Idina Menzel Starrer ‘If/Then’ Navigates the Road to Broadway

Musical made a few tweaks since its Washington, D.C., tryout

If a show represents the only new musical on the spring Broadway slate that’s not tied to a well-known movie property, then will the tuner struggle to attract attention in a crowded season?

If the show is “If/Then,” then maybe not. Propelled by the cachet of a pedigreed creative team — including the stage return of Idina Menzel, suddenly hot from her work in Disney’s animated hit “Frozen” — “If/Then” topped $900,000 in its first week of seven previews, outpacing both “Rocky” and “The Bridges of Madison County,” and landing not much behind the per-performance average for “Aladdin,” which plays in a larger venue.

But even if “If/Then” surprised the Rialto with its B.O. strength, the show nonetheless faces the challenges inherent in serving up an entirely original story with no title recognition, as creatives and producers move forward without the help of a ready-made road map.

The musical, which follows two parallel lives that diverge in the wake of one woman’s fateful choice, reunites Tom Kitt and Brian Yorkey, the Pulitzer-winning duo of “Next to Normal,” with that project’s producer, David Stone, and its helmer, Michael Greif. It also reteams Stone with Menzel, who originated the role of Elphaba in the Stone-produced “Wicked.” Greif directed the actress in her breakout role in “Rent.”

Following a fall tryout in Washington, D.C., “If/Then” arrived on Broadway after D.C. critics and audiences agreed there was a lot to like in the ambitious new musical but that the clarity of its dual storytelling needed some work. The introduction of the two-lives device and the transitions between one life and the other were among the issues tackled by Kitt and Yorkey in the seven weeks of down-time between the final D.C. perf and the start of Gotham rehearsals.

“In a new story, if something doesn’t work, you don’t know how much to rip out and redo sometimes,” Kitt says. “There’s no proven version that you can go back to.” Adds Yorkey: “The dramaturgy of a new musical is so complicated that sometimes the thing that really needs to be fixed is way back in a song in act one.”

Early in the piece’s development, the writers considered following more than two branching lives, or delving further into the lives of the other characters affected by the protagonist’s decisions. “Ever since the initial workshops, it’s been an ongoing process of paring down and streamlining,” Greif says.

Since D.C., three songs have been cut, and two new tunes added; one has been notably repositioned, and several others have been tweaked, alongside the work done on the book and on staging elements to clarify the narrative.

For his part, Stone came away from D.C. with a better understanding of how to lure auds in to the narrative and to the show. “At first, we were being a little quiet about the story,” he admits. “But the more we can tell the audience about the central conceit, the easier it is not only to convince them to come — because people love that parallel-lives device — but the easier it is to get them onboard the story from the first minute.”

To that end, the poster image depicts a dark-haired woman standing at the head of a forked road, while TV and radio ads, as well as signage outside the theater, call out, mysteriously: “In one moment, Elizabeth will lead parallel lives. This is the story of both.”

The fact that the show turned out to be the only entirely original musical in a spring that’s heavy on movie tie-ins could prove as much of a prestige-bestowing blessing as a curse. Besides, the musical serendipitously opens on Broadway just as Menzel, already a legit fan-favorite, has achieved newfound stardom from “Frozen” and the Oscar attention for singing its showpiece tune “Let It Go.”

All that looks poised to sustain a new musical that, at $10 million, weighs in as a solidly midsized Broadway offering. “It’s not small like ‘Next to Normal,’ ” Stone says. “But it sure ain’t ‘Wicked.’ ”

More Legit

  • Broadway Bounty Hunter review

    Off Broadway Review: 'Broadway Bounty Hunter'

    Anyone wondering what genre-hopping composer-lyricist-book writer Joe Iconis would do as an encore to the Broadway run of Tony-nominated “Be More Chill” need look no further than his immediate past. Written for veteran stage actress Annie Golden and initially produced by Barrington Stage Company in Pittsfield, Mass. in 2016, “Broadway Bounty Hunter” is both an [...]

  • Because of Winn Dixie review

    Regional Theater Review: 'Because of Winn Dixie,' the Musical

    Watching the musical “Because of Winn Dixie” at Goodspeed Musicals in East Haddam, Conn., it’s hard not to think of another show that premiered in the same regional theater 43 years ago. It, too, featured a scruffy stray dog, a lonely-but-enterprising young girl and a closed-off daddy who finally opens up. But “Winn Dixie,” based [...]


    Off Broadway Review: 'Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow'

    There’s something about Anton Chekhov’s whiny sisters that invites comic sendups of “Three Sisters” like the one Halley Feiffer wrote on commission for the Williamstown Theater Festival. Transferred to MCC Theater’s new Off Broadway space and playing in the round in a black box with limited seating capacity, the crafty show feels intimate and familiar. [...]

  • the way she spoke review

    Off Broadway Review: 'The Way She Spoke' With Kate del Castillo

    Since the 1990s, scores of women in Juarez, Mexico have been mutilated, raped, and murdered at such a rate that some have called it an epidemic of femicide—killing women and girls solely because they are women. Isaac Gomez’s play “the way she spoke,” produced Off Broadway by Audible and starring Kate del Castillo, confronts the [...]


    Brian Cox Playing LBJ in Broadway Run of 'The Great Society'

    Brian Cox will play President Lyndon Johnson in the Broadway run of “The Great Society,” playwright Robert Schenkkan’s follow-up to “All the Way.” The role of Johnson, a crude, but visionary politician who used the office of the presidency to pass landmark civil rights legislation and social programs, was originally played by Bryan Cranston in [...]

  • Paul McCartney Has Penned Score for

    Paul McCartney Has Been Secretly Writing an 'It's a Wonderful Life' Musical

    The pop superstar who once released a movie and album called “Give My Regards to Broad Street” really does have designs on Broadway, after all. It was revealed Wednesday that Paul McCartney has already written a song score for a stage musical adaptation of the 1946 Frank Capra film classic “It’s a Wonderful Life.” The [...]

  • The Night of the Iguana review

    West End Review: 'The Night of the Iguana' With Clive Owen

    If Tennessee Williams is the poet laureate of lost souls, none of his characters as are off-grid as the restless travelers trying to make it through his little-seen 1961 play, “The Night of the Iguana.” Holed up in a remote Mexican homestay, its ragtag itinerants live hand-to-mouth, day by day, as they seek refuge from [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content