You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

TV-News Outlets Grapple With How To Report On Grisly ISIS Videos

The videos are shocking, repulsive and horrifying. Yet they would likely attract tens of thousands of viewers who have few qualms about watching appalling content.  As a broadcaster, do you put them on the air or hold back?

Many TV-news outlets are grappling with that issue this week as they judge whether or not to unspool elements from a video depicting the beheading of journalist Steven Solotoff by Islamic militants. The video, the second of its kind in recent days (a previous one showed the beheading of another journalist, James Foley) would give news programs a chance to show with gut-wrenching detail the acts of a terrorism organization that are certain to affect foreign-policy decisions. At the same time, they risk becoming propaganda outlets for the perpetrators, a group known as Islamic State of Iraq and Greater Syria, or ISIS.

“The temptation is always to put it out there. That’s pretty much the default position of any news organization,” says John Carroll, assistant professor of mass communication at Boston University. “Clearly, the public does not want these videos out there circulating, but that’s not necessarily the mandate for news organizations.”

TV-news outlets have faced similar issues in the past. When Wall Street Journal reporter Daniel Pearl was kidnapped by Pakistani militants and subsequently murdered by them in 2002, video of the ghastly act was available. Boston University’s Carroll recalls alternative weekly The Boston Phoenix publishing several still photos and offering a link to video on a website.

The majority of outlets have shied away from showing anything more than stills, screen grabs or a few seconds from the videos.  At Al Jazeera America, “We have not and will not air any video or audio from the horrific tapes,” the network said in a statement. “These videos are used for propaganda and we want no part of that. We can report the facts without showing the images.”

At Fox News Channel, “what we try to do is use judgement so that people are informed about what actually happened while showing as little of what took place as possible,” says Michael Clemente, executive vice president of news/editorial.

During CNN’s”Legal View” on Wednesday, the network’s senior international correspondent, Nic Robertson filed a report that was accompanied by some video that showed corpses of people who had been killed by Islamic militants. CNN has also aired audio of one of the English-accented militants who has appeared in ISIS videos of the slain journalists, said Tony Maddox, executive vice president and managing director of CNN International, in an interview.

“It’s clear that these videos are having a big impact on different countries, on government policy, on overseas policy, and it’s not for CNN to say therefore viewers shouldn’t see them,” he says.  CNN has not actually shown beheadings or violent acts, he said, but has identified particular elements that would provide viewers with information they ought to have. CBS showed seconds-long video clips from ISIS videos during a Charlie Rose-anchored edition of its “CBS Evening News.”

“I have not seen the execution themselves” on any of the evening-news broadcasts on ABC, CBS and NBC, “but all have used portions of the videos containing them: masked executioner standing over kneeling condemned man in orange,” notes Andrew Tyndall, who runs the Tyndall Report media-monitoring service.

Should these videos proliferate, there is a risk that they could lose some of their shock value and TV-news outlets could lose some of their inhibitions. CNN’s Maddox maintains producers and executives will always think twice – or more – before putting such stuff on air. “Barbarism never loses its power to truly shock,” he says.

No matter how TV-news executive choose to filter their content,  keeping the public’s sensibilities in mind, viewers will be able to find it anyway, thanks to a world in which even the most alarming acts can be found with a Google search and a few clicks of the keyboard.

More TV

  • BBC Orders Spoof Talk Show Fronted

    Spoof Talk Show Fronted by an Animated Vladimir Putin Coming to the BBC

    The BBC will air a spoof talk-show fronted by an animated Vladimir Putin. The U.K. pubcaster has ordered two pilot episodes of “Tonight With Vladimir Putin,” a semi-scripted talk show hosted by a CGI representation of the Russian leader. The first guest will be Alistair Campbell, a former high-ranking political spin doctor in the U.K. [...]

  • Upcoming Fantasy Shows Like 'Game of

    10 Upcoming Shows to Watch if You're Mourning 'Game of Thrones'

    Millions of people’s Sunday night routines are ruined now that “Game of Thrones” is over, and there are holes in their hearts as big as the hole in The Wall that are aching for a new fantasy series to fill them. Several prequel series are on their way, but as there’s no word on just [...]

  • Game of Thrones Composer Ramin Djawadi

    'Game of Thrones' Composer Ramin Djawadi: 'I'm Still in Denial'

    Since the first season, Ramin Djawadi has composed the music for “Game of Thrones” and created the epic tunes, including the iconic theme song, heard over the series’ most memorable moments. With the series finished, he talked with Zane Lowe on Apple Music’s Beats 1 about his experience on the show and an upcoming 20-city [...]

  • TUPAC SHAKUR black panther collection

    ‘Defiant Ones’ Director to Helm Docuseries on Tupac, Who Assaulted Him in 1993

    Director Allen Hughes, who helmed the award-winning HBO documentary “The Defiant Ones,” has closed a deal with Tupac Shakur’s estate for a five-part docuseries for which he will have full access to all of the late rapper’s released and unreleased recordings, writings and poetry, according to an announcement from his rep. The announcement says the [...]

  • Ellen DeGeneres -- The Ellen Show

    Ellen DeGeneres Extends Daytime Talk Show Run Through 2022

    Ellen DeGeneres is sticking with her daytime talk show. DeGeneres announced Tuesday that she has signed a new deal to continue hosting “The Ellen DeGeneres Show” through 2022. There had been rumors for some time that DeGeneres was planning to leave the show when her current contract was up in 2020, something she leaned into [...]

  • How YouTube Is Trying to Get

    How YouTube Is Trying to Get Will Smith His First-Ever Emmy Nomination (EXCLUSIVE)

    YouTube could be the key to Will Smith finally earning a Primetime Emmy nomination — or win. The superstar Formerly Known as the Fresh Prince has been nominated for two Academy Awards, five Golden Globes and one Screen Actors Guild Award, and has won four Grammys (out of eight nominations). Yet a Primetime Emmy nomination [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content