×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Sundance Film Review: ‘Happy Valley’

Amir Bar-Lev offers a typically gripping and thoughtful take on the Penn State scandal.

With:

Matt Sandusky, Andrew Shubin, Joe Posnanski, Jay Paterno, Scott Paterno, Sue Paterno, Matt Jordan, Lou Prato, Michael Pilato.

In his documentaries “My Kid Could Paint That” and “The Tillman Story,” Amir Bar-Lev zeroed in on the difference between the public perception of a scandal and the private truth of the matter — a theme that serves him no less effectively in “Happy Valley,” a gripping inquiry into the revelations of sexual abuse that shocked the U.S. and devastated Penn State’s storied football program. Rather than focusing primarily on Jerry Sandusky’s crimes, the film broadens in scope and complexity to examine the assumptions of an entire community, as well as the football-first culture that allowed evil to flourish in its midst. Distinguished by its measured, analytical approach and revelatory testimony from Sandusky’s adopted and abused son, Matt, this nuanced but quietly excoriating work merits widespread exposure, and could be especially well timed to coincide with the still-ongoing court proceedings against three former university administrators.

The acts of molestation and rape committed against young boys over a 15-year period by Jerry Sandusky, a 30-year member of the football coaching staff at Pennsylvania State U., are quickly recounted here: Police photographs and victims’ statements flash before the camera, along with skin-crawling archival clips of Sandusky promoting the Second Mile, his nonprofit charity devoted to serving underprivileged kids. But as its ironic title would suggest, “Happy Valley” (as the State College area is often known) takes a broader view of the matter, as Bar-Lev proves less interested in profiling a monster than in penetrating the cone of silence that shielded him for so long. To that end, he singles out the troubled legacy of the late Joe Paterno, the beloved head coach and Penn State figurehead who was removed from the university for his failure to report Sandusky’s actions to police.

Early video of onlookers gathered at the courthouse on June 22, 2012, cheering loudly when Sandusky is found guilty on 45 counts of child abuse, is later startlingly contrasted with shots of Penn State students rioting on Nov. 9, 2011, outraged by the news of Paterno’s removal. It’s a juxtaposition that gets at all the questions of denial, complicity and moral responsibility at the heart of the case: How much did Paterno and his colleagues know, for how long, and what did they do (or not do) about it? Yet the footage of students protesting — chanting “We want JoePa!” and “Fuck the media!” and at one point overturning a truck — also speaks to a larger point about what happens when college football becomes not just a diversion or a pastime, but a way of life.

If there’s an analogy to be drawn to the Catholic Church’s abuse scandals, it’s that the Sandusky affair was also effectively enabled by a religion — one that, in the forms of Paterno and Sandusky, came complete with its own untouchable deities. Shots of fans cheering wildly at football games take on a chilling lyricism that may briefly remind you of the acts of worship filmed in “Jesus Camp” (at the film’s post-screening Q&A, Bar-Lev invoked Leni Riefenstahl). Here and in his interviews, the director means to locate the point where love of the game is allowed to take priority over all else, whether it’s a few officials shielding a pedophile or a town going into damage-control mode.

SEE MORE: Sandusky’s Son Hopes ‘Happy Valley’ Will Empower Abuse Survivors

The strength of the film’s approach is the way it builds a potent moral argument while still remaining even-handed toward all involved. A die-hard Penn State fan may come off as more clueless than he realizes when he criticizes the candlelight vigil that was held in lieu of the traditional pre-game “rally in the Valley,” yet you can just about sympathize with his anger that, in the wake of the controversy, the community lost something precious and vital. Paterno’s sons Scott and Jay offer honest, heartfelt assessments of their father’s tarnished career; their widowed mother, Sue, clearly crushed, is treated no less sympathetically. Yet there’s no mistaking the family’s sense of misplaced victimhood when they hire an independent investigator to effectively diminish Paterno’s culpability in the matter.

Even as its argument takes shape, “Happy Valley” continues to deepen in complexity. The filmmakers would appear to support the NCAA’s assessment of an unhealthy “culture of reverence” for Penn State’s football program, yet they also give voice to the argument that the crippling sanctions imposed on the school in 2012 were a sort of shaming spectacle, part of the public ritual of repentance that always sets in whenever scandal rears its head. Some of the documentary’s most fascinating material — a few priceless altercations filmed near the bronze statue of Paterno on campus (it was ultimately torn down), artist Michael Pilato having to repeatedly alter the images in his famous Penn State mural as the allegations mounted — examines the very human impulse to enshrine our highest achievers through art. The speed with which the town turned on Paterno, attempting to blot out even the positive aspects of his legacy, raises the question of whether history, always a mix of pride and shame, should ever be erased.

In keeping with traditional media practice, the sexual-abuse victims remain unnamed here, with the singular exception of Matt Sandusky, whose soul-baring interview with Bar-Lev forms the core of the picture. Slowly but with great purpose, he recalls how the Sandusky family rescued him from a childhood of poverty and neglect, only to plunge him into a completely different nightmare — one he felt duty-bound to keep secret until conscience forced him to bring it to light. For a film that is very much about the need to continually question our heroes and hold them to a higher standard, “Happy Valley” offers an unapologetic tribute to one man’s painful honesty and a tacit rebuke to those who couldn’t muster anywhere near the same courage.

Bar-Lev’s technically polished production premiered at Sundance just a month after director Eric Proulx’s docu “365 Days: A Year in Happy Valley” began screening in and around State College. A biopic starring Al Pacino as Paterno is also in the works.

Sundance Film Review: 'Happy Valley'

Reviewed at Sundance Film Festival (Documentary Premieres), Jan. 19, 2014. Running time: 98 MIN.

Production:

(Documentary) An A&E Indiefilms presentation of an Asylum Entertainment, Passion Pictures production. Produced by Jonathan Koch, Steve Michaels, John Battsek, Ken Dornstein. Executive producers, Molly Thompson, Robert DeBitetto, David McKillop. Co-producer, Ezekiel Morgan.

Crew:

Directed by Amir Bar-Lev. Camera (color, HD), Sean Kirby, Nelson Hume; editor, Dan Swietlik; music, H. Scott Salinas; supervising sound editor/re-recording mixer, Richard Fairbanks; line producer, Alice Henty.

With:

Matt Sandusky, Andrew Shubin, Joe Posnanski, Jay Paterno, Scott Paterno, Sue Paterno, Matt Jordan, Lou Prato, Michael Pilato.

More Film

  • UGC Distribution Closes on Mariano Cohn’s

    Ventana Sur: UGC Distribution Closes Market Hit ‘4 x 4’ (EXCLUSIVE)

    BUENOS AIRES — UGC Distribution has beaten out all other suitors to clinch what had became by Friday morning the most anticipated deal of this year’s Ventana Sur market: All rights to France on Argentine Mariano Cohn’s “4 x 4,” sold by Latido Films and distributed throughout Argentina by Disney. After mounting speculation about which [...]

  • Aquaman 2018

    Film News Roundup: 'Aquaman' Hits $152 Million at International Box Office

    In today’s film news roundup, “Aquaman” has already grossed more than $150 million outside the U.S., Michael Masini joins “Birds of Prey,” and Freestyle buys the documentary “Shamanic Trekker.” BOX OFFICE More Reviews Tallinn Film Review: 'Winter's Night' TV Review: 'Vanity Fair' Warner Bros.’ tentpole “Aquaman” has taken in $152 million overseas in 36 markets, [...]

  • 'Winter's Night' Review: Enigmatic, Offbeat Korean

    Tallinn Film Review: 'Winter's Night'

    There are thousands of films about love’s beginning, and a great many about love’s end. But far fewer deal with a relationship’s late-middle: the spreading, sluggish delta of coupledom when decades of familiarity, if they have not bred contempt, at least threaten irritation. “Winter’s Night,” Jang Woo-jin’s playfully melancholic third feature, after the acclaimed “A [...]

  • Tomasz Kot UTA

    UTA Signs ‘Cold War’ Star Tomasz Kot (EXCLUSIVE)

    UTA has signed “Cold War” star Tomasz Kot. He has appeared in more than 30 films and 26 plays as well as dozens of television series. More Reviews Tallinn Film Review: 'Winter's Night' TV Review: 'Vanity Fair' Most recently, Kot has received award-season buzz for his starring role as Wiktor in Pawel Pawlikowski’s feature “Cold [...]

  • Kenneth Branagh's 'All Is True' Opening

    Kenneth Branagh's 'All Is True' Opening Palm Springs Film Festival

    The 30th annual Palm Springs International Film Festival will open on Jan. 3 with historical drama “All Is True,” starring Kenneth Branagh, Judi Dench, and Ian McKellen. Branagh, who will be in attendance at the opening night screening, directed from Ben Elton’s script about the little-known period in the final years of William Shakespeare. Branagh [...]

  • Actor and Activist Rodney Kageyama Dies

    Actor and Activist Rodney Kageyama Dies at 77

    Actor, activist and influentials member of the Japanese American community, Rodney Kageyama, died in his sleep Dec. 9. He was 77. The SAG member was known for roles in “Karate Kid IV” with Hillary Swank, Ron Howard’s film “Gung Ho” and the spinoff sitcom, and the TV movie “Hiroshima: Out of the Ashes” with Max [...]

  • Most Popular Films 2018: The Best

    9 Holiday Gift Ideas Inspired by This Year's Most Popular Films

    From superheroes to super nannies, 2018 was a year full of memorable characters — and memorable movies. Whether you’re a big film buff, an avid follower of a popular franchise, or have a couple movie fans in your life, here are nine gifts that capture the fun of some of this year’s biggest films. 1. [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content