You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Court Strikes Down Possible Cash Payments to College Athletes

NCAA rules prohibiting compensation to college athletes are “more restrictive than necessary” and subject to antitrust laws, but the athletic conference can still limit payments to the full cost of attendance, a three-judge appellate panel ruled on Wednesday.

The decision from the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals comes as amateur athletes have been challenging NCAA rules, pointing to the bonanza of broadcast and cable contracts and licensing of their image and likeness for such things as videogames. Although the appellate decision was a mixed ruling, it found fault with the idea of providing athletes with cash payments for the use of their name, image and likeness.

The plaintiff in the case, Ed O’Bannon, a former basketball player for UCLA, filed suit after discovering his avatar was being used in an Electronic Arts videogame, but NCAA rules prevented him from being compensated. His claim was consolidated with that of another athlete, Samuel Keller, a former quarterback for Arizona State University and the University of Nebraska. Last year, a district court judge ruled that NCAA’s prohibition on compensation to athletes for the use of their name, image and likeness violated antitrust rules. A remedy was to pay NCAA members scholarships up to the full cost of attendance, and cash compensation of up to $5,000 per year.

“Applying the Rule of Reason, we conclude that the district court correctly identified one proper alternative to the current NCAA compensation rules — i.e. allowing NCAA members to give scholarships up to the full cost of attendance — but that the district court’s other remedy, allowing students to be paid cash compensation of up to $5,000 per year, was erroneous,” the appellate panel ruled.

The judges ruled that “a compensation cap set at student athletes’ full cost of attendance is a substantially less restrictive alternative means of accomplishing the NCAA’s legitimate pro-competitive purposes.”

Yet they saw a big difference between providing compensation for attendance costs and giving them cash payments for the use of their image and likeness.

“The difference between offering student-athletes education related compensation and offering them cash sums untethered to educational expenses is not minor; it is a quantum leap,” the judges wrote. “Once that line is crossed, we see no basis for returning to a rule of amateurism and no defined stopping point; we have little doubt that plaintiffs will continue to challenge the arbitrary limit imposed by the district court until they have captured the full value of their” name, image and likeness. “At that point, the NCAA will have surrendered its amateurism principles entirely and transitioned from its ‘particular brand of football’ to minor league status.”

Judge Sidney Thomas concurred with the opinion but wrote that there was “sufficient evidence in the record” to also support the award of a $5,000 cash payment for the use of name, image and likeness.

Earlier this year, a federal judge in Tennessee threw out a class action lawsuit filed by 10 former athletes against ESPN and other broadcasters, ruling that telecasts were exempt from right of publicity claims.

More Biz

  • Jussie Smollett Good Morning America

    Jussie Smollett Angrily Denies Complicity in Attack

    Attorneys for “Empire” actor Jussie Smollett issued a statement Saturday denying that he orchestrated his Jan. 29 assault, and saying he is “angered” and “devastated” by recent developments in the case. Chicago police want to interview Smollett, after learning new evidence from two Nigerian brothers who were released on Friday night. Local media outlets have [...]

  • Walt Disney Archives Founder Dave Smith

    Walt Disney Archives Founder Dave Smith Dies at 78

    Walt Disney Archives founder Dave Smith, the historian who spent 40 years cataloging and preserving the company’s legacy of entertainment and innovation, died Friday in Burbank, Calif. He was 78. Smith served as Disney’s chief archivist from 1970 to 2010. He was named a Disney Legend in 2007 and served as a consultant to the [...]

  • Colin Kaepernick Kneel

    Colin Kaepernick, Eric Reid Reach Settlement With NFL

    Colin Kaepernick and Eric Reid, two football players who alleged the National Football League colluded to oust them from the game after they started kneeling in protest of racial inequality during the playing of the national anthem, have reached a settlement in the matter, according to a statement from the sports organization and lawyers representing [...]

  • R. Kelly

    R. Kelly Could Be in ‘Big Trouble’ Over Alleged New Sex Tape, Attorney Says

    Strong allegations of sexual misconduct have followed R. Kelly for 25 years, but the singer has always managed to slip free. Yet reports that a videotape of him sexually assaulting an underage girl, combined with the outcry surrounding the Lifetime documentary “Surviving R. Kelly,” means that public sentiment, at the very least, is definitely not [...]

  • Christian Bale as Dick Cheney in

    New Media Residuals and Feature Films Contribute to Spike in Writers' Pay

    The outlook for members of the Writers Guild of America has brightened — even amid pervasive uncertainty in the entertainment industry. According to the most recent report to WGA West members, earnings surged 2.8% to $1.41 billion in 2017, thanks mostly to gains in feature films and new-media residuals. Total covered earnings for WGA West [...]

  • Joe Dante Gremlins

    Hollywood Execs Seek Licensing Deals at the New York Toy Fair

    On Feb. 16 more than 30,000 studio executives, buyers and toy company reps will gather in Manhattan for the annual Toy Fair New York, all vying for market share and trying to snag the latest hot trend in a fast-changing industry. Those working the film side of the business will focus much of their attention [...]

  • Lady Gaga Bradley Cooper A Star

    Universal Music Group Fuels 11.3% Rise in Vivendi's 2018 Revenues

    Vivendi’s revenues were up 11.3% to €13.93 billion ($15.7 billion) in 2018, powered by Universal Music Group, which delivered such hits as the “A Star Is Born” soundtrack and Drake’s new album. UMG’s revenues climbed by 10% to €6 billion ($6.8 billion) compared to 2017. On top of the “A Star Is Born” soundtrack, the [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content