×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Hollywood, Silicon Valley Sharpen Their Swords in Piracy War

The battle against online piracy may be shifting to movie streaming sites, but the PR war over tactics is still stuck in SOPA mode.

The Stop Online Piracy Act stalled out in early 2012, in the face of an unprecedented online protest, driven in part by tech congloms, that it would jeopardize the free flow of Internet content. But the specter of the battle still lingers. In recent months, Hollywood studios have been accused of attempting to revive the stalled legislation in a number of ways, most recently via legal maneuvering.

Last month, major studios sued MovieTube, an operator of a series of sites that stream pirated movies and TV shows, and sought a preliminary injunction that would require third parties to “cease or disable” services to the company. Google, Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr and Yahoo pushed back, contending in a court filing that the studios’ proposed injunction would be too sweeping in its scope. They fear it would set a precedent for other cases, and bind service providers to the litigation.

In a proposed amicus brief, the tech companies said that the injunction being proposed “would require the same intermediaries targeted by SOPA to engage in the same kind of content- and domain-blocking that would have been required by SOPA had it been enacted.”

The studios have since dropped the injunction request after MovieTube pulled its sites.

But the the tech firms’ outcry was only the latest charge that other means were afoot to impose the failed legislation. The studios and tech companies each weighed in on an Intl. Trade Commission case over dental braces in which the ITC claimed authority to prevent patent-infringing 3D digital files from crossing borders, just as it would halt counterfeit physical goods. The studios argued that the intent of Congress was for trade law to protect U.S. industries “from all manner of unfair acts,” while the tech sector decried that notion as potentially allowing broad government oversight over Internet transmissions. The case is now before a federal appellate court.

On the state level, Google general counsel Kent Walker has labeled an investigation by Mississippi Attorney General Jim Hood into the company’s search practices as a studio attempt “to revive the failed SOPA legislation through other means.” And studios’ and labels’ calls for online registrars to better enforce piracy has raised the argument that the MPAA was leveraging the Internet Corp. for Assigned Named and Numbers to use the domain name system to enforce copyright law. The studios countered that their efforts have been distorted by “fringe tech groups.”

Studios have argued that they are merely trying to pursue an antipiracy strategy by applying laws already on the books.

Jonathan Lamy, spokesman for the Recording Industry Assn. of America, painted the anti-copyright forces as hypocrites. “During the SOPA debate, the common response was that existing law or agencies like the ITC were the appropriate ways to deal with overseas rogue websites,” he said. “Fast forward three years, and apparently those statements are ‘no longer operative.’ Our job is to hold them to their word.”

Some public interest groups say that there is good reason to sound the SOPA alarm over the current round of skirmishes: Leaked MPAA memos from the Sony hack showed that the studios were exploring a range of legal options, including court orders, that would require ISPs to quarantine infringing sites.

Sherwin Siy, vice president of legal affairs for the nonprofit Public Knowledge, says that while the term “SOPA” has been used as a rallying point for different issues since 2012, the recent cases are relevant, because they have to do with the idea of site blocking, which was “what motivated the SOPA protest in the first place.”

Citing the MovieTube case, Aaron Liskin of Kinsella Weitzman Iser Kump & Aldisert said that although the studios’ request for an injunction was “somewhat uncommon,” the fact that they don’t know who’s behind the website is an operative factor. Still, he allows, “The general rule of thumb is that injunctions bind parties (to litigation). Here Facebook and Yahoo are not parties.”

Studios are well aware that their moves risk being branded as “SOPA-like,” and it’s a reason no major antipiracy legislation has been pursued since 2012. They have been working on a counter-PR strategy, via groups like CreativeFuture — formerly the studio- and guild-backed Creative America — to try to mobilize the content community around the value of protecting creative works. But there’s also a recognition that getting that message ingrained in the minds of consumers is a long-term initiative.

Ruth Vitale, CEO of CreativeFuture, took to the group’s blog to mock what she saw as particularly alarmist reactions to the MovieTube case.

“I know that ‘stop censorship’ and ‘don’t break the Internet’ were effective talking points more than three years ago,” she wrote. “That’s the past, and a reference to legislative history. I think we’re all a bit wiser now. Can we finally collectively agree that piracy is not free speech?”

More Biz

  • Capitol Music Group Names Amber Grimes

    Capitol Music Group Names Amber Grimes Senior VP of Global Creative

    Amber Grimes has been named to the newly-created position of Senior Vice President of Global Creative for Capitol Music Group, it was announced today by Chairman & CEO Steve Barnett, to whom Grimes will report. According to the announcement, in her new position, Grimes will be integrally involved in formulating and executing the company’s global [...]

  • Kevin Hart

    Why Kevin Hart's Mea Culpa Was Too Little, Too Late (Opinion)

    Forgive me if this sounds trite or preachy, but the importance of owning up to our mistakes cannot be overstated. Denials, silence, cover-ups, repudiation — all are unacceptable. Media outlets around the globe, including ours, wrote about how Kevin Hart initially took no responsibility for having posted disgusting homophobic tweets years ago that resurfaced when [...]

  • Annie Lennox, Chrissie Hynde, Industry Execs

    Annie Lennox, Chrissie Hynde, Industry Execs Sign Anti-Brexit Letter

    Annie Lennox, Chrissie Hynde, Pink Floyd’s Nick Mason, Paloma Faith, Ed Sheeran manager Stuart Camp and Grammy/Emmy award-winning film composer David Arnold and several leading UK music industry bodies are among the signees of a letter drafted by the new organization Music4EU, stating that Brexit “represents a significant threat to the UK’s music industry” and [...]

  • Kevin Hart Oscars Gay Tweet Controversy

    What Public Figures Should Learn From the Kevin Hart Oscars Debacle

    When social media erupted over Kevin Hart’s anti-gay tweets from years ago, many in the media and the entertainment industry believed he would immediately apologize, LGBTQ people would critique but ultimately accept his mea culpa, and the comedian would go on to host the Academy Awards. If offenders make a commitment to do better, their [...]

  • Bob Bakish Variety Cover Story

    Inside Bob Bakish's Aggressive Turnaround Plan for Viacom

    Bob Bakish was days into his job as CEO of Viacom in late 2016 when he began convening meetings with senior executives to execute a triage effort to save the once-mighty media giant. Paramount Pictures had just posted a $445 million annual loss. Viacom’s cable networks were in danger of being dropped by major distributors [...]

  • Craig Hunegs WB

    Craig Hunegs to Exit Warner Bros. TV Group and Digital Networks (EXCLUSIVE)

    After nearly 25 years in the Warner Bros. family, Craig Hunegs is exiting his post as head of business for Warner Bros. TV Group and president of the studio’s digital networks wing. Hunegs said he has been discussing his exit with Warner Bros. chairman-CEO Kevin Tsujihara for the past several months. At a time of [...]

  • 'Walking Dead' Profits Dispute Heading to

    'Walking Dead' Profits Dispute Heading to Trial

    The long-running legal battle between Frank Darabont and AMC over profits from “The Walking Dead” will run a bit longer, as a judge ruled Monday that the case must go to trial. Darabont and CAA sued the network back in 2013, arguing he was deprived of $280 million in profit participation because AMC did not [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content