×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘The Tribe’

Performed entirely in sign language with nary a subtitle nor a syllable of spoken dialogue, Myroslav Slaboshpytskiy's prize-winning debut feature is an audacious coup de cinema.

With:
Grigoriy Fesenko, Yana Novikova, Rosa Babiy, Alexander Dsiadevich, Yaroslav Biletskiy, Ivan Tishko, Alexander Osadchiy, Alexander Sidelnikov, Sasha Rusakov, Denis Gruba, Dania Bykobiy, Lenia Pisanenko, Alexander Panivan, Kirill Koshik, Marina Panivan, Tatiana Radchenko, Ludmila Rudenko. (Sign language)

Actions, emotions and desperate impulses speak far louder than words in “The Tribe,” a formally audacious coup de cinema that marks a stunning writing-directing debut for Ukrainian filmmaker Myroslav Slaboshpytskiy. Set largely within the walls of a boarding school for the deaf that reveals itself as a violent cesspool of organized crime, this bleak, pitiless yet weirdly exhilarating drama is performed entirely in sign language by an ensemble of non-professional young actors, with nary a subtitle nor a syllable of spoken dialogue — a demanding high-concept stunt that accrues multiple layers of meaning as the picture moves toward its bone-chilling conclusion. Breathtakingly controlled, riveting even at its most inscrutable, this worthy winner of three Cannes Critics’ Week prizes looks to be a significant conversation-piece at every festival it plays, and should parlay glowing critical response into serious arthouse exposure.

It will be especially interesting to see what deaf viewers make of Slaboshpytskiy’s highly accomplished first feature; engrossingly expanded from the writer-director’s 2010 short, “Deafness,” it’s an unflinchingly pessimistic portrait of a youthful underground subculture that has dealt with its social disadvantages by turning to thuggery and prostitution. Given the emotional/inspirational thrust of so many movies and TV shows (from “Children of a Lesser God” to TV’s “Switched at Birth”) featuring deaf characters, who are often presented in relation to their hearing friends and family, there’s something coldly bracing about “The Tribe’s” total immersion strategy, as well as its utter refusal to sentimentalize its characters and the harsh, isolated world they inhabit.

Our guide to that world is Sergey (Grigoriy Fesenko), a young man whom we first see making his way to the school where he has just enrolled. As he adjusts to his new environment — after being welcomed by a teacher into a classroom, he’s quickly initiated into his fellow students’ decidedly less educational activities — the film establishes a visual style of meticulously composed widescreen master shots, alternating fixed perspectives with occasional camera movements orchestrated in long, fluid single takes. (The cinematographer is Valentyn Vasyanovych, making his own knockout feature debut.)

It’s a rigorous aesthetic that seasoned festivalgoers and arthouse patrons will immediately recognize (especially those familiar with a certain strain of Eastern European realist cinema), and it’s uniquely suited to one of the director’s chief aims here, which is to convey a form of sustained, non-verbal communication among large groups of individuals. For those with little or no understanding of sign language (presumably most of the audience), “The Tribe” will prove a sometimes perplexing yet endlessly stimulating viewing experience that demands, and rewards, the closest kind of attention. Sans dialogue or translation, each interaction effectively becomes a puzzle to be solved, and Slaboshpytskiy is brilliant at using ambiguity to heighten rather than dull the viewer’s perceptions. Even when the meaning of a particular exchange eludes us, a greater sense of narrative comprehension begins to take hold.

After a few obligatory hazing rituals, Sergey is adopted into “the tribe” of the title, where he’s put to work as a low-ranking thug in a gang with a surprisingly clear hierarchy. First he takes part in a few petty robberies, and eventually he becomes a pimp, dragging around two female classmates who service drivers at a nightly truck stop. (Sergey’s predecessor in this role actually died on the job, as seen in a sequence executed with great ingenuity and pitch-black humor.) Very much in on the sordid proceedings is the school’s woodshop teacher, who’s planning to send the girls abroad to Italy — a scheme that runs into trouble when Sergey makes the mistake of falling for one of them, Anna (played with fire and vulnerability by Yana Novikova). This occasions several explicit lovemaking scenes in which some of the more adventurous sexual positions seem to have been dictated, at least in part, by the rigid symmetry of the frame.

Sergey and Anna’s affair represents a fateful breach of the gang’s literally unspoken laws, and from there “The Tribe” becomes a mesmerizing and methodically detailed procedural, observing as a hotheaded lone wolf steps out of line and is duly punished by the designated alphas. The consequences are grim and harrowing, never more so than in one extended sequence so unsparing that you may wish, for once, that Slaboshpytskiy would avert his gaze. But he never does, instead maintaining an unblinking concentration as Sergey is moved to swift, decisive action, paving the way for a shockingly brutal finale.

At times the film’s formalist approach conveys the feeling of being eerily suspended in an alien environment, one where everyone has adopted sign language not as a substitute for speech, but as a defiant, even triumphant alternative. At other times — as when a mass melee seems to break out almost in slow-motion, or when a robbery unfolds in a left-to-right Steadicam shot — we could be watching a bizarre dance performance as enacted by a silent flash mob. For a picture set amid such unrelenting ugliness (Vlad Odudenko’s grotty production design is all harshly lit corridors and graffiti-strewn exteriors), “The Tribe” offers no shortage of aesthetic satisfactions: As an intricate exercise in group choreography, it’s never less than fascinating to behold, while Sergiy Stepanskiy’s vividly detailed sound design fills in the aural vacuum, registering every slap, punch and sharp intake of breath.

But Slaboshpytskiy’s film is finally most remarkable for the way it strips its characters to their raw, ferocious essence, while still allowing them to fully retain their distinctiveness as individuals. Operating well beyond the fringes of respectable society, these young men and women may well be the pawns and agents of a cruelly exploitative system, but they still come across as thinking, feeling human beings, each one desperately trying to assert his or her own place in a ruthless ruling order. To that end, these untrained actors perform with an intense, abrasive physicality that’s almost frightening in its eloquence; dialogue has rarely seemed more superfluous, as every gesture feels charged with attitude and emotion. The purity of expression Slaboshpytskiy achieves here may well take some viewers back to the silent era, but in finding its own bold cinematic language, “The Tribe” feels like something unmistakably, radically new.

Film Review: 'The Tribe'

Reviewed at Cannes Film Festival (Critics' Week), May 21, 2014. (Also in Karlovy Vary Film Festival  Special Event.) Running time: 130 MIN. (Original title: "Plemya")

Production: (Ukraine) A Garmata Film Prod. production with the support of Ukrainian State Film Agency, Hubert Bals Fund of Intl. Film Festival Rotterdam, Rinat Akhmetov Foundation "Development of Ukraine." (International sales: Alpha Violet, Paris.) Produced by Iya Myslytska, Valentyn Vasyanovych.

Crew: Directed, written by Myroslav Slaboshpytskiy. Camera (color, widescreen, HD), Valentyn Vasyanovich; editor, Vasyanovych; production designer, Vlad Odudenko; costume designer, Alena Gres; sound designer, Sergiy Stepanskiy.

With: Grigoriy Fesenko, Yana Novikova, Rosa Babiy, Alexander Dsiadevich, Yaroslav Biletskiy, Ivan Tishko, Alexander Osadchiy, Alexander Sidelnikov, Sasha Rusakov, Denis Gruba, Dania Bykobiy, Lenia Pisanenko, Alexander Panivan, Kirill Koshik, Marina Panivan, Tatiana Radchenko, Ludmila Rudenko. (Sign language)

More Film

  • Ava DuVernay Toby Emmerich Michael Douglas

    Ava DuVernay, Toby Emmerich, Michael Douglas to Speak at Produced By Conference

    Ava DuVernay, Toby Emmerich, and Michael Douglas will speak at the Producers Guild of America’s 11th Produced By Conference. The event will be held on June 8-9 at Warner Bros. Studios in Burbank, Calif. More Reviews West End Review: 'Emilia' Film Review: Tim Burton's 'Dumbo' Other notable speakers include Netflix executive Cindy Holland; Blumhouse producer [...]

  • Jean Francois Helene Etzi

    Disney's French Chief Jean-Francois Camilleri Exiting, Helene Etzi Upped

    Jean-Francois Camilleri is leaving Disney after more than 30 years and will replaced as the head of its French operation by Helene Etzi. Sources said Camilleri’s departure was his own decision. He announced his exit on Twitter, Tuesday, and paid tribute to his team and colleagues at Disney, thanking them for the “unique adventure.” More [...]

  • dumbo Tim Burton

    Film Review: Tim Burton's 'Dumbo'

    The key image in Walt Disney’s 1941 “Dumbo” is something out of a fairy-tale daydream: Dumbo, the baby elephant with long-lashed goo-goo eyes, a cuddly grin, and ears as long and floppy as wings, flapping those ears to soar around a circus big top, flying over the crowds with a freedom as touching as it [...]

  • Guys and Dolls

    'Guys and Dolls' Getting Remade at TriStar (EXCLUSIVE)

    “Guys and Dolls,” the venerable Broadway musical, is set to return to the big screen. TriStar Pictures has purchased remake rights to the original Damon Runyon short stories about gamblers and gangsters that inspired the shows, as well as the rights to the Broadway musical with its book by Jo Swerling and Abe Burrows and [...]

  • Captain America: Civil War

    'Black Widow,' 'Little Women,' 'Charlie's Angels' Among Most Tracked Female Directed Projects, IMDb Says (EXCLUSIVE)

    Greta Gerwig’s “Little Women,” Cate Shortland’s “Black Widow,” Patty Jenkins’s “Wonder Woman 2,” and Elizabeth Banks’s “Charlie’s Angles” are among the ten most tracked projects on IMDbPro. Ava DuVernay (“Selma”), Sofia Coppola (“Lost in Translation”), Chloé Zhao (“The Rider”), and Susanne Bier (“After the Wedding”) rank among the most widely followed female directors on the [...]

  • European Union Placeholder

    European Parliament Gives Final Approval to Controversial Article 13 Copyright Directive

    The European Parliament on Tuesday gave final approval to Article 13, a controversial part of a wider directive that shakes up the rules around copyright in the European Union. The new rules will have ramifications for online platforms, content owners and creators, and the general public. The proposed new framework, now approved, has sparked widespread [...]

  • Fox Disney Layoffs

    Fox Studio Quickly Fades Away as Disney Starts Work on Integration

    In the waning days of 21st Century Fox, there was a run on the searchlight. As Disney neared the completion of its $71.3 billion acquisition of 21st Century Fox, employees on the Fox lot rushed into the studio’s gift shop to pick up mugs, shot glasses, sweatshirts, hats and T-shirts emblazoned with 20th Century Fox’s [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content