You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

NCAA Tournament’s ‘Cinderella’ Stories Have Become a Popular Media Myth

Mercer beats Duke? Harvard wins again? Despite what you read and hear, it's not as shocking as you might think

Myths die hard in the media, especially if there’s a good, familiar story undergirding them. So it is with the NCAA basketball tournament, and the notion of a “Cinderella team” emerging – some program without a storied, big-conference pedigree that makes a deep run, busting brackets along the way.

Certainly, it’s irresistible for sportswriters and pundits, offering a David-and-Goliath angle that can’t help but galvanize attention and buzz even among those with only a marginal interest in the games.

It’s a good story, all right. If only it were still true.

Sure, there are still traditional powers that tend to be in the championship chase year after year. But the so-called “one and done” rule, which essentially dictates that players spend at least one year in college (reaching the age of 19) before bolting to the National Basketball Assn., has seriously diminished any program’s claim to year-after-year supremacy, and heightened parity within the college ranks.

In the opening round, televised across the Turner Networks and CBS, lower-ranked teams have already produced some eye-popping upsets. That included Friday’s defeat of Duke by 14th-seeded Mercer and Harvard’s latest humbling of a significantly higher seed. The “Who is Mercer?” stories — spoiler alert: Small university in Georgia — began cropping up almost immediately.

Still, the Duke parading around in those uniforms today isn’t the one of the 1990s. Moreover, this Blue Devil squad was led by a freshman, Jabari Parker, who will likely be wearing an NBA uniform soon, while Mercer had a number of more experienced seniors on its roster.

Even so, one suspects a lot of the saps who picked Duke to win several games in tournament pools made those judgments based strictly on reputation, being unable to pick any of its players out of a lineup.

The real beneficiaries of perpetuating the Cinderella scenario, meanwhile, aren’t the players but the media and the coaches. Upsets help keep ratings high. For the coaches, performing well in the tournament has become the quickest ticket to higher-paying, higher-profile gigs, from Butler’s Brad Stevens graduating to the NBA to Florida Gulf Coast’s Andy Enfield, last year’s darling, who was promptly wooed away by USC. (Not surprisingly, one needn’t look hard to find headlines from 2013 proclaiming FGC a “Cinderella.”)

The tournament remains great fun because of its sudden-death format. And in a strange way, the dilution of talent has only made the games more unpredictable, and thus more intriguing.

Those running around talking about who fits this year’s glass slipper, however, are being fooled by a myth the media has no incentive to let go. And while the NCAA keeps rolling in dough despite a flawed system, those who view the tournament through the prism of what it once was are, inevitably, making a sucker’s bet.

More TV

  • Mike Royce24th Annual Critics' Choice Awards,

    CBS Orders Comedy Pilot 'Story of Us' From 'One Day at a Time' Co-Creator Mike Royce

    CBS has ordered a pilot for the comedy “The Story of Us” from writer and executive producer Mike Royce. The hybrid comedy tells the story of how an unlikely couple becomes a family through interviews and vignettes spanning 10 years. In addition to Royce, Nick Stoller and Conor Welch will serve as executive producers. Sony [...]

  • 'Schitt's Creek' Stars Reveal Dream Guest

    'Schitt's Creek' Cast Reveals Dream Guest Stars: Oprah, Beyonce and ...

    “Schitt’s Creek” has big dreams. Dan Levy, who stars as David on the series, says his wish list of guest stars includes Oprah, Beyonce, Mariah Carey and Gwyneth Paltrow. “All for different reasons, none of whom we’ll get,” he cracked at the Critics’ Choice Awards. For those who haven’t caught on to the “Schitt’s Creek” [...]

  • Bob Costas Olympics Mike Tirico

    Bob Costas Officially Out at NBC After Nearly 40 Years

    Bob Costas has formally parted ways with NBC after nearly 40 years as a sportscaster for the Peacock. Costas and NBC have been negotiating an exit agreement for months. Word surfaced last summer that he was preparing to end his tenure with the network. Costas confirmed the news in an interview with the New York [...]

  • Happy

    TV Roundup: Syfy Drops First Trailer for Season 2 of 'Happy!'

    In today’s TV News Roundup, Syfy drops the first trailer for the second season of “Happy!” and Imagine Kids & Family sets a partnership with Four M Studios.  FIRST LOOKS Syfy has dropped the first trailer for season two of “Happy!” starring Christopher Meloni and Patton Oswalt. The new season premieres Wednesday, March 27 at 10/9c [...]

  • 'Brexit' Review: Benedict Cumberbatch Stars in

    TV Review: HBO's 'Brexit'

    The announcement of the film “Brexit” — which aired in the U.K. on Channel 4 before its HBO bow on Jan. 19 — engendered serious criticism from the British, and understandably so. The film, which looks at recent history in the manner HBO productions like “Game Change” and “Recount” had done, takes on a story whose very [...]

  • 'Fyre Fraud' and 'Fyre' Reviews: Behind

    TV Review: 'Fyre Fraud' and 'Fyre'

    It seems in retrospect unavoidable that the week of release for a highly-anticipated documentary about a scammer began with an attention-grabbing stunt. On Monday, in advance of the planned Friday drop of Netflix’s “Fyre,” Hulu executed a surprise release of its own “Fyre Fraud”; both films assay the failed 2017 gathering Fyre Festival, a would-be [...]

  • Deadly Class Review

    TV Review: 'Deadly Class' on SyFy

    High school, according to TV and movies, is either the best or worst thing that can happen to a person. It’s almost always depicted as the most fun a kid can have, or a horrifying hellhole from which there’s no escape. “Deadly Class” is decidedly in the latter camp — and despite its edgy attempts [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content