‘Halo 5,’ ‘Star Wars Battlefront’: Underperforming or Digital Sales Underestimated?

Video-game retailer GameStop reported Monday that new software sales were down 9.3 percent for the third quarter versus last year and that many high-profile games were underperforming.

But games like “Halo 5,” “Assassin’s Creed Syndicate” and the newly released “Star Wars Battlefront” may just be suffering from an underestimation of how much digital sales are driving their bottom line.

were not selling well based on what had been modeled by the company said GameStop CEO Paul Raines and GameStop president Tony Bartel in yesterday’s earnings call.

Regarding “Halo 5,” many believe that it’s digital sales – which GameStop sees no profit from – where much higher on a percentage basis. Microsoft  claimed “Halo 5” became the “best-selling digital game ever” during its launch week.

Take the discrepancy between Microsoft’s reported $400 million in sales for “Halo 5” and an NPD report that claimed the game only earned $119 million. GameStop president Tony Bartel  explained the variance by saying NPD only reports U.S. sales, didn’t include data from retailers, and  didn’t take into account two additional days of sales that Microsoft counted.

Bartel added there was no reason to believe the sci-fi shooter’s digital sales had exceeded estimations that digital would only comprise 20-25% of digital sales.

“We are in constant discussions with all publishers and platform-holders and we believe that all major full-game titles launched in this quarter were in line with previously announced digital download levels,” Bartel said.

Cowen & Company issued a note to investors following GameStop’s call stating the data was off and that GameStop was likely underselling the digital sales of “Halo 5.”

“We especially have a hard time believing that ‘Halo 5’ digital units remain in the 20-25% range, as GameStop management suggested on the call,” the report said. “GameStop gave some other potential reasons for the disconnect between NPD data and Microsoft’s post-launch press release, but we don’t believe they are sufficient to explain the size of the gap.”

The report went on to say that the underperformance of these games was likely because of digital downloads.

“It seems unlikely to us that what amounts to a buyers’ strike is really going on amidst the most powerful hardware cycle on record,” the report added. “We suspect that the average underperformance vs. their expectations is really being driven by an acceleration of digital downloads.”

Popular on Variety

More Digital

  • Elite Season 2

    San Sebastian: Spain’s SVOD Players Debate Competition, Brand, Talent

    SAN SEBASTIAN  — Executives from HBO, Netflix, Amazon and Movistar+ and “Elite” co-creator Darío Madrona took to the stage to field questions on the Global Impact of Spanish Series. Here, briefly, are five takeaways: 1.Spain First “La Casa de Papel” was watched by 34,355,956 Netflix accounts over its first seven days,  after a July 19 [...]

  • Tinder - Swipe Night

    Tinder's Apocalyptic 'Swipe Night' Interactive Dating Show Sets Release Date

    Tinder next month will bow its first original entertainment content — “Swipe Night,” an interactive adventure series in which viewers are forced to make dating choices on humanity’s last night on Earth. Variety previously reported details of the location-based social network/dating app service’s foray into original content, which recently wrapped production in Mexico City and [...]

  • Editorial Use onlyMandatory Credit: Photo by

    YouTube Rolls Back Verification Changes, Says Verified Creators Can Keep Their Badge

    A day after announcing significant changes to its verification program, YouTube announced Friday afternoon that it won’t be de-verifying existing creators after all. “We heard loud and clear how much the badge means to you,” said YouTube product manager Jonathan McPhie in a blog post. “Channels that already have the verification badge will now keep it [...]

  • BLive: BitTorrent Live Streaming App to

    BitTorrent to Launch Public Beta of New Live Streaming App

    BitTorrent is getting ready to open the floodgates for its new live streaming app, dubbed BitTorrent Live: The company plans to launch a BitTorrent Live Android app on various app stores as part of a public beta test late Friday, according to a spokesperson. BitTorrent Live, which is also known as BLive, is being described [...]

  • Netflix - Apple TV

    Netflix Stock Drops After CEO Acknowledges 'Tough Competition' Coming From Disney, Apple

    Netflix shares fell as much as 7% Friday to a nine-month low, coming after CEO Reed Hastings commented that the November launches of Disney Plus and Apple TV Plus will introduce a “whole new world” of competition. Hastings, speaking at the Royal Television Society conference Friday in Cambridge, England, said, “While we’ve been competing with [...]

  • Facebook

    Facebook Suspends Tens of Thousands of Apps During Privacy Investigation

    Facebook has suspended tens of thousands of apps ever since it began investigating potential privacy abuses, the company said Friday. The apps in question had been built by around 400 developers, and a suspension doesn’t necessarily indicate actual privacy violations. Facebook began combing through millions of apps that made use of its platform after the [...]

  • tivo logo

    Tivo Plans to Launch Android TV Dongle, Tivo+ Curation App

    DVR maker Tivo is getting ready to release a new device that may not record television at all: The company plans to launch a $50 Roku-like TV dongle early next year, its new CEO Dave Shull revealed in a conversation with CNN this week. The new device will be powered by Google’s Android TV platform, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content