You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

TV Review: A&E’s ‘Those Who Kill,’ ‘Bates Motel’


Chloe Sevigny, James D’Arcy, James Morrison, Omid Abtahi

Thanks to Chloe Sevigny’s interesting resume, her presence raised hopes that A&E’s latest stab at (overtly) scripted programming, “Those Who Kill,” might be more than just another serial-killer procedural — “Criminal Minds XXVII,” as it were. Alas, no such luck, and this latest dreary adaptation of a Danish series has the added burdens of being almost unforgivably shoddy in its details, with cops who stumble and bumble through their investigation, and yet another profiler with a haunted past (is there any other kind?). A&E introduces the show as a “Bates Motel” companion, but this latest crime-drenched show isn’t much fun for those who watch.

Using the drab environs of Pittsburgh as a surrogate for its European inspiration — and to be fair, for a small country, the Danes certainly have a way with brooding and outlandish murderers, dramatically speaking — the series casts Sevigny as Catherine Jensen, a detective with one of those sallow-eyed stares.

Faced with the grim discovery of bodies, she enlists the aide of Thomas Schaeffer (James D’Arcy), a brilliant academic/forensic psychologist, much to the chagrin of her boss (“24’s” James Morrison), who had a run-in with Schaeffer that ended badly.

The task of developing the show fell to “The X-Files” alum Glen Morgan and director Joe Carnahan, and while they conjure some creepy visuals, almost every aspect of the investigation is just plain silly if given more than a moment’s thought. That includes, but is not limited to, perhaps the worst securing of a suspect in the history of made-for-TV police work, which is saying something.

Indeed, while the show has an interesting look and some creepy visual flourishes, it’s hard to get past the ridiculous twists — or for that matter, a press release that refers to Pittsburgh as “picturesque.”

Sevigny certainly brings intensity to the role, and the series promises a serialized thread over its 10 episodes. Still, it’s hard to escape the sense that serial killers have become such a formulaic sop as to become TV’s version of a dramatic crutch.

Then again, “Those Who Kill” will follow “Bates Motel,” the network’s “Psycho” prequel, which returns with similar craziness, while still facing the same pitfalls about being hamstrung by where it fits into the movie’s universe.

Despite the firstrate performances by Vera Farmiga and Freddie Highmore as the mother-and-son combo Norma and Norman Bates, the show can’t delve too far into Norman’s murderous madness — although the creatives have pushed it some, compensating by creating a “Twin Peaks”-like world around the characters. Simply put, this is one of those small towns where all is not as it seems, and the per-capita murder rate is off the charts.

Because the first season performed reasonably well, “Bates Motel” remains open, and despite the considerable craft that has gone into creating a world designed to take on a life of its own, it’s difficult to see how the serialized narrative can run much longer without beginning to muck up its own Hitchcockian mythology.

As for “Those Who Kill,” the title notwithstanding, the show is mostly just guilty of a rather mundane form of petty theft — and a decided lack of imagination.

TV Review: A&E's 'Those Who Kill,' 'Bates Motel'

(Series; A&E, Mon. March 3, 10 p.m.)


Filmed in Pittsburgh by One Two, One Three Pictures, Miso Films, Imagine Television and Fox 21.


Executive producers, Brian Grazer, Francie Calfo, Glen Morgan, David Petrarca, Peter Bose, Jonas Allen; producer, Howard Griffith; director, Joe Carnahan; writer, Morgan; camera, Yasu Tanida; production designer, Scott P. Murphy; editors, Jason Hellmann, James Coblentz; music, Johnny Jewel; casting, Sharon Bialy, Sherry Thomas, Russell Scott. 60 MIN.


Chloe Sevigny, James D’Arcy, James Morrison, Omid Abtahi

More TV

  • Vis-a-Vis Mediapro

    Fox's Hit Spanish Drama ‘Locked Up’ Gets Spin-Off, Launching 2020

    Fox Network Groups in Spain and Globomedia, the Barcelona-based parent company of production house The Mediapro Studio, have announced a spinoff to Mediapro’s flagship Catalan series “Vis a Vis” (“Locked Up”). Set to air on Fox networks in 2020, “Vis a Vis: El Oasis” will close the circle on narratives from the original series, bringing [...]

  • ‘Peaky Blinders’ Scribe Bringing SAS Special

    ‘Peaky Blinders’ Scribe Bringing Special Forces Story ‘SAS: Rogue Heroes’ to TV

    Steven Knight is adapting “SAS: Rogue Heroes,” bringing the story of the elite British special forces unit to TV. Knight has enjoyed enormous success with his series “Peaky Blinders,” and also penned “Taboo” and the feature films “Locke” and “Eastern Promises.” His SAS series will be based on Ben Macintyre’s best-selling non-fiction book “SAS: Rogue [...]

  • ‘Riviera’ Renewed for Season 3 at

    ‘Riviera’ With Julia Stiles Renewed for Season 3 at Sky

    Sky has ordered a third season of “Riviera” with filming starting this fall. Julia Stiles will return as Georgina Clios and the action is set to move from France’s Cote d’Azur to an international stage. Stiles will also exec produce the new season, which was announced soon after season two launched on U.K. pay-TV platform [...]

  • Ari Emanuel Endeavor

    Endeavor IPO Filing Offers Details of Company's Financials, Leadership Pay Packages

    Endeavor’s IPO filing Thursday offers a hard look at the company’s financial performance during the past three years during a period of rapid growth for the company that’s home to UFC, WME, Professional Bull Riders and a clutch of other assets. Endeavor is generating solid free cash flow from operations and healthy adjusted earnings for [...]

  • Blake Jenner What If TV Show

    'What/If' Star Blake Jenner on Creating Chemistry With Jane Levy, Renee Zellweger

    Blake Jenner first rose to fame in 2012 when he won “The Glee Project” and therefore earned a role on “Glee” proper. In the years since, though, he graduated from teen heartthrob status to meatier, edgier roles in films such as “American Animals” and now the Netflix limited series “What/If,” in which he stars opposite [...]

  • Mario Lopez Candy Crush

    Mario Lopez, Seth Kurland Set Latinx Family Comedy Series at Netflix

    Mario Lopez and Seth Kurland are teaming up for a new comedy series at Netflix. Variety has learned that the streamer has given a 16 episode order to the multi-cam comedy “The Expanding Universe of Ashley Garcia” co-created by Lopez and Kurland. In the series, when Ashley Garcia — the world’s only 15-and-a-half-year-old robotics engineer [...]

  • HBO logo

    TV News Roundup: HBO Announces Recipients of 2019 HBOAccess Writing Fellowship

    In today’s roundup, Fox Nation announces a fresh slate of programming for the summer and HBO announces the recipients of its HBOAccess Writing Fellowship. DEVELOPMENT: HBO has announced the recipients of its 2019 HBOAccess Writing Fellowship. The eight writers selected out of the 3,000 submissions will participate in an 8-month program of master classes and [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content