The Real Reason Wall Street Walloped the Media Business

The sky is falling in the media business, but there’s more than one poultry metaphor that explains this week’s stock-market meltdown.

Yes, the absence of any imminent threat that would otherwise trigger this hysteria should invoke Chicken Little. But chickens are also coming home to roost in this beleaguered sector; long pent-up anxiety over its increasingly wobbly fundamentals was bound to be released sooner rather than later.

The two-day tumble of the media stocks was clearly an overreaction, because while the impacted companies reported nothing on their quarterly calls this week to inspire confidence in them, the selloff was way out of proportion to the scale of their bad news.

Another way to understand the panic is that the existential angst Wall Street has been feeling about the media sector for quite some time was just begging for any excuse to be vented. That came, improbably enough, via a seemingly minor recalibration that Disney declared for its affiliate-fee projections.

To some degree, you have to give Wall Street credit for paying attention to the details; you might have thought it would have taken a more spectacular flameout to send stocks plummeting, like a huge movie bomb or a pay-TV provider pulling the plug on a cable channel. But Disney’s adjusted estimate became a lightning rod because affiliate fees are the most important revenue stream in the media mix, and Disney has the most powerful cable brand in ESPN, which is dependent on that stream.

If anything, the stock selloff may be further fueled by concerns over the state of the sports network, which has been getting socked by bad buzz in recent months related to increasing talk of the sky-high expense of its TV-sports rights and the defections of some key on-air talent. The latter issue is really a rounding error in the grand scheme of ESPN’s business, but rights costs are a more valid concern.

That said, any media-industry analyst worth his salt has been saying for over a year now that the growth of affiliate fees was going to be tapering off in the long term because of the inevitable contraction of the pay-TV market, which makes this week’s sudden selloff all the more mystifying.

Still, there was something about the mighty Disney confirming that truth in even moderate fashion that must have really hit home for a Wall Street already on edge about media stocks. The drubbing that Viacom stock suffered Thursday only validated how deep that skepticism is.

A troubling narrative about the media business has been gathering steam for many months: TV ratings are declining precipitously across the board, particularly among younger demographics. Why that’s happening is attributed to many factors, from the inadequacy of measurement capabilities to capture viewing that is spreading across platforms to the cannibalization of eyeballs by Netflix, which would hit the TV business even harder were subscription VOD services not funneling billions in license fees to TV content providers.

Regardless of the root of the ratings problems, the declining audience is triggering advertising-revenue losses that are being compounded by the inroads digital juggernauts like Google and Facebook are already making on Madison Avenue. The only revenue stream more important than advertising is affiliate fees, which are pretty solid for the foreseeable future. Cord-cutting is a real but glacially slow force that will hit affiliate fees in time, though that’s where this week’s meltdown mystery deepens: Neither the declines reported by the pay-TV distributors this quarter nor the competition from over-the-top alternatives that are still quite new suggest there’s been any dramatic acceleration of consumers ditching cable and satellite.

Media companies can boast all they want about a particular movie franchise succeeding or a new theme park opening, but these are all ancillary to pay TV, which is where the media business lives and dies in varying degrees, depending on the conglomerate.

Even when the stocks rebound, pay TV is the cloud that will be hanging over the media business for many years to come. The conglomerates will do their best to tout increasing diversification, international growth and innovations in addressable advertising, but they won’t do much to dispel the primary concern anytime soon. This is the new normal, so let’s all get used to it.

More Biz

  • Hong Kong skyline

    Hong Kong Declares Emergency in Coronavirus Response

    Hong Kong’s government has put the territory on the highest state of emergency in response to the outbreak of coronavirus in mainland China. Schools will remain closed until Feb. 17, long after the Chinese New Year holidays, which begin today, should have finished. Hong Kong is a Special Administrative Area of China and some 600 [...]

  • Harvey Mason Jr.., Chair of the

    Grammy Board Chief Calls Allegations of Nomination-Rigging ‘Just Not Right’

    Among the many allegations in ousted Recording Academy CEO Deborah Dugan’s blockbuster legal complaint, the one that possibly cuts most to the heart of the institution — and is of most concern to artists and the public — is the allegation that the nominating process is “rigged.” The example in the complaint points to the [...]

  • Annabella Sciorra

    Friend Tells of Annabella Sciorra's Mid-1990s Struggles at Harvey Weinstein Trial

    A longtime friend of Annabella Sciorra testified Friday in Harvey Weinstein’s criminal trial that the actor turned to cutting herself and exhibited other troubling behavior in the mid-1990s after she was allegedly raped by the disgraced film mogul. The defense questioning of model Kara Young got heated as Judge James Burke sustained repeated objections to [...]

  • Writers vs Agents Packaging War WGA

    Judge Doubts WGA Claim That Packaging Fees Are Kickbacks

    A federal judge seemed skeptical on Friday of the Writers Guild of America’s claim that packaging fees amount to a criminal kickback to agents. Judge Andre Birotte heard more than two hours of arguments from attorneys for the guild and three agencies: WME, UTA and CAA. He said he would issue a ruling at a [...]

  • Songs for Screens Powered by Mac

    Songs for Screens: Why Aerosmith Is Still Gold for Synchs

    Aerosmith’s star-studded tribute concert as the 2020 MusiCares Person of the Year honorees on Friday night (January 24) will cement another important milestone in the historic Boston-founded band’s contributions to the American rock canon. But over the past decade, some of the band’s best-known music has remained part of the cultural conversation through some of [...]

  • Sirius Logo

    Radio Hall of Famer Kid Kelly Leaves SiriusXM After Two Decades

    In a surprise move, veteran programmer, on-air personality and Radio Hall of Famer Kid Kelly has left SiriusXM after nearly 20 years with the radio giant, a rep for the company has confirmed to Variety. The news was first reported by RAMP. He most recently served as SiriusXM’s VP of Pop Music Programming. “After a [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content