You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Writers Guild Pushes Back on Argument that Net Neutrality Rules Violate First Amendment

The Writers Guild of America West and other content creator organizations are defending the FCC’s new neutrality rules, challenging Internet providers who claim that the regulations violate their First Amendment rights.

After the FCC passed the new rules in late February, cable and telecom companies filed nearly a dozen lawsuits, many claiming that the agency overstepped its authority in reclassifying the Internet as a Title II telecommunications service. The FCC took the regulatory step in order to establish legal footing to impose no-blocking and no-throttling rules on Internet traffic, as well a regulations banning paid prioritization.

With oral arguments scheduled for Dec. 4 before the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals, a number of groups are weighing in on both sides of the issue.

The WGAW, Future of Music Coalition and the National Alliance for Media Arts and Culture, in an amicus brief filed on Monday, said that without the FCC’s protection, “the openness that fosters democratic discourse and innovation will give way to oligopoly and corporate control of speech, which are hallmarks of traditional media platforms.”

They said that there was “some irony” in the fact that some plaintiffs have cited the First Amendment in challenging the FCC rules.

That was a reference to a brief filed in July from plaintiffs Alamo Broadband and Daniel Berninger. They argued that broadband providers “are speakers because they engage in speech, and they exercise the same editorial discretion as cable television operators in deciding which speech to transmit.

“The rules are subject to strict scrutiny because they compel providers to carry all speech, including political speech with which providers disagree, and because the rules discriminate among speakers on the Internet,” they wrote in their brief.

But the WGAW and other groups say that the plaintiffs’ description “bears no resemblance to what consumers recognize as Internet access.”

“In fact, ISPs are the computer-aided, faster versions of Federal Express, UPS or Union Pacific. When a consumer orders a movie written by a WGAW member, she expects the ISP simply to deliver the movie. The movement of that content from point to point is the ISP’s core function. The function is not speech.”

They also said that such a rationale would create a “legal anomaly” that would transform conduct into speech merely because “the fixation of the content has changed from code on a DVD to code on an IP packet transmitted over the Internet.”

The Writers Guild has championed robust FCC net neutrality rules while other Hollywood guilds have remained largely silent. The WGAW noted that the growing number of online video services are offering new opportunities for writers and other content creators, who have otherwise seen the consolidation of the media over the past two decades.

Other plaintiffs in the case, like the National Cable and Telecommunications Assn., argue that the FCC has adopted a “radical course” in reclassifying the Internet that subjects the broadband industry to “a host of burdensome Title II provisions that have nothing to do with Internet openness.”


More Biz

  • Jussie Smollett Good Morning America

    Jussie Smollett Angrily Denies Complicity in Attack

    Attorneys for “Empire” actor Jussie Smollett issued a statement Saturday denying that he orchestrated his Jan. 29 assault, and saying he is “angered” and “devastated” by recent developments in the case. Chicago police want to interview Smollett, after learning new evidence from two Nigerian brothers who were released on Friday night. Local media outlets have [...]

  • Walt Disney Archives Founder Dave Smith

    Walt Disney Archives Founder Dave Smith Dies at 78

    Walt Disney Archives founder Dave Smith, the historian who spent 40 years cataloging and preserving the company’s legacy of entertainment and innovation, died Friday in Burbank, Calif. He was 78. Smith served as Disney’s chief archivist from 1970 to 2010. He was named a Disney Legend in 2007 and served as a consultant to the [...]

  • Colin Kaepernick Kneel

    Colin Kaepernick, Eric Reid Reach Settlement With NFL

    Colin Kaepernick and Eric Reid, two football players who alleged the National Football League colluded to oust them from the game after they started kneeling in protest of racial inequality during the playing of the national anthem, have reached a settlement in the matter, according to a statement from the sports organization and lawyers representing [...]

  • R. Kelly

    R. Kelly Could Be in ‘Big Trouble’ Over Alleged New Sex Tape, Attorney Says

    Strong allegations of sexual misconduct have followed R. Kelly for 25 years, but the singer has always managed to slip free. Yet reports that a videotape of him sexually assaulting an underage girl, combined with the outcry surrounding the Lifetime documentary “Surviving R. Kelly,” means that public sentiment, at the very least, is definitely not [...]

  • Christian Bale as Dick Cheney in

    New Media Residuals and Feature Films Contribute to Spike in Writers' Pay

    The outlook for members of the Writers Guild of America has brightened — even amid pervasive uncertainty in the entertainment industry. According to the most recent report to WGA West members, earnings surged 2.8% to $1.41 billion in 2017, thanks mostly to gains in feature films and new-media residuals. Total covered earnings for WGA West [...]

  • Joe Dante Gremlins

    Hollywood Execs Seek Licensing Deals at the New York Toy Fair

    On Feb. 16 more than 30,000 studio executives, buyers and toy company reps will gather in Manhattan for the annual Toy Fair New York, all vying for market share and trying to snag the latest hot trend in a fast-changing industry. Those working the film side of the business will focus much of their attention [...]

  • Lady Gaga Bradley Cooper A Star

    Universal Music Group Fuels 11.3% Rise in Vivendi's 2018 Revenues

    Vivendi’s revenues were up 11.3% to €13.93 billion ($15.7 billion) in 2018, powered by Universal Music Group, which delivered such hits as the “A Star Is Born” soundtrack and Drake’s new album. UMG’s revenues climbed by 10% to €6 billion ($6.8 billion) compared to 2017. On top of the “A Star Is Born” soundtrack, the [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content