You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Laugh Tracks Are No Replacement for the Real Thing

A funny thing happened this pilot season. Or rather, a funny thing didn’t.

The networks turned out a handful of multi-cams with laugh tracks — or sweetened live studio audience recordings, as they like to refer to them.

Whatever you call it, it’s like nails on a chalkboard to me. And I know I’m not alone.

I love to laugh. Just don’t tell me when to do it.

This isn’t a rant against multi-cams: I adore “The Big Bang Theory,” and barely notice the audio. Maybe it’s because I’m laughing. Or maybe it’s because the show is actually — wait for it — funny.

And as a child of the ’70s and ’80s, I grew up on a steady diet of sitcoms. “MASH.” “Cheers.” “Happy Days.” “The Cosby Show.”

It’s not the format I have a problem with. It’s the humor, or the lack of faith in it.

My message to comedy writers is this: Believe in yourself — and your writing — enough. Tone down the laugh tracks. Not every word or sentence needs to be punctuated with a thunderous, eardrum-shattering roar of hilarity.

Write a funny show, and the laughs will follow naturally.

Sitting through recent panels at the TCA press tour, I couldn’t help but notice: The networks hired very talented, funny comedians, and then buried them in very unfunny shows. The general consensus in the room was that the panels themselves were far better than the pilots.

Given the opportunity to be spontaneous, the stars were bright, charming and rather clever.

John Mulaney on what he does with his Emmy from his work as a writer on “Saturday Night Live”: “I’m allowed to keep it out if my wife can put stuff on top of it. So we have it in our apartment in New York with a shirt and a stuffed animal on it.” (Maybe you had to be there.)

A multi-cam seems like the holy grail all the networks want, but only CBS seems to be able to achieve.

“They’re definitely harder to do,” said CBS entertainment chair Nina Tassler. “We have a very keen ability to identify those talents who can deliver that kind of comedy.”

I heard comedic legend Bob Newhart speak at a panel recently, and he said he could only perform in front of a live studio audience, because that was the only way he knew if the jokes were funny. He fed off their reactions.

At NBC’s executive session, entertainment chair Bob Greenblatt defended his ongoing pursuit of multi-cams.

“Just a few years ago some of the best shows on television were multi-cam comedies with live studio audiences,” he said. “I keep saying ‘Modern Family’ could easily have been a show with a studio audience in the way it was shot.”

The problem, he said, is that the cachet lies with single-cams like “The Office” and “30 Rock,” which not only won critical praise but also a slew of Emmy noms. “They kept becoming reinforced as single-cameras are the better form, and I really hope we can balance the scales a little bit.”

True, Emmy does tend to favor single cams — this year, the only multi-cam to crack the Emmy code is “Big Bang.”

But why does it have to be either/or? Can we experiment more with the form, beyond the overused dramedy?

Can we put a single-cam in front of an audience, and see what happens if audiences laugh — gasp — naturally? Or even just a lighter laugh track?

Funnier things have happened.

More TV

  • Syfy Cancels 'Nightflyers' After One Season

    Syfy Cancels 'Nightflyers' After One Season

    The George R.R. Martin drama “Nightflyers” has been canceled by Syfy after only one season. Based on the novella from the mastermind behind “Game of Thrones,” the show was seen as a big gamble for the NBCUniversal-owned cable network, as it represented the most expensive series it had ever developed. The network attempted to spark [...]

  • Batwoman Arrow

    The CW's 'Batwoman' Pilot Switches Directors, Adds Dougray Scott

    The CW has added veteran Scottish actor Dougray Scott to its “Batwoman” pilot as well as swapped in Marcos Siega for previous director David Nutter, Variety has learned. The pilot, which stars Ruby Rose as the eponymous caped heroine, is being helmed by DC TV head Greg Berlanti, and was penned by “Vampire Diaries” alum [...]

  • OG Review

    Review: 'O.G.' on HBO

    Jeffrey Wright, the most compelling reason to watch HBO’s new film “O.G.,” is among television’s best actors at switching between codes or manners of being. On “Westworld,” his timeline-toggling android swaps personae so delicately that his performance gains in resonance when recalled in retrospect. (Perhaps that’s why Wright has been so oddly underrated through the [...]

  • Nahnatchka Khan Writers Room

    Nahnatchka Khan Exits 20th Century Fox TV for Overall Deal at Universal

    Nahnatchka Khan has signed a four-year overall deal at Universal Television. The deal brings an end to the decade-plus Khan and her Fierce Baby Productions banner spent at 20th Century Fox Television. The move will see Khan exit from her role as showrunner on ABC comedy “Fresh Off the Boat,” which she also created. The [...]

  • David Ajala

    'Nightflyers' Star David Ajala Joins CBS Drama Pilot 'Under the Bridge'

    David Ajala has been cast in a lead role in the CBS drama pilot “Under the Bridge,” Variety has learned. In the project, when a scandal rocks the medical practice she runs with her husband and their friends, a surgeon rises to the occasion and takes the lead in trying to mend both the practice and [...]

  • A Man Walks Into the Cnn

    CNN Puts Former Sessions Aide in Newsroom Role

    Sarah Isgur Flores, a press aide to former US Attorney General Jeff Sessions, has been hired to help coordinate political coverage for CNN, a move that generated some pushback on social media Tuesday. Politico previously reported the CNN hire. Flores in the past has criticized CNN coverage, even going so far as to refer to [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content