×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

It’s Time to Fix Social Influencers’ ‘Bad Neighbor’ Problem (Guest Column)

Too many claim to represent content creators, which confuses brands

If “good fences make good neighbors,” as Robert Frost’s poem “Mending Wall” suggests, then the content creator/social influencer space is a really bad neighborhood.

Regretfully, I’m spending a lot of times these days dealing with bad corporate “neighbors” and the consequences of their actions.

Social platforms and the content creators building their businesses on them have created a fast-growing ecosystem of new companies and new business models: multichannel, or multiplatform networks (i.e. Maker Studios, Kin Community), automated marketplace platforms (i.e. Famebit, Reelio) and social agencies (i.e. theAudience, DBA). Presently, much of the ecosystem is fueled by brand dollars trying to capitalize on the unprecedented levels of engagement and “influence” creators have with their audiences.

Every new “neighbor” in the social influence marketplace thinks they have the right to represent content creators to brands, but most don’t. “Neighbors” include agents, managers, social ad agencies, websites, publishers, MCNs/MPNs, the guy down the street, etc. While many have the best long-term interest of content creators in mind, a large number have an opportunistic, short-term view and think that content creators are commodities.

As demand for brand content involving social influence goes up, it’s only going to get worse. Brands are dealing with rampant online ad fraud and a lack of options to get their content viewed by an engaged, scaled audience. The solution: Call in the influencers! And every Tom, Dick and Harry is now down with the hustle. Here’s how it works:

— A “neighbor” receives a RFP (request for proposal) from a brand or their agency that requires some “social activation,” which means getting a content creator to promote the brands product through videos and/or social posts

— The sales person from “neighbor” company puts together an “awesome” proposal with media, brand content and a “prospective” talent list.

— If the company putting the proposal together has the “exclusive media and brand content sales rights” to sell campaigns on behalf of the content creator, job well done.

— Sometimes one “neighbor” will ask another friendly “neighbor” who represents different creators if they would be willing to include one of their creators in a pitch. It takes trust, good working relationships and lots of communication for it to work, but I’ve seen this approach be successful.

— Here’s where the problem starts: many contracts with content creators are poorly constructed and have exclusivity “loopholes.” Often agreements allow for the creator’s agent and/or manager to field in-bound sales offers. This loophole allows for pretty much anyone to “sell” a social influencer, creating a lot of chaos in the advertising marketplace.

— What makes matters worse is that, even when contracts with creators are well-executed, exclusive and without ambiguity, opportunistic companies take advantage and represent influencers to brands with full knowledge of the aforementioned legal contracts.

What can seem like easy money in the short-term will end up destroying content creators long-term viability and reputation. I have experienced brands and agencies getting irate with the process of signing up creators for brand content campaigns.

The mess is rooted in a general misunderstanding of what a content creator is. They are more than mere talent; they are the host, producer, editor and network. Content creators are more akin to media companies then they are to talent.

Media companies, whether they are NBC, AOL or Kin Community, have invested a large amount of time and money building a sales team to work with brands. Could you imagine if ABC went into the marketplace and started representing NBC’s shows to brands? It would never happen. And yet this is what is happening everyday in the world of content creators.

Because content creators are mistakenly considered talent, people in our industry think they can just call up their agent and manager and get them to participate in a brand deal for the right price.

The truth is creators would be best served if they had just one sales team selling them to brands. I don’t have a strong point of view on what type of company that should be. It could be a talent agency, MCN, publisher, whoever.

Here’s my prescription for how to make “good fences” for the social influencer space and ultimately create a happier, more valuable neighborhood:

— The leading players in the social influencer/content creator space need to come together and draw up new rules of engagement: a Bill of Rights for social influence representation.

— Content creators, regardless of what platform you are on, should have one – and only one – sales team representing their media and brand content opportunities exclusively in the market.

— Content creators should have agents and/or managers if they need help evaluating and negotiating opportunities. Traditional agents and/or managers are incredibly valuable when negotiating traditional media opportunities, i.e. TV, movies, books.

— Brands and their agencies should not assume that anyone is able to secure social influencers at the lowest price for their brand content campaigns. If you suspect someone is misrepresenting creators, ask to see their contract with the creators or demand to speak with the creators directly.

— Neighbors who think they can sell a brand content deal and then just “get the talent” through the creator’s manager and/or agent, stop and think before you do this.

There are many talented creators and executives working hard to build a respectable and valuable marketplace for social content. If people do the right thing, and create “good fences,” we can build a neighborhood Mister Rogers would be proud of.

Please email me if you would like to discuss cleaning up the neighborhood.

Michael Wayne is the co-founder and CEO of Kin Community, a leading digital media company that empowers women’s lifestyle creators.

More Digital

  • Jorge-Franco-and-Adrian-Suar

    Pol-ka Expands Outside Argentina, Optioning ‘El Cielo a Tiros’ (EXCLUSIVE)

    PAMPLONA, Spain  —  Taking a new expansive step as an international content player, top Argentine production house Pol-ka, has optioned small-screen rights to “El cielo a tiros,” the latest novel from “Rosario Tijeras” author, Colombian novelist Jorge Franco. Pacted via Scenic Rights, the deal sees Pol-ka planning to shoot a drama series based on the [...]

  • Tencent Music presentation at Shanghai

    Shanghai: Tencent Proposes Alliance of Music and Film

    All tech companies strive to be ubiquitous. Within China, behemoth Tencent is a clear leader of the pack. From the company’s “pan entertainment strategy” in 2012 to its 2018 equivalent “neo-creativity strategy,” Tencent keeps unveiling new master plans, each time with more in-house platforms and business approaches involved. On the margins of the Shanghai International [...]

  • Genius Spars With Google Over Lyric

    Genius Accuses Google of Scraping Song Lyrics, Music Data Company Hits Back

    Lyrics annotation service Genius.com has accused Google of scraping its site and stealing its content, the Wall Street Journal reported this weekend. However, a lyrics data provider at the center of the controversy claimed on Monday that those allegations were without merit. The Journal reported that Genius had been complaining to Google about the alleged [...]

  • littlstar ps4 app

    Littlstar Expands Beyond VR With New PS4 App, Signs Up 30,000 Paying Subscribers (EXCLUSIVE)

    A&E-backed immersive content aggregator Littlstar is expanding beyond virtual reality (VR): The New York-based startup launched a dedicated PlayStation4 app this week, giving users of Sony’s game console access to their personal media libraries, as well as both traditional and 360-degree video content from a variety of publishers. Littlstar also announced that it signed up [...]

  • Game of Thrones Season 8 Production

    'Game of Thrones,' Netflix VFX Among Those to Be Featured in SIGGRAPH Production Talks

    VFX pros behind the final season of “Game of Thrones,” the blockbuster film “Avengers: Endgame,” Pixar’s upcoming “Toy Story 4,” last year’s Oscar-winning “Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse,” Netflix series, including “Stranger Things,” and more will give SIGGRAPH 2019 attendees a behind-the-scenes look at their work during the conference’s Production Sessions. There will even be a [...]

  • Patrick Drahi

    Altice's Patrick Drahi to Acquire Sotheby's Auction House for $3.7 Billion

    Patrick Drahi, the owner of the telecom group Altice, is on track to purchase Sotheby’s, the high-profile auction house, for $3.7 billion. The acquisition would turn Sotheby’s into a privately owned concern after 31 years as a publicly listed company on the New York Stock Exchange. Drahi said the acquisition had “no capital link with Altice [...]

  • Soundgarden’s Immersive 'Artists Den' Experience Premieres

    Soundgarden’s Immersive 'Artists Den' Experience Premieres This Week (Exclusive Preview)

    There’s no question that the posthumous release is the most difficult to get right: Human beings are unpredictable, and trying to guess what a person’s intentions might have been is an uphill (if not a losing) battle. Yet posthumous releases ranging from Michael Jackson’s “This Is It” to recent Prince and Jimi Hendrix collections prove [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content