×

Editors Cut Up Over Film Length Debate

Opinion is divided on James Bond’s latest action-stuffed outing, “Spectre” — yet there’s one point on which most viewers seem to agree. At 148 minutes — the longest running time in the series’ history — it could probably stand a bit of cutting.

“Spectre” is not alone. Two-hour-plus running times were once the general preserve of epic event spectacles, hard art cinema and prestige dramas, not multiplex entertainment and series entries. Yet the average running time of 2015’s top 10 U.S. grossers is 122 minutes.

That crop includes “The Hunger Games: Mockingjay — Part 2,” the latest product of the recently popular trend of splitting final series chapters across two films — half a movie, in effect, yet still 137 minutes long.

While certain films’ narratives need such space to unfurl, it’s hard to argue that in other cases: several pictures deep into their franchises, why do the “Fast & Furious” and “Mission: Impossible” films require over 130 minutes to cover minimal new ground?

Viewers can answer these questions all too easily from the comfort of their seats. For editors, however, arriving at the optimum running time involves trickily juggling directors’ visions, producers’ demands, audience preferences and instinctive sensitivity to the script.

“A movie is a shared dream between an audience, where you live a character’s life,” says “Room” editor and Independent Spirit Award nominee Nathan Nugent. “That’s not always best-served in 90 minutes. In ‘Room,’ we took our time in the first act exploring the characters’ space. But in the last act of a film, you need to be more to the point, to make more satisfying leaps in time, more elegant story weaves. It should never have the same shape as the first.”

For “Steve Jobs” editor Elliot Graham, the challenge was balancing the three equally weighted acts of Aaron Sorkin’s exactingly structured script. “Usually a film starts, builds and ends,” says Graham. “It’s hard to ask an audience to complete a story, wait, invest in beginning another one, and do so three times — it was a unique challenge. But that drive to lean into the pacing, in addition to addressing pitfalls, helped to bring down the running time while also creating a unique momentum that became a part of the language of the film.”

Working from a 180-page script, Graham defied the “page a minute” metric that is often cited as an industry rule of thumb, but doesn’t necessarily apply to heavily dialogue-driven movies or to sparser, more ambient ones. Working with an example of the latter in Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu’s “The Revenant,” Oscar-winning editor Stephen Mirrione found the greatest challenge was in maintaining the film’s unrelenting atmosphere — as opposed to multi-stranded films like“Traffic” and “Babel,” which afford more storytelling variations — without it seeming monotonous.

“All the scenes took on the same rhythm — one the camera was creating out of technical necessity, but it was starting to pervade the whole movie. And when everything’s the same rhythm, you don’t feel like you’re moving,” Mirrione explains. A longtime Inarritu collaborator, Mirrione brought the film’s running time down by degrees, in dialogue with the director as he shifted out of a shooting “headspace” — a gradual process given the film’s labored shoot.

For Mick Audsley, editor of Baltasar Kormakur’s true-life mountaineering thriller “Everest,” there was less negotiation involved: he and the helmer made an early pact that the film couldn’t run more than two hours: “Because the subject matter was so emotionally intense, it couldn’t sustain beyond that,” he says. “It wouldn’t be right to put the audience through an emotional ordeal and an endurance test of length.”

Joe Walker, editor of Denis Villeneuve’s “Sicario,” brings up a different commercial concern — one that bumps up running times, rather than the reverse.

Adds Walker, “100 to 120 minutes just feels right for the scope of the stories we are telling. Stray under 90 or 100 minutes and you risk entering the not-giving-value-for-money zone.”

Nugent agrees, citing small-screen competition as a factor: “The quality of TV drama has risen so much that people feel movies should give you more bang for your buck.” Certainly giving the audience a lot in that respect is Fred Raskin, editor of Quentin Tarantino’s 178-minute “roadshow,” “The Hateful Eight.” “I’m certainly setting myself up for potshots by saying this,” he says, “but a moody three-hour-long picture with well-developed characters and a storyline that engages from beginning to end is often more right than a 105-minute picture with cardboard-cutout characters and an overly truncated narrative.”

Shot on Ultra Panavision 70, Tarantino’s film is a famously old-school contraption. But has the digitization of filmmaking also encouraged longer running times? Audsley believes so, not least because technology has given editors more material to work with than ever before: “Rushes are now in excess of five to six hours a day; when we were working with film, you’d get 30-40 minutes since it was so expensive to process,” he says. “In many ways that’s good: It makes people looser, more open to experimentation. But maybe we’re not as disciplined as we used to be.”

Digital editing, meanwhile, means editors can retrieve previously excised material far more easily than before. Do running times swell with too much second-guessing? Perhaps, says Nugent. “Technology allows you to go back on those first-cut decisions. Back when it was harder to undo things, editors made braver storytelling decisions.”

More Film

  • Promise at Dawn Calcoa

    Colcoa French Film Festival Moves to the Fall With Revamped Format

    Colcoa, the Los Angeles-based French film festival, will be hosting its 23rd edition in September, right before the start of the awards season. Created by the Franco-American Cultural Fund, Colcoa will also be showcasing a more contained lineup focused on film and TV at the Directors Guild of America’s newly-renovated venue. The festival was previously [...]

  • Bruce Springsteen FYSEE Opening Night with

    Bruce Springsteen-Codirected 'Western Stars' Film Will Premiere in Toronto

    “Western Stars,” the film that Bruce Springsteen has made to accompany his recent album of the same name, will have its world premiere at the Toronto International Film Festival, it was announced Tuesday. The feature is being listed as a co-directing project between Springsteen and his longtime filmic collaborator, Thom Zimny, who just picked up [...]

  • Sylvester Stallone and Braden Aftergood Balboa

    Sylvester Stallone's Production Company Wants to Be the Blumhouse of Action Films

    “I don’t believe Sylvester Stallone carries around a wallet,” says Braden Aftergood, the executive in charge of scripted development at the movie star’s content company Balboa Prods. It’s not that Sly, as he’s known to friends and fans alike, is trying to duck out on a dinner bill. He never seems to have his license [...]

  • Toronto Film Festival Lineup

    Toronto Film Festival: 'Joker,' 'Ford v Ferrari,' 'Hustlers' Among Big Premieres

    This year’s Toronto Film Festival will feature super-villain origin stories, splashy literary adaptations, and Tom Hanks as the most beloved performer in children’s television. The Canadian celebration of all things movies unveiled its 2019 lineup on Tuesday, and it appears to be an eclectic mixture of glossy awards bait, auteur-driven indies, and populist crowd-pleasers. It’s [...]

  • Sylvester Stallone Variety Cover story

    Sylvester Stallone Feels Robbed of an Ownership Stake in 'Rocky': 'I Was Furious'

    Sylvester Stallone shares an uncanny, symbiotic connection with Rocky, the underdog boxer character he created four decades ago — a kindred spirit who served as his creative muse in spawning one of Hollywood’s most successful film franchises. In his long career Stallone also played another memorable screen role — John Rambo — but Rocky was [...]

  • Beware of Children

    First Trailer Released for Venice Days Entry 'Beware of Children' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Variety has been given exclusive access to the first trailer for Dag Johan Haugeruds’ politically and socially charged drama “Beware of Children,” which premieres as part of the Venice Film Festival’s Venice Days section. The pic, which is being sold at Venice by Picture Tree Intl., features the dramatic aftermath of a tragic incident in [...]

  • The Tower animated film about Palestinians

    ‘The Tower’ Animation Wins Japan's Skip City Festival

    “The Tower,” Mats Grorud’s animation about the plight of the Palestinians, as viewed through the eyes of an 11-year-old girl in Beirut, won the grand prize in the international competition at the 16th edition of Skip City International D-Cinema Festival. The film also scooped the section’s audience award. The Skip City festival, which launched in [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content