonie recruited around the world for help in bringing to the big screen an original story about a young dancer, screening this week in Ventana Sur’s Primer Corte. Joining Argentina’s Bikini Films, Brazil’s 3 Moinhos Produçoes, Chile’s Picardía [...]

  • La Liga Presents: Ibero-American Animation Around

    France’s Annecy Intl. Animation Film Festival Joins ‘Los Amigos de La Liga’

    The Annecy Intl. Animation Film Festival will be part of Amigos de la Liga (Friends of the League), a new partnership initiative set up by La Liga, the animation alliance created to promote the Ibero-American animation sector worldwide, comprising Spain’s Quirino Awards, Argentina’s Animation! and Mexico’s Pixelatl Festival. The announcement was made at a panel [...]

  • The-Red-Tree

    ‘The Red Tree’ Director Joan Gómez on Telling Colombia’s Story Through Cinema

    Joan Gomez’s “El Arbol Rojo” (“The Red Tree”) is playing at Ventana Sur’s Films in Progress as it approaches the finish line of a years-long, international marathon of labs, markets and festivals which have gone a long way to establishing the film as one of the Argentine market’s most talked about in-progress titles. As a [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content