Film Review: ‘The Oscar-Nominated Short Films 2014: Documentary’

While not as formally groundbreaking as the feature crop, the Oscar doc short nominees get up close and personal with their subjects.

In selecting its shortform nonfiction nominees this year, the Academy chose to celebrate directors who found a way to humanize heavy issues. While the underlying subjects range from hate crimes to the Holocaust, the films themselves feel intimate and personal, introducing viewers to extraordinary people and leaving the impression, long after their relatively short running times have elapsed, of our having encountered someone special. Although these five nominees are probably the least-seen of the entire ballot, they represent the greatest chance for discovery, introducing talented filmmakers and fascinating individuals worth seeking out either in theaters or on-demand.

Earning fresh headlines on Oscar week with the passing of its subject, “The Lady in No. 6” reflects the optimism and vitality of 109-year-old pianist Alice Herz-Sommer, a little old Czech lady possessed of infectious positivity. Herz-Sommer takes nothing for granted, having survived the Theresienstadt concentration camp after being selected to join its orchestra, which partly explains the pic’s subtitle, “Music Saved My Life.” But through a sometimes-clumsy mix of photos and narration, Oscar winner Malcolm Clarke (“You Don’t Have to Die”) considers more than just Herz-Sommer’s wartime experience. At the time he filmed her, Herz-Sommer still played daily, having long since forgiven her tormentors. With a charitable smile, she waves off Germany’s sins and credits the country instead with giving the world Bach, Beethoven and Brahms.

Forgiveness is also the subject of Jason Cohen’s “Facing Fear,” a simultaneously devastating and inspirational retelling of how Matthew Boger, a homeless gay teen who had been randomly targeted, beaten and left for dead by a gang of neo-Nazi punks, later found the strength to befriend Tim Zaal, the very aggressor whose boot mark remains permanently etched in his forehead. Coincidentally, the two met at Los Angeles’ Museum of Tolerance and now give presentations together about prejudice, reconciliation and the often-difficult concept of putting oneself in another’s shoes — lessons that the elegantly assembled short now brings to an even wider audience.

Popular on Variety

Because the doc shorts run longer than their live-action and animated counterparts, distributor ShortsHD has divided the nonfiction offerings into two programs. Running between the two aforementioned nominees is “Karama Has No Walls,” which combines astonishing verite footage of an attack on nonviolent protestors in Yemen’s Change Square with a more traditional and baldly sentimental series of interviews with the parents of victims killed in the massacre. While the adults put the loss of life in emotional context, the most impressive aspect of the film is how thoroughly several young men managed to document the attack, in which local goons, rooftop snipers and a phalanx of military reinforcements set a wall on fire and proceeded to shoot the peacefully assembled demonstrators, often targeting those with cameras. In this day and age, the revolution will always be televised.

Though unaffiliated with a specific political cause, Jeffrey Karoff’s “Cavedigger” otherwise complements the other nominees in that it, too, reveals a remarkable human being, providing deeper insight into an individual within the space of 39 minutes than the others manage. A unique artist committed to carving cavernous dwellings out of New Mexico sandstone, Ra Paulette has pushed himself away from loved ones and patrons alike, seeking some sort of ineffable communion with the earth. With gorgeous hi-def lensing by d.p. Anghel Decca and an atmosphere as invigorating as those Southwest desert vortexes, the “Walden”-like portrait serves as a reflection on obsession, creativity and, to a surprising extent, one’s priorities vis-a-vis the modern world.

While thoughts of legacy still linger on the mind, Edgar Barens’ HBO-bound “Prison Terminal: The Last Days of Private Jack Hall” humanely reveals how an Iowa inmate incarcerated for life spends his final stretch. Whereas countless docus have explored the subject of death row, “Prison Terminal” asks the question few ever consider — namely, how do those sentenced to die in prison actually die in prison? Rather than focus on the Iowa State Penitentiary’s unique hospice program, Barens chooses to follow one patient, Hall, a former P.O.W. who found himself behind bars again for a murder which he doesn’t regret. Hall’s crime is of little interest to Barens, who similarly de-emphasizes any stylistic interference, focusing instead on the idea of dignity in death, even for those whom society condemns.

Film Review: 'The Oscar-Nominated Short Films 2014: Documentary'

Reviewed online, Paris, Feb. 27, 2014. Running time: 184 MIN. 


A ShortsHD release presented with Magnolia Pictures. Produced by Carter Pilcher, Leif Nelson.


The Lady in No. 6: Music Saved My Life
(Canada-U.S.-U.K.) Reed Entertainment, Media Verite Films production in association with Bunbury Films. Produced by Christopher Branch, Malcolm Clarke, Nick Reed. Executive producers, Frederic Bohbot, Lawrence Abramson, Phillip B. Goldfine, Timothy Marlowe, Agustin. Co-producers, Pip Reed, Kieran Crilly, Jonathan Kitzen. Directed by Malcolme Clarke. Written by Clarke, Carl Freed. Camera (color/B&W), Kieran Crilly; editor, Carl Freed; music, Luc St. Pierre; visual effects, Nick Fodor. With:  Narrator: Malcolm Clarke. Running time: 38 MIN. 

Karama Has No Walls
(Yemen-U.K.-U.A.E.) A Setara Films, Hot Spot Films production. Produced, directed by Sara Ishaq. Camera (color, HD), Ameeen Al-Ghaberi, Nasr Al-Namir, Khaled Rajeh, Ameen Al-Ghaberi, Ishaq; editors, Amri Hamdani, Ishaq. With: Abdulwahed Al-Muati, Ghaled Al-Harazi, Saleeem Al-Harazi, Nasr Al-Namer, Khaled Rajeh. (Arabic dialogue) Running time: 27 MIN. 

Facing Fear
A Jason Cohen Prods. production, in association with Fetzer Institute. Produced, directed, written by Jason Cohen. Co-producer, T.M. Christopher. Camera (color, HD), Svetlana Cvetko; editor, Christopher; music, David Kesler. Running time: 23 MIN. 

A Karoff Films presentation. Directed by Jeffrey Karoff. Camera (color, HD), Anghel Decca; editor, Erin Nordstrom; music, Pete Min. With: Ra Paulette, David Heath, Shel Neymark, Liz Riedel, Paula Seaton. Running time: 39 MIN. 

Terminal Prison: The Last Days of Private Jack Hall
A Home Box Office production. Produced, directed by Edgar Barens. Executive producer, Sheila Nevins. Camera (color, HD), Barens; editor, Geof Bartz. Running time: 40 MIN.

More Film

  • Jeremy Kleiner Dede Gardner Brad Pitt

    Brad Pitt's Production Banner Plan B Relies on Creative Diversity

    “For a long time people tried to figure out ‘What is Plan B?’” says Plan B principal Dede Gardner, who along with fellow executives Jeremy Kleiner and Brad Pitt will receive the David O. Selznick Award at the 31st annual Producers Guild Awards on Jan. 18. “I remember Brad came to us the year that [...]

  • Allison Janney and Viola Davis appear

    Film Review: 'Troop Zero'

    You’ve probably seen a version of “Troop Zero” before. Whether that version was called “Troop Beverly Hills,” “The Mighty Ducks,” or an edited-for-TV showing of “The Bad News Bears,” it’s unlikely that anything here will be particularly fresh to anyone but the youngest of viewers. But novelty does not appear to have been high on [...]

  • Cast of 'Black Panther'25th Annual Screen

    Peers Honoring Peers: What Makes SAG Awards Special

    The 26th annual SAG Awards will be held Jan. 19 at the Shrine Auditorium in Los Angeles and broadcast live on both TNT and TBS at 8 p.m. EST. The SAG Awards are different from typical awards ceremonies for a number of reasons — beginning with length. The show, which comes in at two hours, [...]

  • Ted Sarandos Milestone Award PGA

    Netflix Leader Ted Sarandos Plans Broader Creative Push for the Future

    Ted Sarandos, who has helped to upend the way audiences receive and consume entertainment as Netflix’s chief content officer, will be honored with the Milestone Award at the 31st annual Producers Guild Awards on Jan. 18. Game-changers including Steven Spielberg, Sherry Lansing, Robert Iger, Jeffrey Katzenberg and Ron Meyer have previously received the recognition, and [...]

  • PGA co-presidents Gail Berman and Lucy

    Producers Guild Program Combating Sexual Harassment Kicks Into High Gear

    Producers Guild co-presidents Gail Berman and Lucy Fisher are headed to the org’s annual awards celebration Jan. 18 with a big accomplishment under their respective belts: its anti-harassment program kicked into high gear in 2019, providing free training to 350 people in six months. The Independent Production Safety Initiative (IPSI), established in late 2018, is [...]

  • Robert De Niro SAG Lifetime Acheivement

    SAG Life Achievement Award Honoree Robert De Niro Opens Up

    Robert De Niro is a big winner. It’s the afternoon of the AFI Luncheon, honoring the best in film and television, and De Niro has just left the ceremony with three certificates. “There they are, yeah,” he gestures to a table in his hotel room at the Four Seasons when asked, as if it’s no [...]

  • Best Documentary Scenes from 2019

    Directors Describe Their Key Scenes in the Past Year’s Top Documentary Films

    The directors of this awards season’s documentary hopefuls explain the ticking hearts at the center of their shortlisted films. Apollo 11, Director: Todd Douglas Miller  Setting the Scene: The pre-launch sequence for the first mission in which humans landed on the moon, featuring NASA workers and regular citizens alike. Popular on Variety “It encapsulates everything and [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content