You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘The Pearl Button’

Patricio Guzman overreaches in trying to connect the genocide of Chile’s indigenous water nomads with Pinochet’s political murders.

Martin G. Calderon, Gabriela Paterito, Emma Malig, Gabriel Salazar, Claudio Mercado, Raul Zurita, Cristina Calderon, Adil Brkovic, Javier Rebolledo, Juan Molina, Raul Beas. (Spanish, Kawesqar dialogue)

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt4377864/reference

What “Nostalgia for the Light” did for the desert, “The Pearl Button” is meant to do for water, but the deft melding of past and present that characterized Patricio Guzman’s earlier film becomes muddied here by the Natural Science 101 voiceover and an unsatisfying bridge between two rather disparate subjects. On the one hand, there’s a fascinating discussion of the indigenous peoples who lived in the waterways of western Patagonia; on the other, the Pinochet dictatorship’s chilling practice of dumping political prisoners into the sea. Attractive images and involving subjects partly paper over gaps in connective tissue, but “Button” is unlikely to achieve a success equal to “Light.”

Considering that Chile boasts 2,670 miles of coastline, Guzman is right to question why a country with so much seafront has never capitalized on its maritime possibilities. Unsurprisingly, the answer lies in the nation’s colonial history: Chile did have five distinct ethnic groups whose life was intimately tied to the watery archipelagos of the south, but farmers and missionaries wiped them away. Now their languages, like Kawesqar and Yagan, are all but dead, and their culture a cherished memory among the few people who still recall 600-mile canoe trips between the islands.

Guzman interviews several of these elders, weaving in fascinating early 20th-century photographs by Martin Gusinde of the extinct Selk’nam people as well as ethnological films. The pic’s title comes from a short history lesson about Jemmy Button, a Yagan teen sold to a British naval captain in 1830 for a mother-of-pearl button (anthropologists may cringe at the line “He traveled from the Stone Age to the Industrial Age, and back”). Another button makes an appearance towards the docu’s end, but a sense of poetic closure feels forced.

Popular on Variety

Perhaps that’s because tying together the genocide of an entire race, whose way of life was sea-based, with the targeted murders of thousands of political dissidents simply doesn’t hold water. No one can (or should) fault Guzman for his vital insistence, throughout his long career, on ensuring that the crimes of the military dictatorship are never forgotten. Yet a re-creation of the horrific manner in which people, some still alive, were bagged, tied to pieces of railroad track, and dumped from helicopters into the sea belongs to another movie. A miniseries would perhaps be a better way to explore the complex relationship between Chile and its coastline, rather than a film that struggles to connect such unrelated subjects.

Guzman’s soporific voiceover, especially at the start, with too-basic information about how water arrived on earth, aims for a lyricism that feels forced. Does water, even in poetry, really retain a memory of the things and people it encounters? Surely, as John Keats so brilliantly expressed in his self-scribed epitaph “Here lies one whose name was writ in water,” aqueous substances obliterate traces left behind, and all that remains is but a chance survivor of nature’s inexorable eraser.

Visuals were shot on 2K digital, and while the lensing of Patagonia’s majestic, awe-inspiring glaciers is undeniably beautiful, the print viewed contains less of the staggering tonal ranges auds have come to expect from nature docus. Speculations about water in other solar systems, including CGI imaginings, are superfluous to the argument, and fantasizing about whether the indigenous peoples could have found safe haven in another galaxy is best left to the likes of H.G. Wells and Edgar Rice Burroughs.

Film Review: 'The Pearl Button'

Reviewed at Berlin Film Festival (competing), Feb. 7, 2015. Running time: 82 MIN. (Original title: "El boton de nacar")

Production: (Documentary — France-Chile-Spain) An Atacama Prods. presentation of an Atacama Prods., Valdivia Film, Mediapro, France 3 Cinema production, with the participation of France Televisions, CNC, Cine plus, WDR, RTS Radio Television Suisse. (International sales: Pyramide Intl., Paris.) Produced by Renate Sachse. Executive producer, Adrien Oumhani. Coproducers, Bruno Bettati, Fernando Lataste, Jaume Roures Llop.

Crew: Directed, written by Patricio Guzman. Camera (color, 2K), Katell Djian; editor, Emmanuelle Joly; music, Miranda & Tobar, Hughes Marechal; art director, Pamela Chamorro; sound, Alvaro Silva Wuth, Jean-Jacques Quinet.

With: Martin G. Calderon, Gabriela Paterito, Emma Malig, Gabriel Salazar, Claudio Mercado, Raul Zurita, Cristina Calderon, Adil Brkovic, Javier Rebolledo, Juan Molina, Raul Beas. (Spanish, Kawesqar dialogue)

More Film

  • The Cold Blue

    Erik Nelson Wants to Preserve the Past With 'The Cold Blue' World War II Documentary

    Erik Nelson describes his documentary “The Cold Blue” as “the garage band of movies” — he didn’t have the large team or crew other documentary contenders have. “The Cold Blue” is a World War II documentary that looks at raids and B-17 bombing missions that took place during the war. Nelson’s team looked at 34 [...]

  • Ray Manzarek

    Film News Roundup: Concert-Documentary 'The Doors: Break on Thru' Set for February

    In today’s film news roundup, one-night showings of a Ray Manzarek tribute and the season premiere of “Doctor Who” have been set for 2020, and the MPAA hires a copyright expert. ONE-NIGHT SHOWINGS The Doors and Trafalgar Releasing are teaming on the worldwide Feb. 12 release of “The Doors: Break on Thru – A Celebration [...]

  • Richard Jewell

    Warner Bros. Hits Back at Atlanta Paper Over 'Richard Jewell' Legal Threat

    Warner Bros. is standing behind “Richard Jewell,” the Clint Eastwood drama that is the source of controversy over its portrayal of a female journalist trading sex for scoops. The Atlanta Journal-Constitution sent a legal threat to the filmmakers on Monday asking them to include a disclaimer noting that the film took dramatic license. In a [...]

  • The Irishman

    'Captain Marvel,' 'The Irishman,' Other Original Scores to Miss Out on Oscar Nominations

    The Regina Spektor song from “Bombshell” and at least six major scores including “The Two Popes” and “The Irishman” won’t be on Oscar’s music shortlists when they are announced next week. That’s because none of them are on the official Academy eligibility lists from which music-branch members are now voting. Preliminary voting ends tomorrow afternoon, [...]

  • Golden Globes Zodiac signs

    Golden Globes Nominees as Zodiac Signs

    The Golden Globes nominees aren’t the only stars of awards season. Variety turned to astrology to assign Zodiac signs to this year’s nominees. Some selections required a little more nuance — Olivia Wilde’s “Booksmart” is a Virgo with a prominent Sagittarius rising and Greta Gerwig’s “Little Women” is a Sagittarius that wishes it were a [...]

  • Two-time Oscar®-winner Tom Hanks portrays one

    How Production Designer Jade Healy Recreated the Beautiful Neighborhood of Mister Rogers

    Production designer Jade Healy is doing double duty this awards season. For one, her work can be seen in Noah Baumbach’s “Marriage Story.” There, she created a world of angst and individuality, making use of negative space as a couple reaches the end of their relationship. In Marielle Heller’s “A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood,” [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content