×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Netflix Data Reveals Exactly When TV Shows Hook Viewers — And It’s Not the Pilot

Netflix crunched cold, hard viewing data for more than two dozen TV shows and says it has determined which specific episode grabbed most subscribers to the point where they watched the entire first season.

However, none of the shows Netflix looked at, which included originals and licensed series, hooked viewers with the pilot. In fact, two shows — “Arrow” and “How I Met Your Mother” — didn’t hit the tipping point until episode 8. In the traditional TV biz, conventional wisdom holds that a show’s pilot is the most critical linchpin to igniting viewer interest, given the nature of how new television programs debut.

But don’t get the wrong idea: Netflix has no plans to use Big Data to rejigger the way TV shows get made, in order to put the strongest emotional hooks earlier in a season (which would result in more viewing by subscribers). Instead, the company sees the metrics as validation of its binge-release strategy of delivering all episodes of a season at once.

“This won’t have any direct effect on the creative process for our showrunners/creators,” a Netflix rep explained.

Netflix pinpointed the episode for each show’s season 1 for which 70% of viewers who watched it went on to complete the entire run.

For example, in “Breaking Bad” season one, the “hook” was episode 2: the one in which Jesse Pinkman dissolves a drug rival in a bathtub — and the disintegrated remains crash down through the ceiling. For prison dramedy “Orange Is the New Black” (pictured above), which Netflix execs have said is the service’s most-watched original series, it’s episode 3. That’s when Crazy Eyes (Uzo Aduba, who just won a Primetime Emmy for the role) drops both poems and fluids in the course of her imagined romance with Piper (Taylor Schilling).

See More: Binge-Viewing Is Becoming a Less Shameful Activity: Survey

“Given the precious nature of primetime slots on traditional TV, a series pilot is arguably the most important point in the life of the show,” Netflix chief content officer Ted Sarandos said. “However, in our research of more than 20 shows across 16 markets, we found that no one was ever hooked on the pilot. This gives us confidence that giving our members all episodes at once is more aligned with how fans are made.”

Netflix found slight geographic differences in the “hook” study. For example, Germans showed early fandom for “Arrow” whereas French viewers were hooked earlier on “How I Met Your Mother” than the worldwide average.

For the study, Netflix analyzed data from accounts of subs who started watching season one of the selected series between January and July 2015 in Brazil, Belgium, Canada, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Ireland, Mexico, Netherlands, Norway, Sweden, the U.K. and the U.S., and between April and July 2015 for Australia and New Zealand. The company noted that the hooked episode had no correlation to overall viewership numbers or viewer attrition for a particular series.

Here’s the full list of shows Netflix analyzed, with the number of the episode when 70% of viewers were hooked (all series are the first seasons):

  • “Arrow”* – Episode 8
  • “Bates Motel” – Episode 2
  • “Better Call Saul”* – Episode 4
  • “Bloodline” – Episode 4
  • “BoJack Horseman” – Episode 5
  • Breaking Bad”* – Episode 2
  • “Daredevil” – Episode 5
  • “Dexter”* – Episode 3
  • “Gossip Girl” – Episode 3
  • “Grace & Frankie” – Episode 4
  • “How I Met Your Mother” – Episode 8
  • “House of Cards”* – Episode 3
  • “Mad Men”* – Episode 6
  • “Marco Polo” – Episode 3
  • Orange Is the New Black” – Episode 3
  • “Once Upon A Time” – Episode 6
  • “Pretty Little Liars” – Episode 4
  • “Scandal” – Episode 2
  • “Sense8″* – Episode 3
  • “Sons of Anarchy”* – Episode 2
  • “Suits”* – Episode 2
  • “The Blacklist”* – Episode 6
  • “The Killing” – Episode 2
  • “The Walking Dead”* – Episode 2
  • “Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt” – Episode 4

* Denotes series that are not currently available in all Netflix territories.

Popular on Variety

More Digital

  • Patreon

    After Paying Out $1 Billion to Creators, Patreon Sets Its Sights on Europe

    Membership services startup Patreon has paid out over $1 billion to creators since its launch in 2013, the company announced Tuesday. Now, Patreon is getting ready for an international expansion, with a particular focus on Europe, Patreon’s senior vice president of product Wyatt Jenkins told Variety. In addition to the $1 billion payout milestone, Patreon [...]

  • David Nevins, President & CEO of

    CBS Creative Chief David Nevins on His Plans to Compete With HBO Max

    Appearing at Recode’s Code Media conference in Los Angeles on Monday afternoon, CBS chief creative officer David Nevins didn’t hold back criticizing one of his biggest competitors: “If you are going to put out one main product, you have to be as mainstream as you can,” Nevins said about WarnerMedia’s plans for HBO Max. Minutes [...]

  • Amazon Music Free

    Amazon Music Expands Access to Free Streaming Service, Spotify Stock Falls

    The free version of Amazon’s music-streaming service is now available across more platforms, bolstering competition with Spotify’s free tier. Starting Monday, Amazon said, customers can now listen to Amazon Music’s ad-supported selection of top playlists and thousands of stations for free. It’s available to anyone in the U.S., U.K. and Germany who doesn’t have a [...]

  • John T. Stankey WarnerMedia CEO

    WarnerMedia CEO John Stankey on Early Disney Plus Success: 'Good for Them'

    WarnerMedia CEO John Stankey told the audience of Recode’s Code Media conference in Los Angeles Monday that Disney “did a good job” with Disney Plus, which announced that it reached 10 million sign-ups the day after the service’s launch. “Good for them,” Stankey said. “They are off to a good start.” However, he also cautioned [...]

  • Google Stadia

    Google Stadia Reviews: Game-Streaming Service Not Ready for Primetime

    The first takes on Google Stadia, the internet giant’s new game-streaming service that debuts Nov. 19, are out. And the consensus is that Stadia is needed more time in the oven before it was served up to the gaming crowd. Google’s big promise with Stadia is that players can access top-tier game titles without a [...]

  • 60 Minutes" reporter Lara Logan takes

    Lara Logan Will Host Fox Nation Documentary Series

    Lara Logan made a name for herself by reporting from global trouble spots for CBS News. Soon, she will be holding forth on a four-part docuseries for Fox Nation, the Fox News streaming-video service. Logan will present “No Agenda,” which will debut in January on Fox Nation, and is produced by Warm Springs Productions. She [...]

  • warnermedia lab hires

    WarnerMedia Hires Jeremy Toeman, Matthew Davis as Innovation Lab Execs (EXCLUSIVE)

    WarnerMedia is building out the leadership of its Innovation Lab: The AT&T-owned media company has hired Jeremy Toeman as vice president, technology and product, and Matthew Davis as vice president, creative. Both will be based in New York and report to WarnerMedia executive vice president Jesse Redniss, who is also the general manager of the [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content