‘Avatar’ Idea Theft Suit Rejected by Appellate Court

A federal appeals court rejected an artist’s claim that the plot of “Avatar” was stolen from an idea he pitched to writer-director James Cameron.

The appellate court panel sided 2-1 with Cameron and Lightstorm Entertainment in their contention that “Avatar” was an independent creation, with the director drawing upon produced and unproduced projects from the 1970s and ’80s that pre-dated the time he met artist Gerald Morawski in 1991.

The decision upholds a 2013 ruling from U.S. District Judge Margaret Morrow, who found that although Morawski’s project pitch — called “Guardians of Eden” — bore similarities to “Avatar,” she was convinced by Cameron’s 45-page declaration that showed how “Avatar” was his own idea.

The appeals court noted that Cameron “presented detailed and copious evidence of independent creation. Under California law, if a defendant presents ‘clear’ and ‘positive’ evidence of independent creation, any inference of use of another’s work arising from access and substantial similarity is dispelled, and a plaintiff may no longer solely rely on that inference to establish improper use.”

Judge Morgan Christen dissented, concluding that the case still had contested issues of fact that warranted going forward with the case.

Jon Landau, Cameron’s producing partner, said in a statement, “While it is unfortunate that a myriad of fortune-hunting plaintiffs seek to take credit for the success of our film, we are grateful that the courts have consistently seen through these grossly meritless claims.”

 

More Biz

  • Golden Globes

    HFPA, Dick Clark Productions Near New Golden Globe Awards Rights Deal With NBC

    A federal appeals court rejected an artist’s claim that the plot of “Avatar” was stolen from an idea he pitched to writer-director James Cameron. The appellate court panel sided 2-1 with Cameron and Lightstorm Entertainment in their contention that “Avatar” was an independent creation, with the director drawing upon produced and unproduced projects from the 1970s and ’80s that […]

  • New York Daily News, Tronc

    Tronc Lays Off 50% of New York Daily News Editorial Staff, Including Top Editor Jim Rich

    A federal appeals court rejected an artist’s claim that the plot of “Avatar” was stolen from an idea he pitched to writer-director James Cameron. The appellate court panel sided 2-1 with Cameron and Lightstorm Entertainment in their contention that “Avatar” was an independent creation, with the director drawing upon produced and unproduced projects from the 1970s and ’80s that […]

  • Jack Ma Alibaba

    Alibaba Looking at Expansion in Advertising, Media Sectors

    A federal appeals court rejected an artist’s claim that the plot of “Avatar” was stolen from an idea he pitched to writer-director James Cameron. The appellate court panel sided 2-1 with Cameron and Lightstorm Entertainment in their contention that “Avatar” was an independent creation, with the director drawing upon produced and unproduced projects from the 1970s and ’80s that […]

  • Mandatory Credit: Photo by AP/REX/Shutterstock (9178399b)Hillary

    Hillary Clinton Talks Russia, Trump, Putin and Midterm Elections at NYC Festival

    A federal appeals court rejected an artist’s claim that the plot of “Avatar” was stolen from an idea he pitched to writer-director James Cameron. The appellate court panel sided 2-1 with Cameron and Lightstorm Entertainment in their contention that “Avatar” was an independent creation, with the director drawing upon produced and unproduced projects from the 1970s and ’80s that […]

  • Richard Simmons

    Prosecutors Charge Private Eye With Illegal Spying on Richard Simmons

    A federal appeals court rejected an artist’s claim that the plot of “Avatar” was stolen from an idea he pitched to writer-director James Cameron. The appellate court panel sided 2-1 with Cameron and Lightstorm Entertainment in their contention that “Avatar” was an independent creation, with the director drawing upon produced and unproduced projects from the 1970s and ’80s that […]

  • Lionsgate General Counsel Left Amid Allegations

    Lionsgate General Counsel Left Amid Allegations of Sexual Abuse

    A federal appeals court rejected an artist’s claim that the plot of “Avatar” was stolen from an idea he pitched to writer-director James Cameron. The appellate court panel sided 2-1 with Cameron and Lightstorm Entertainment in their contention that “Avatar” was an independent creation, with the director drawing upon produced and unproduced projects from the 1970s and ’80s that […]

  • 'Hammerhead' Takes Top Honors at New

    'Hammerhead' Takes Top Honors at New York Television Festival

    A federal appeals court rejected an artist’s claim that the plot of “Avatar” was stolen from an idea he pitched to writer-director James Cameron. The appellate court panel sided 2-1 with Cameron and Lightstorm Entertainment in their contention that “Avatar” was an independent creation, with the director drawing upon produced and unproduced projects from the 1970s and ’80s that […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content