You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Venice Film Review: ‘The Council of Birds’

Timm Kroeger’s intriguing graduation film set in 1929 looks terrific yet is too awash in unarticulated German Romanticism, full of unresolved minor keys and mystical expectations.

Thorsten Wien, Eva Maria Jost, Daniel Krauss, Christian Bluemel, Andreas Conrad, Theo Leutert.  

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3895678/reference

In 1929, three pals search for a composer friend who’s hidden himself away in the woods in the intriguingly febrile “The Council of Birds,” an impressive graduation film from Timm Kroeger that looks terrific yet is rather too awash in unarticulated German Romanticism. Conspicuously steeped in the period’s literary and musical culture, with its unresolved minor keys and mystical expectations of what’s on the horizon (spiritually, socially, politically), the pic boasts lovely textured visuals that prove digital really can approach the look of celluloid, in the right hands. Fests will take “Council,” partly in anticipation of the budding director’s forthcoming efforts.

Viewers familiar with the cultural and philosophical movements of the era are the target audience, those conversant in German Romanticism’s cult of nature and the quasi-quivering sense of man’s spiritual betterment via a pure environment. Paul Leinert (Thorsten Wien), his new wife Anna (Eva Maria Jost) and their friend Wilhelm Krueck (Daniel Krauss) trek into a remote forest on the invitation of Otto Schiffmann (Christian Bluemel), a post-Wagnerian composer who’s there to escape his collapsed marriage as well as Berlin and its fondness for “Hindemith and negro music.”

After walking through majestic woods for hours, the trio find Otto’s cabin in a chaotic state. His dog Ani is there, but not Otto. The friends settle in to calmly wait. And wait. Paul is contemplative, in awe of his friend’s musical talents; Anna does “womanly” things like cook and tidy up, while Willi, the most active of the group, plays with Ani and takes photographs. Inside the house, long shadows cast a pall on the interior, and the ticking clock sounds loudly throughout the rooms. Without warning, Otto returns, silent and sitting in the gloom.

While he sleeps, Anna washes Otto’s fevered body. He suddenly awakes and kisses her; she pulls back in surprise and then meets his lips. The clock’s ticking is silenced, and a postcoital shot of Anna smoking, leaning against a tree and exuding a sloppy fecundity, says everything one needs to know. In fact, it says too much  the image might work in a 1950s meller, but seems very out of place here, despite Kroeger’s conscious attempt to imitate a restrained cinematic style of the past.

It often feels like “The Council of Birds” is trying to reproduce in film the pregnant uncertainty of minor-key passages in Mahler, Wagner, and Hans Pfitzner, the three composers whose music is featured so prominently. Kroeger keeps an air heavily laden with mystery, his protags constantly on the verge of a discovery  about themselves, about their surroundings  which he deliberately keeps unresolved, even in the coda set in 1932. It’s tempting to read the sense of dread as a foreshadowing of Germany’s impending path to hell, though Kroeger refuses to offer so pat an analysis.

In terms of characterization, everyone is underwritten, more metaphor than flesh and blood. The one exception is Anna, thanks in large part to Jost’s palpable screen presence, exuding conflicted period flavor as if she’s part Kristina Soederbaum, part Heidemarie Hatheyer. Most striking of all however are the visuals, profoundly influenced by German painting in the way diffused light filters through the pale green trees, their tall, slender trunks acting as both barrier and haven. Roland Stuprich’s surprisingly mature lensing (this is his first feature) plays off long and medium shots, ensuring that the dense forest’s troubling call remains a co-protagonist alongside the actors.

Popular on Variety

Venice Film Review: 'The Council of Birds'

Reviewed at Venice Film Festival (Critics’ Week), Sept. 3, 2014. Running time: 81 MIN. (Original title: “Zerrumpelt Herz”)

Production: (Germany) A Filmakademie Baden-Wuerttemberg production. Produced by Viktoria Stolpe.  

Crew: Directed by Timm Kroeger. Screenplay, Roderick Warich, Kroeger. Camera (color, HD, widescreen), Roland Stuprich; editor, Jann Anderegg; production designer, Cosima Vellenzer; costume designers, Sarai Feuerherdt, Romy Mueller; sound (5.1), Aljoscha Haupt, Heiko Nickerl, Oscar Stiebitz; visual effects, Kariem Saleh; assistant director, Elsa Kremser.  

With: Thorsten Wien, Eva Maria Jost, Daniel Krauss, Christian Bluemel, Andreas Conrad, Theo Leutert.  

More Film

  • Gaston Pavlovich

    Gaston Pavlovich Talks About Producing 'The Irishman'

    Through his production company Fabrica De Cine, Gastón Pavlovich is one of the producers on Martin Scorsese’s two most recent movies: 2016’s “Silence” and 2019’s “The Irishman.” The 51-year-old native of Mexico first gained notice as an executive producer on the Tom Hanks comedy-drama “A Hologram for the King.” Pavlovich also began working with Scorsese [...]

  • Joker

    How 'Joker' Production Designer and Costume Designer Brought New Color to a Familiar World

    The partnership between a film’s production designer and costume designer is an important one. One creates the outfits and the look of the character, the other creates the world that the viewer disappears into. Together, they collaborate to reinforce the visuals of the film. Todd Phillips’ “Joker” is a world where production designer Mark Friedberg [...]

  • History-of-the-Occult

    Blood Window Announces 2019 WIP and World Premiere Lineup (EXCLUSIVE)

    Ventana Sur’s Blood Window sidebar for projects and films in progress has been a standout event on the Latin horror calendar since its launch in 2013, and is one of the Buenos Aires market’s most popular sections. In the following years, it has become a key two-way conduit between Latin American and international festivals and [...]

  • Scarlett Johansson Chris Evans Actors on

    Why Chris Evans Thinks Scarlett Johansson and Adam Driver Need Oscars for 'Marriage Story'

    Scarlett Johansson (“Marriage Story”) isn’t afraid to ask for another take and she encourages young actors to do the same. Johansson revealed her thought process behind multiple takes while shooting during an intimate conversation with Chris Evans (“Knives Out”) for “Variety Studio: Actors on Actors.” “I feel like if you have an idea — and [...]

  • 'Harriet' Movie: Why It Doesn't Mention

    Why 'Harriet' Doesn't Mention the $20 Bill

    In “Harriet,” directed and co-written by Kasi Lemmons, Cynthia Erivo plays Harriet Tubman, who escaped slavery, joined the Underground Railroad and then freed more than 70 people from slavery. (Spoilers about the movie ahead.) Though Tubman died in 1913 at age 91, the movie ends during the Civil War, with Tubman leading a troop of [...]

  • Frank Grillo Maggie Q

    Frank Grillo, Maggie Q to Star in Thriller 'Cutman' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Frank Grillo and Maggie Q will star in “Cutman,” a dramatic thriller directed by Michael Mailer and written by Tiffany Heath. Grillo will play an over-the-hill boxer who begins working as the muscle for a local gangster. His life takes an unexpected turn when he meets a young girl whose mother is a heroin addict [...]

  • Jamie Foxx Renee Zellweger Shuzhen Zhao

    Oscar Predictions 2019: Breaking Down the Early Frontrunners

    The Oscar race is on. Renée Zellweger is a sure bet to snag a nomination for her transformation in “Judy” and Adam Driver looks certain to be a nominee for his work in Noah Baumbach’s “Marriage Story.” In the lead for best picture are movies including “The Irishman,” “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood” and [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content