Broadway Review: ‘Side Show’ Directed by Bill Condon

Erin Davie, Emily Padgett, Matthew Hydzik, Robert Joy, Ryan Silverman, David St. Louis.

The new, improved “Side Show” smells like a hit. Helmer Bill Condon’s shrewd reworking of this short-lived 1997 cult musical by Henry Krieger and Bill Russell (which comes to Gotham via La Jolla and the Kennedy Center) is both darker in tone and lighter in theme than memory has it. Leading ladies Emily Padgett and Erin Davie are perfection as Daisy and Violet Hilton, conjoined twins in real life who were plucked out of a carnival midway by a rascal showman and transformed into vaudeville stars. A lot of things that didn’t work in the original version still don’t work now, but no question about it, this show has the best freaks on Broadway.

The reworked book is all the better for keeping a tight focus on sassy Daisy (Padgett) and sweet Violet (Davie), country girls whose personal journey from obscurity to fame brings both happiness and heartbreak. It was also a smart creative decision to drop the original belligerent subtext (We’re-All-Freaks-Sucker-So-Don’t-Think-You’re-Normal), which allows the freaks to be freaks rather than metaphors.

The stunning opening number, “Come Look at the Freaks,” presents these social outcasts — among them a bearded lady, a hairy dog-boy and a lizard-man — in all their macabre glory as they slither out from the shadows created by Jules Fisher and Peggy Eisenhauer’s lighting design. Draping themselves all over David Rockwell’s murky carnival stage, they proudly exhibit their deformed bodies in the customized costumes (and nifty prostheses) designed by David and Lou Elsey. They must have been quite a sight during the bleak days of the 1930s Depression, reassuring the rubes that, no matter how badly off they were, they weren’t that badly off.

However alluring (or revolting) these unfortunates might appear to the customers who hand over their dimes and crowd into the sideshow tent, backstage they are one big family. Sir, the sleazy proprietor played in grand showman style by Robert Joy, isn’t the kindest boss to work for, but as a father figure, he represents the only stability that Daisy and Violet have ever known. Jake, the make-believe cannibal who is secretly in love with Violet, is a far better protector, especially in David St. Louis’ powerful performance.

But no one can protect the girls from Terry Connor (Ryan Silverman), a hustler who recognizes their potential value as vaudeville performers (“Very Well Connected”), and Buddy Foster (Matthew Hydzik), the sidekick who takes on the job of training them in the ways of show biz, winning hearts as “Typical Girls Next Door.” As we already know from their poignant desire to be “Like Everyone Else,” Daisy and Violet are ready to leave their family, and when they finally go (“Say Goodbye to the Sideshow”), the sense of loss is keen.

Costumer Paul Tazewell comes into his own when Daisy and Violet find fame and fortune on the vaudeville circuit. Stripping the girls of their innocent pink dresses, he drapes them in some really stunning numbers, from flirty red dresses and elegant suits to beaded white wedding gowns that look stunning on Padgett and Davie — who finally get some frocks as lovely as their glorious soprano voices.

But aside from the pretty clothes (and blonde hair) the twins get to wear, life on the vaudeville circuit can’t compare with the loving home they left in the first act. The twins’ individual characters are complex and, as played here, quite moving. The sentiments of “Who Will Love Me as I Am?” and “I Will Never Leave You” have thought and depth, and unlike the love songs, are not bellowed at the high decibel of football cheers.

But no one else is written with any depth whatsoever. Terry’s character is shockingly shallow and Buddy’s only slightly less so, salvaged by a modest note of sexual ambiguity. And while the clarity of the vocal arrangements enhance the lovely musicality of Krieger’s lyrical compositions, that lucidity also exposes the clunkiness of the lyrics, which land on defenseless ears like blunt instruments.


Popular on Variety

Broadway Review: 'Side Show' Directed by Bill Condon

St. James Theater; 1330 seats; $145 top. Opened Nov. 17, 2014. Reviewed Nov. 14. Running time: TWO HOURS, 30 MIN.

Production: A presentation by Darren Bagert, Martin Massman, Jayne Baron Sherman, Joan Raffe & Jhett Tolentino, Universal Stage Productions, Joined at the Hip Productions, Shadowcatcher Entertainment, CJ E&M / Mike Coolik, Michael M. Kaiser, Jim Kierstead, Marc David Levine, Clear Channel Spectacolor, Catherine & Fred Adler, Curtis Forsythe, Gloken, Highbrow & Nahem, Nobile Lehner Shea Productions, Pretty Freaks, Weatherby & Fishman, Mathew Masten, and Jujamcyn Theaters, in association with The John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts & La Jolla Playhouse, of a musical in two acts with book & lyrics by Bill Russell, music by Henry Krieger, additional book material by Bill Condon.

Creative: Directed by Bill Condon. Sets, David Rockwell; costumes, Paul Tazewell; lighting, Jules Fisher & Peggy Eisenhauer; sound, Peter Hylenski; makeup,  Cookie Jordan; special makeup effects, David Elsey & Lou Elsey; wigs & hair, Charles G. LaPointe; orchestrations, Harold Wheeler, musical direction & arrangements, Sam Davis; choreographer, Anthony Van Laast; production stage manager, Linda Marvel.

Cast: Erin Davie, Emily Padgett, Matthew Hydzik, Robert Joy, Ryan Silverman, David St. Louis.

More Legit

  • The Inheritance review

    'The Inheritance' Announces Broadway Cast

    After an Olivier-winning run in London, “The Inheritance” is gearing up for its Broadway debut. The two-part epic has set the cast for its transfer from the West End to the Great White Way. John Benjamin Hickey, Paul Hilton, Samuel H. Levine, Andrew Burnap and Kyle Soller are among the cast members reprising their roles [...]

  • Patrick Page, Amber Grey, Eva Noblezada,

    'Hadestown' Announces 2020 National Tour

    ‘Hadestown’, the eight-time Tony award winning Broadway musical, is set for a national tour in 2020. The show will stop in more than 30 cities including Denver, Houston, Los Angeles, Minneapolis, New Orleans, and more. The musical is a stage adaptation of the Greek myths of Orpheus and Eurydice and King Hades and his wife [...]

  • Jake Gyllenhaal

    Listen: Why Jake Gyllenhaal Is His 'Best Self' in the Theater

    Looking for the best possible version of Jake Gyllenhaal? You’ll find it onstage, according to the actor himself. Listen to this week’s podcast below: “I am my best self when I’m working in the theater,” Gyllenhaal said on the latest episode Stagecraft, Variety’s theater podcast, on which he appeared with Carrie Cracknell, the director of [...]

  • Photo: Jeremy Daniel

    'The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical' Gets Broadway Run

    “The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical” is Broadway bound. The musical adaptation of the franchise about a teenager who discovers he’s the son of Poseidon hits the Great White Way on Sept. 20 ahead of an Oct. 16 opening night. It comes on the heels of an extensive, nationwide tour that took the show [...]

  • Tom Sturridge Jake Gyllenhaal

    Jake Gyllenhaal and Tom Sturridge Celebrate 'Sea Wall/A Life' With Star-Studded Opening Night

    A star-studded audience looked on as Jake Gyllenhaal and Tom Sturridge returned to the stage for their double monologue performance in “Sea Wall/A Life.” Theater-goers and celebs including Anne Hathaway, Tom Hiddleston and John Mulaney gathered in Manhattan’s Hudson Theatre for opening night, celebrating a show tackling grief, birth and death through the eyes of [...]

  • Bat Out of Hell review

    Off Broadway Review: 'Bat Out of Hell'

    No one has ever accused Jim Steinman of subtlety. The composer behind Meat Loaf’s 1977 “Bat Out of Hell” (more than 43 million albums sold worldwide) and 1993’s “Bat Out of Hell II: Back into Hell” (five and six times platinum in the UK and US) has forever trafficked in a boldly theatrical brand of [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content