×

Is Tourism a Side Benefit of Movie, TV Tax Incentives?

West Monroe, La., may not be drawing the jet set, but it’s easy to see what visitors to the small town are looking for: “Duck Dynasty.”

The reality show’s popularity was cited in a recent report, sponsored by the MPAA and state film boosters, which argued that valuable movie- and TV show-inspired tourism is an important side benefit of government film tax incentives.

Anecdotal evidence is one thing; quantifying it is another.

The study, prepared by HR&A Advisors, says that tourism spending connected to movies and TV shows supported 22,720 jobs and up to $766.6 million in personal income in the state. The figures were calculated based on the results of an online survey of 1,381 recent visitors to Louisiana, showing that 14.5% of tourists said they were “induced” to visit by movies and TV shows filmed there.

Those results were almost immediately challenged by the public interest group Louisiana Budget Project, which called the report deeply flawed and said that “a typical viewer of a typical Louisiana-based production doesn’t even know they’re watching a Louisiana movie.”

The numbers are likely to be the source of continued debate as states weigh renewing or expanding their tax incentive programs.

Popular on Variety

“That is the big question,” says Stefan Roesch, film tourism consultant and author of the book “The Experiences of Film Location Tourists.” “I think it is pretty difficult, from a market-research point of view, to define who a ‘film-induced’ tourist actually is.”

Some tourists may want to just visit a location, he says, while others may want more than that. When Roesch went to Tunisia to see locations where George Lucas shot Luke Skywalker’s home planet for “Star Wars,” some of those traveling with him played the movie’s theme. One wore a Jedi robe and told him, “I was living that moment. I was Obi-Wan Kenobi.”

Generally, though, it’s not easy to determine the exact impulses responsible for vacation objectives, Roesch says. “How do you quantify the influence of a film (on) travel to a wider destination? What do you say (it’s worth)? 50%? 30%?”

It’s even difficult to extrapolate the effect of perhaps the most popular movie-inspired travel site — what Roesch calls the “mother lode” of film-driven tourism: New Zealand, the target of those ostensibly attracted by “The Lord of the Rings” trilogy.

The nation’s international-arrivals figures did experience an increase after the first picture was released, but Roesch notes that those numbers had been rising before that.

That isn’t to say location filming has little or no impact on tourism. The MPAA’s Vans Stevenson cites Southern California as a prime example. No one questions the fact that Hollywood is one of the world’s major tourist destinations.

Unfortunately for the MPAA, a report released last month by Louisiana state economic development officials didn’t account for any of the economic benefit from tourism, instead concentrating on the return that productions bring back to state tax coffers only. The conclusion was far less rosy: Just 23¢ from each dollar of tax credit comes back in the form of state taxes.

And yet, someone is making some money from “Duck Dynasty”-inspired visitors. Otherwise there probably wouldn’t be the Duck Commander Hometown Tour.

More Artisans

  • A still from Miles Davis: Birth

    Film Editor Lewis Erskine on Finding the Rhythm for Miles Davis Doc 'Birth of the Cool'

    On-the-beat editing for the documentary “Miles Davis: Birth of the Cool” comes courtesy of Lewis Erskine who brings rhythm to the images apace with that perfect flow of the jazz icon’s horn. The film premiered at the Sundance Film Festival in 2019 and earned a nomination at the NAACP’s 2020 Image Awards for outstanding documentary [...]

  • Robin Thede

    Robin Thede: 'Turn Black History Month Into Black History Year' (Guest Column)

    From “The Queen Latifah Show,” “The Nightly Show,” “The Rundown with Robin Thede” and “A Black Lady Sketch Show,” my career has been dedicated in large part to the representation, advancement and celebration of black people year-round. And I know what you’re thinking: “Robin, you’re black (I think, right? Googles ‘Robin Thede ethnicity’ Yes, got [...]

  • Kasi LemmonsNew York Women in Film

    Kasi Lemmons: 'African American History Is American History' (Guest Column)

    My influences were literary initially. I was a big reader of books so my influences were Toni Morrison, Gabriel Garcia Marquez and southern novelists. In terms of film, I liked Bergman a lot and Hitchcock, but there were a lot of different people that I admired. I realized recently that Lina Wertmuller was one of [...]

  • The Invisible Man

    How 'The Invisible Man's' Production and Costume Designer Avoided Horror Tropes

    While Universal’s “The Invisible Man” is based on the studio’s popular 1933 horror feature of the same name, director Leigh Whannell didn’t envision his remake as a fright fest. That provided the marching orders for his artistic team: Production designer Alex Holmes and costume designer Emily Seresin sought to avoid horror tropes, turning the Elisabeth [...]

  • call of the wild

    'The Call of the Wild' Editor David Heinz on Creating Emotions for a CGI Dog

    “The Call of the Wild” editor David Heinz has worked on “The Jungle Book” and “War for the Planet of the Apes,” but this movie starring Harrison Ford and an animated dog named Buck was different. “If you think about it, the lead of the movie is fully CGI and never speaks,” he said, also [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content