You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

‘Brooklyn’ and ‘Youth’: A Tale of Searchlight’s Contrasting Contenders

How will this one shake out as both films re-emerge in Toronto?

Since acquiring John Crowley’s “Brooklyn” at the Sundance Film Festival, Fox Searchlight has been preoccupied. First came the summer counter-programming releases of “Far from the Madding Crowd” and another Sundance pick-up, “Me and Earl and the Dying Girl.” Then came “Youth,” acquired at the Cannes fest, with stars like Michael Caine, Harvey Keitel and Jane Fonda. The studio dropped Davis Guggenheim’s documentary “He Named Me Malala” in Telluride and ended up in a long game with “Brooklyn” as the reigning back-to-back best picture champ’s awards slate started filling out.

For a time, “Youth” seemed to me like a great bet for the season. A story about aging artists looking back on life, seen through the kaleidoscopic lens of Oscar-winning maestro Paolo Sorrentino (“The Great Beauty”), it could absolutely appeal to older voters. Searchlight brought the film to Toronto just four months after its world bow on the Croisette, but with “Brooklyn” coming back out into the light a full eight months later itself, I’m left wondering if it represents the bigger opportunity.

Unlike “Youth,” Crowley’s film is very even-handed. It never goes for overt emotion when it certainly could, never takes the bait of steering the Colm Tóibín adaptation (deftly handled by screenwriter Nick Hornby) into tragedy when you’re almost anticipating it. It remains, front to back, an absorbing character study featuring Saoirse Ronan’s finest work to date, another reminder that Emory Cohen (“The Place Beyond the Pines”) is one of the most exciting actors of his generation and a bevy of craft accomplishments — from eye-popping costumes and sets to gorgeous photography to an evocative score — that puts it, in my view, on the top of the Searchlight pile.

“Youth” has its moments. But they feel fleeting within a frenzied mixture, inspired only in bursts. What will help a film like that, however, is passion. There may be plenty who recoil at Sorrentino’s overt flourishes, but its lovers will defend it, meaning it will get a fair share of number one votes on the preferential ballot. “Brooklyn,” on the other hand, will be a broader sell. It will appeal to many different types, and that could be key to its own bid for success.

So keep an eye on this as the months tick by. Like taking on “Shame” in 2011, “Youth” represented an opportunity for Searchlight to jump into business with a talented filmmaker. And that will absolutely pay dividends. But I’m not convinced this one can survive as a best picture play. Caine’s performance is wonderful but reserved. The photography is striking but labored. Fonda’s work is boisterous and, actually, just the kind of element I could see representing the film on the whole come Oscar night. But “Brooklyn” hits all of its marks with an ease that makes it a more attractive option on the whole.

Or maybe, to the delight of the studio, it won’t have to be an either/or proposition at the end of the day. Whatever happens, they couldn’t have asked for two more contrasting contenders to work with, that’s for sure.

Popular on Variety

More Film

  • Johnnie To Quits Taiwan Golden Horse

    Johnnie To Quits Golden Horse Awards as China Builds Pressure

    Leading Hong Kong film maker Johnnie To has dropped out of the Golden Horse Awards, where he was set to be president of the jury deciding the prize winners. The awards, which take place and are organized from Taiwan, have long been considered the most prestigious prized in Chinese-language cinema. However they are currently under [...]

  • Zeroville

    Film Review: 'Zeroville'

    I’m tired of hearing how some novels are “impossible to adapt.” Balderdash! Just because some books don’t lend themselves to being translated from page to screen doesn’t mean that the attempt ought not to be made. Just ask James Franco, who’s shown a speed freak’s determination to tackle some of the unlikeliest literary adaptations of [...]

  • Red Penguins review

    Toronto Film Review: 'Red Penguins'

    “Red Penguins” is a cautionary tale with particular resonance in the context of our current bizarre intertwining with Russia, the country that interfered in the last U.S. presidential election and is led by the POTUS’ apparent BFF. This wild tale of attempted transnational commerce just after the demise of the USSR in the 1990s chronicles [...]

  • Danny Ramirez'On My Block' TV show

    Danny Ramirez to Star in Film Adaptation of 'Root Letter' Video Game (EXCLUSIVE)

    An English-language film adaptation of Japanese video game “Root Letter,” starring Danny Ramirez, is in production in the U.S. through Akatsuki Entertainment USA. Besides Ramirez (“Top Gun: Maverick,” “Assassination Nation”), the film stars Keana Marie (“Huge in France,” “Live in Pieces”) and Lydia Hearst (“The Haunting of Sharon Tate,” “Z Nation”). With a screenplay by [...]

  • Screen writer Beau WillimonMary Queen of

    Beau Willimon Re-Elected as President of Writers Guild of America East

    Beau Willimon, the playwright and showrunner who launched Netflix’s “House of Cards,” has been re-elected without opposition to a two-year term as president of the Writers Guild of America East. Willimon also ran unopposed in 2017 to succeed Michael Winship. Kathy McGee was elected to the vice president slot over Phil Pilato. Secretary-treasurer Bob Schneider [...]

  • Running With the Devil review

    Film Review: 'Running With the Devil'

    A retired Navy SEAL who for a time was a military advisor on the Colombian drug trade, Jason Cabell conceived his first solo feature as writer-director to tell the story of that particular commerce “from the point of view of the drugs.” The result isn’t exactly a docudrama indictment like “Traffic,” a thriller a la [...]

  • Sweetheart review

    Blumhouse's 'Sweetheart' Sets October Digital Release From Universal (EXCLUSIVE)

    After making waves at this year’s Sundance Film Festival, the Blumhouse project “Sweetheart” is set to hit digital and on demand platforms. Universal Pictures Home Entertainment will offer the film on all major streaming hubs and paid video on demand come Oct. 22, unleashing the creature feature which stars Kiersey Clemons in a harrowing tale [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content