You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Why the Pay TV Model Won’t Work for the Music Business

You’ve got to stop e-mailing me Ted Gioia’s article in the Daily Beast about lessons the music industry can learn from TV.

This is what drives me crazy about America, people glom onto something that squares with their worldview, and they trumpet it to high heaven, even though this writer’s got no basis in reality, and the whole missive leaves the consumer and business realities out of the equation.

We had a high-quality carrier in the music business; it was known as the CD. Hell, we even improved it, with the SACD and DVD-A. But the truth, is no one wanted this high-end tech. It hit the market like the DeLorean, too late and too expensive — and out of touch with the times.

Yup, the music industry was there first. The CD was an improvement to most people’s ears. They already had scratched vinyl and high-speed duplicated cassettes. To hear pristine sound was a revelation. The fact that it was tinny and not remastered for the format initially … Well, change takes time. Was every show in HD when you bought your flat panel TV?

And your flat panel is enough for television; the price cratered seemingly overnight. Whereas in music, you need an amplifier and speakers, and it’s all very expensive, while people are notoriously cheap.

Technologically speaking, audio innovation has happened faster than video. We got the iPod back in 2001. We didn’t get video on hand-held devices until the advent of iPhones and broadband streaming. And still most video content is unavailable. You’ve got to steal it.

The barrier to entry in music is almost nonexistent. You know how much money it costs to make those TV shows? Far in excess of what it does an album. And despite endless uploads to YouTube, few have gravitated to network or cable from that platform, because the shows just aren’t good enough.

The truth is, the music business was the canary in the coal mine. The reason files sounded so bad has got to do with bandwidth — the ability to send over thin pipes. The movie and TV industries were laughing, believing their content was unstealable, not realizing that as soon as we got fat pipes, they’d be in trouble. And what have these visual content companies done? Lobby against the high-speed pipes of South Korea and other leading-edge technical nations. Yup, blame TV and movie studios for holding our whole nation back, because the truth is, faster broadband falls straight to the bottom line.

As a consumer, you can listen to music for one low price, all in one place. Try doing that with television. You’ve got to pay everywhere, and it’s only getting worse. You’ve got to have a Hulu subscription, an Amazon one and a Netflix one, and you still can’t see everything, which is why when you delve into P2P statistics, you see that most piracy now occurs in video; in music, we’ve gone a long way toward solving the problem of fair and legal distribution.

The Daily Beast says we can solve our problems by getting people to pay for tracks, by stiffening our backs and telling the public to do it our way. Hasn’t happened yet. Didn’t we try that? Didn’t the RIAA sue people? Did that make revenue jump? Of course not.

The great thing about music is how the constant flow of material renders indelible hits that could not be predicted a moment before their arrival. Like Lorde’s “Royals,” which is so infectious listeners can’t stop playing it. But the truth is, the music game is in the hands of the consumers. The business just follows the trends. And now we’ve got some guy saying we should go back to the old era, where content was behind bars and the gates were controlled by the few.


More Music

  • Kenny Dixon, Drummer for Country Star

    Kenny Dixon, Drummer for Country Star Kane Brown, Dies in Car Accident

    Kane Brown and his fans are mourning the death of the country star’s drummer, Kenny Dixon, in an automobile accident in Tennessee Saturday. “I’m gonna miss you so much man. I’d always come back and jam out with u,” Brown tweeted on Sunday, posting a photo of himself standing on the drum riser grinning at [...]

  • Chambers Brothers

    George Chambers, of 1960s Hit Group the Chambers Brothers, Dies at 88

    George “Pops” Chambers, singer and bassist for the Chambers Brothers, best known for the 1968 hit “Time Has Come Today,” died Saturday at 88. “The best big brother you could ever have,” Willie Chambers wrote on his Facebook page Sunday night. “I am so sad, and at the same time, I’m so glad to have [...]

  • Stock market

    Trading In Music's Futures: How to Cash In on the Industry's Gold Rush (Guest Column)

    The music industry is entering a time of financial prosperity thanks to the widespread use of streaming services like Spotify, Apple Music, and Tidal. According to a recent report by Musicwatch, 77% of all internet users in the U.S. stream music, while Goldman Sachs projects a revenue pot of $34 billion by 2030. Finally, the [...]

  • Vampire Weekend - Brian Robert Jones,

    Vampire Weekend, Mumford & Sons, Rufus du Sol to Headline Okeechobee Festival

    Today, Insomniac Events announced the lineup for the fourth edition of Florida’s Okeechobee Music & Arts Festival. The four-day event will return to Sunshine Grove in Okeechobee, Florida March 5-8, 2020 with a multi-genre lineup led by Vampire Weekend, Mumford & Sons, Rufus du Sol and Bassnectar, along with over 100 other artists across a [...]

  • Member of South Korean Girl Group

    Korean Pop Star Sulli Dies at 25

    Korean pop star Sulli was found dead at her home near Seoul on Monday. She was 25. Her manager found her body and alerted the police. The manager reported that the star, whose real name was Choi Jin-ri, suffered from depression, and police said that they were working on the assumption that she had died [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content