You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Hollywood Can’t Seem to Crack Marvel’s ‘Fantastic Four’

For years, the Fantastic Four immodestly bore the title “The World’s Greatest Comic Magazine.” Introduced in 1961, the title ushered in the age of Marvel Comics, inaugurating the creative explosion of writer Stan Lee and artist Jack Kirby, which has been compared in musical terms to John Lennon and Paul McCartney during the Beatles’ heyday.

All of that makes the rather tortured history of the franchise onscreen, especially given the current ascent of comicbook blockbusters, all the more perplexing — most recently with Fox’s reboot “Fantastic Four,” which comes eight years after the last live-action “Fantastic Four” effort, a sequel subtitled “Rise of the Silver Surfer.”

Not only has the newest project been bludgeoned by critics, but the director, Josh Trank, responded by implying that the studio, 20th Century Fox, was responsible for its failings. Whatever the underlying truth, for comicbook fans it raises the specter of the bad old days, when studios abused comics by refusing to take the source material seriously.

Granted, a lot has changed since then. “The Avengers” assembled and exploded, “Iron Man” took off, even “Guardians of the Galaxy” went into orbit. Yet while the Fantastic Four held its own against alien races like the Skrulls and the Kree, it has yet to win a battle with Hollywood.

So why hasn’t anybody been able to successfully tackle “Fantastic Four,” which was not only a groundbreaking comic — predating Spider-Man, the Hulk and a host of Marvel titles that followed — but arguably more enjoyable to read than most of them? For those reasons, it’s a question that rankles comicbook fans more than most, despite Marvel’s other cinematic triumphs.

Of course, the fact that Fox is distributing the movie speaks in part to the property’s complicated past, having been parceled off (along with X-Men and Spider-Man) during a period in the mid-1990s in which Marvel declared bankruptcy. Ill-conceived rights deals yielded a low-budget 1994 Roger Corman movie that was never released, and a 1978 Saturday-morning animated series that had to make do without the Human Torch, since the character had been separately optioned for a movie. The replacement, padding out the foursome: comic-relief sidekick H.E.R.B.I.E. the Robot, which, in terms of teeth-gnashing names in comicbook and genre circles, was an early precursor to Jar Jar Binks.

Notably, many of the perceived hurdles to adapting Fantastic Four have been overcome elsewhere. Both “X-Men” and “Avengers” demonstrated it was possible to do movies featuring super-powered teams, after comicbook-based projects devoted to relative loners like Batman and Superman. The characters in “X-Men” and “Avengers” also squabbled and dealt with personal issues, a hallmark of the Lee-Kirby collaboration, which as a consequence felt more real and relevant to young readers when their work took the industry by storm.

The Fantastic Four were also notable in that, unlike most superheroes, they didn’t bother with secret identities. Indeed, the fact that everyone knew who they were — and that they suffered occasional indignities and intrusions associated with fame — was a regular aspect of the stories, and a frequent source of humor. If ever a superhero group seemed well suited to the age of TMZ, it’s this one — not that you’d know it from the latest movie, which is heavily rooted in the quartet’s origins.

The obvious argument is that Marvel, since taking control of its own destiny, has simply done all this better, exhibiting a love for and respect toward the source material that was, historically, often lacking. The studio’s interlocking world, its Marvel universe, has become an organic entity that supports and buttresses even the lesser titles.

Even so, “X-Men” has managed to flourish without that umbrella. And Fantastic Four possessed a rich-enough array of ancillary characters that it should have had the heft to stand on its own.

In hindsight, the crucial breakdown might have come not so much with director Tim Story’s 2005 movie, which did just well enough at the box office to warrant a sequel, but that second film. Afforded the opportunity to incorporate the Silver Surfer and the Galactus saga — as good a comics arc as Marvel might have produced during that period — the filmmakers fumbled, compounding errors from the first film as opposed to cleaning them up and improving them.

So instead of the “Fantastic Four” movie that Marvel fans had long anticipated, they had to settle for another disappointment, followed by this eight-year wait to see a reboot that falls short, creatively speaking, for an entirely different list of reasons.

Some have spoken of “Fantastic Four” as a cursed property in terms of its screen life, but that gets at the “what” without really answering the “why.” What does seem clear is that barring an unforeseen outpouring of interest from those who can’t readily recite the Thing’s battle cry, the ship for this signature Marvel property appears to have sailed.

While comic books can — and frequently have — hit the reset button, exploring alternate scenarios and universes, when it comes to movie franchises that cost more than $100 million to produce, there are only so many bites at the apple or trips into orbit. Just ask Green Lantern. Because whatever the complicated mix of factors that has hobbled Fantastic Four, the bottom line is that Hollywood has once again made the “World’s Greatest Comic Magazine” look perfectly ordinary.

More TV

  • ‘Gentleman Jack’ Gets Season 2 at

    ‘Gentleman Jack’ Renewed for Season 2 at BBC, HBO

    “Gentleman Jack” will return to TV screens on both sides of the Atlantic after the BBC and HBO ordered a second season of the period drama. The series is based on a true story and stars Suranne Jones as Anne Lister, a lesbian, and the proprietor of her family’s coal mines. She has to walk [...]

  • Jane Austin SAG AFTRA

    SAG-AFTRA Secretary-Treasurer Jane Austin Running for President

    Jane Austin, the National Secretary-Treasurer of SAG-AFTRA, has become the third candidate for the presidency of the performers union, joining incumbent Gabrielle Carteris and Matthew Modine. Austin is running as an independent for the top post at SAG-AFTRA, which has 160,000 members. Carteris will seek re-election as the head of the ticket for the Unite [...]

  • Vida

    Why Too Much TV Can Be a Good Thing (Column)

    Three episodes into the second season of “Vida,” there’s a wedding so gloriously and specifically queer that I almost couldn’t believe my eyes. After watching countless couples walk down the aisle onscreen before, Starz’s “Vida” takes care to show a ceremony quite unlike any other, featuring drag queens, a pair of Latinx grooms in bedazzled [...]

  • Emmys: Peak TV Meets Peak FYC

    Emmys: Peak TV Meets Peak FYC With Activations and Experiences

    As the number of Emmy contenders continues to skyrocket in this era of too much choice, “For Your Consideration” events are evolving into full-fledged experiential activations. The traditional Emmy screenings and panel discussions are still around — and have grown to a point that the Television Academy now allows competing events on the same day. [...]


    TV Ratings: ABC's 'Live in Front of a Studio Audience' Easily Tops Wednesday

    The ABC special “Live in Front of a Studio Audience” handily walked away with Wednesday night in the overnight ratings. “Live in Front of a Studio Audience” pulled in a 1.7 rating in adults 18-49 and 10.4 million viewers. For comparison, its closest competition in the demo were the season finales of “Chicago Med” and [...]

  • Star Trek: Picard - Logo ©

    'Star Trek: Picard' Drops First Teaser Trailer, Poster (Watch)

    CBS All Access has released the first look at “Star Trek: Picard,” the new series that will see Sir Patrick Stewart reprise the iconic role of Jean-Luc Picard. Little is known about the plot of the series other than it is said to tell the story of the next chapter of Picard’s life. Stewart played [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content