San Diego Theater Review: Steve Martin and Edie Brickell’s ‘Bright Star’

Carmen Cusack, A.J. Shively, Wayne Alan Wilcox, Hannah Elless, Stephen Lee Anderson, Stephen Bogardus, Patti Cohenour, Wayne Duvall, Jeff Hiller, Kate Loprest, Libby Winters, Allison Briner, Max Chernin, Paige Herschell, Leah Horowitz, Joe Jung, Lulu Lloyd, Ashley Robinson, Greg Roderick, Sarah Jane Shanks, Scott Wakefield.

Yep, that’s the real Steve Martin collaborating with roots-music queen Edie Brickell on the Old Globe premiere “Bright Star,” but not the wild and crazy guy with an arrow through his head nor the sophisticated satirist of “Shopgirl.” Rather, it’s the relaxed banjo-picking talk show guest, fingers pluckin’ out a gentle, tuneful, uninflected folk fable of loss and longing. If too rarefied for Gotham’s embrace (as the somewhat similar “Violet” was), this lyrical tuner could find ready acceptance regionally. Either way the storytelling would benefit from higher stakes and greater guts.

The plot centers on North Carolinian Alice Murphy (Carmen Cusack in a well-deserved star turn), doyenne of a prestigious Southern journal just after WWII. Trussed up in Jane Greenwood’s Peck & Peck tailoring (seemingly inspired by old Celeste Holm movies), loveless Alice spews Eve Arden wisecracks at the likes of returning G.I. Billy Cane (A.J. Shively, earnestly likeable): He says “You must be Miss Murphy”; she says “I don’t have to be, but I am.” Billy’s Pepsodent toothiness belies his ambition to scale literary heights.

As an editor, Alice made Hemingway bawl. But in flashback two decades earlier, toss away the glasses and hair bun and she reverts to the wild mountain gal of her youth, cutting a swath through Zebulon in a forbidden liaison with Jimmy Ray Dobbs (an underpowered Wayne Alan Wilcox), ineffectual scion of the town boss (Wayne Duvall, chomping down on his role like it’s a stogie). Helmer Walter Bobbie carries out her transformation and the many time shifts with grace and originality, complemented by Eugene Lee’s elegant, fluid backwoods designs.

Popular on Variety

Pre- and postwar eras are linked by some 20 numbers inspired by Brickell and Martin’s Grammy-winning “Love Has Come For You.” Urbanites with no ear for bluegrass may cry repetitiousness at the narrow instrumentation (banjo, guitar, piano and bass predominating). But if any playlist could win over roots-music skeptics it’d be this one, with lilting melodies, foot-stomping rhythms (nicely exploited at key moments by choreographer Josh Rhodes) and seamless integration of character, ballad, story and locale.

Songs aside, characterizations are distinctly undercooked. Guileless Billy seems untouched by wartime service, too callow to craft greeting cards let alone the “sweeping tale of pain and redemption” Alice unaccountably expects of him.

Meanwhile, she must be the least rebellious hellion the Blue Ridge ever saw, with a preacher dad (Stephen Lee Anderson) as fundamentalist-strict as a marshmallow. The dialogue keeps alluding to hardscrabble existence and emotional damage, but the tone at the Murphy cabin is sheer “Brady Bunch.”

Things are no more fraught at the Dobbs mansion, where we can’t tell whether limp Jimmy Ray is a flawed idealist, willing pawn or just plain schlemiel. Big Daddy cackles over a revenge scheme over the Murphys’ land rights that’s promptly forgotten; thereafter his role wavers nervously between good ol’ boy buffoonery and the essence of evil.

All this sleepy ambivalence causes major problems when act one’s finale suddenly goes full Southern gothic on us, in an act of sheer horror at which Flannery O’Connor might balk. It’s hugely out of kilter with what’s come before, sending the cast through hoops of illogic and shaky motivation after intermission.

No one’s asking for a gallery of Faulknerian grotesques. “Bright Star” clearly aims to be as life-affirming as act two’s gorgeous anthem to optimism, “Sun’s Gonna Shine.” Nevertheless, the stakes have to be raised throughout. Billy, girlfriend Margo (a lovely but underused Hannah Elless), Alice and Jimmy Ray can all become more invested in each other and affected by events.

If the creative team deepened characters’ needs and ratcheted up their conflicts, we’d be readier for the climactic turn. There’s a sweeping tale of pain and redemption in “Bright Star” clamoring to come out, and when it does, the movement to restore harmony and Arcadian balance will require less suspension of disbelief. We’ll happily waft along to down-home heaven, which is precisely where the show aims to take us.

San Diego Theater Review: Steve Martin and Edie Brickell's 'Bright Star'

Old Globe, San Diego; 585 seats; $144 top. Opened Sept. 28, 2014; reviewed Sept. 27; runs through Nov. 2. Running time: 2 HOURS, 15 MIN.

Production: An Old Globe presentation of a musical in two acts. Music by Steve Martin and Edie Brickell. Lyrics by Brickell. Book by Martin.

Creative: Directed by Walter Bobbie. Choreography, Josh Rhodes; sets, Eugene Lee; costumes, Jane Greenwood; lighting, Japhy Weideman; sound, Nevin Steinberg; musical supervisor, Peter Asher; musical director and vocal arrangements, Rob Berman; orchestrations, August Eriksmoen; stage manager, Anjee Nero.

Cast: Carmen Cusack, A.J. Shively, Wayne Alan Wilcox, Hannah Elless, Stephen Lee Anderson, Stephen Bogardus, Patti Cohenour, Wayne Duvall, Jeff Hiller, Kate Loprest, Libby Winters, Allison Briner, Max Chernin, Paige Herschell, Leah Horowitz, Joe Jung, Lulu Lloyd, Ashley Robinson, Greg Roderick, Sarah Jane Shanks, Scott Wakefield.

More Legit

  • Grand Horizons review

    'Grand Horizons': Theater Review

    Don’t stop me if you’ve heard this one, as you surely must have: A nice, all-American family is in the process of breaking up and trying to make this sad state of affairs seem funny in Bess Wohl’s Broadway outing “Grand Horizons.” After 50 years of marriage, Nancy (the ever-elegant Jane Alexander) and Bill (the [...]

  • Uncle Vanya review

    'Uncle Vanya': Theater Review

    Director Ian Rickson has had success with Chekhov in the past. His exquisitely balanced, tragicomic production of “The Seagull” (2007 in London, 2008 on Broadway) was well-nigh flawless with, among others, Kristin Scott Thomas as painfully vulnerable as she was startlingly funny. Sadly, with his production of “Uncle Vanya,” despite felicities in the casting, lightning [...]

  • The Welkin review

    'The Welkin': Theater Review

    A life hanging perilously in the balance of charged-up, polarized opinions: This courtroom drama could easily have been titled “Twelve Angry Women.” But playwright Lucy Kirkwood (“Chimerica,” “The Children”) is far too strong and imaginative a writer for so hand-me-down a cliché. Instead she opts for “The Welkin,” an old English term for the vault [...]

  • Tina Fey attends the "Mean Girls"

    Tina Fey Announces Movie Adaptation of Broadway's 'Mean Girls' Musical

    It’s good to be mean…the “Mean Girls” musical, that is. Producers of the hit Broadway show announced today that the Tony-nominated production is being adapted for the big screen for Paramount Pictures. The musical is based on the 2004 movie of the same name. “I’m very excited to bring ‘Mean Girls’ back to the big screen,’ Tina Fey, [...]

  • Freestyle Love Supreme

    Watch Lin-Manuel Miranda and 'Freestyle Love Supreme' in Exclusive Clip From Sundance Documentary

    Before turning “Hamilton” and “In the Heights” into musical phenomenons, Lin-Manuel Miranda could have been found on stage, spouting off-the-cuff rhymes with his improv group, “Freestyle Love Supreme.” After performing across the globe, the troupe — founded 15 years ago by Miranda, his frequent collaborator Thomas Kail and emcee Anthony Veneziale — made its Broadway [...]

  • Ariana Grande 7 Rings

    Rodgers & Hammerstein Are Having a Moment Thanks to Ariana Grande, 'Oklahoma!'

    Jaws dropped when it was revealed that the late musical theater titans Richard Rodgers and Oscar Hammerstein II were granted 90% of the songwriting royalties on “7 Rings,” Ariana Grande’s 2019 No. 1 hit. The dominant motif of Grande’s song is taken from “My Favorite Things,” the cornerstone of R&H’s 1959 musical “The Sound of [...]

  • A Soldiers Play review

    'A Soldier's Play': Theater Review

    Now, that’s what I call a play! Charles Fuller’s Pulitzer Prize-winning drama “A Soldier’s Play,” now being revived on Broadway by Roundabout Theatre Company, packs plenty of dramatic tension into smoldering issues of racial justice and injustice, military honor and dishonor, and the solemn struggle to balance their harrowing demands on characters who are only [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content