Film Review: ‘The Best of Me’

Appealing performances by Michelle Monaghan and James Marsden can't save this latest Nicholas Sparks adaptation.

Michelle Monaghan, James Marsden, Luke Bracey, Liana Liberato, Caroline Goodall, Gerald McRaney, Sean Bridgers, Sebastian Arcelus.

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1972779/

There’s something unmistakably poignant about the sight of Michelle Monaghan and James Marsden circling each other with barely concealed romantic longing in “The Best of Me,” though not for reasons anyone probably intended. The latest soap product to roll off the Nicholas Sparks assembly line, this tale of two former lovers reuniting after a 21-year separation also functions as a study of two terrific actors struggling to overcome the relentless mediocrity of their material. With its ill-motivated swerves into violent tragedy and the near-fatal miscasting of one pivotal role, the Relativity release seems likely to jerk as many laughs as tears from its target audience, though Sparks fans might still turn out in sufficient date-night droves to continue the author’s string of Hollywood hits.

Sparks has cranked out a fresh slab of romantic hokum every year or so since 1996, and the studios have largely kept pace with his output, hitching themselves to a high-yield cash cow that has produced at least one genuine four-hankie classic (“The Notebook”) and any number of lucrative duds (“The Last Song” and “The Lucky One,” among others). Like many films adapted from the author’s work — this time by writers Will Fetters and J. Mills Goodloe, with Michael Hoffman directing — “The Best of Me” spins a tale of young love imperiled by class prejudice, set against a curiously deracinated Southern backdrop, and infused with the sort of fuzzy-headed spirituality that often finds its characters peering skyward, as though straining to see their fates written in the stars.

One such stargazer is Dawson Cole (Marsden), a handsome, 39-year-old mechanic who miraculously survives an oil-rig explosion and wonders if he could be destined for some higher purpose. Right on cue, he learns of the death of his old friend and mentor, Tuck (Gerald McRaney), prompting a return to his Louisiana hometown. There, Dawson has an awkward reunion with his high-school sweetheart, Amanda (Monaghan), from whom he separated 21 years earlier under mysterious circumstances, and with whom he now jointly owns the plantation-style house where they used to spend hours in Tuck’s (and each other’s) blissful company.

Exactly what transpired between the couple is cleared up in lengthy flashbacks to the autumn of 1992, when Amanda (now played by Liana Liberato) falls in love with Dawson (Australian thesp Luke Bracey) — never mind that her father is one of the richest men in town, while the Coles are all mullets and bullets, a clan of white-trash ne’er-do-wells led by the unrepentantly nasty Tommy (Sean Bridgers, clearly enjoying himself). When Tommy beats up Dawson one time too many, leaving him with a lingering shiner that must have given the continuity supervisor a mild headache, Tuck welcomes the young lad into his home an act of charity and friendship that sets a tense rivalry with the Coles in motion.

A good kid plagued by a crushingly low sense of self-worth, Dawson is too moody and withdrawn at first to respond to Amanda’s affections, but he soon comes out of his shell, as signaled by the vigorous baring of his torso. Before long he and his g.f. are making out in the rain, jumping into a nearby watering hole and getting frisky by the fireplace while the Cowboy Junkies’ cover of “Sweet Jane” plays in the background. (With Amanda’s spirited encouragement, Dawson also considers going to college; we know this because we see him burying his nose in a physics textbook.) Meanwhile, back in the painful present, the now ex-lovers struggle to make sense of their renewed attraction, complicated by the fact that Amanda is now married with children. Conveniently enough, her husband (Sebastian Arcelus) is a total jerk.

Monaghan and Marsden (stepping into a role originally intended for Paul Walker before his death last year) are effortlessly appealing, hugely talented actors who don’t often get the leading-role showcases they deserve. While this isn’t the vehicle to turn those fortunes around, their scenes together are easily the movie’s finest, as the grown-up Dawson and Amanda subtly negotiate the emotional distance between them and then gradually acknowledge that their love for one another remains unchanged. There’s sufficient drama in these moments to render superfluous the movie’s preposterously overplotted third act, recklessly endangering characters in whom we have zero investment to begin with; to call it “manipulative” would be giving it far too much credit.

Liberato (“If I Stay”) supplies a warm, vivacious presence as Amanda, and McRaney gives a gem of a performance as the lovable old coot who helps bring the star-crossed lovers together. But as the young Dawson, the 25-year-old Bracey proves a distractingly odd choice on a number of levels; seemingly cast for his ability to look wounded and withdrawn, he comes off as merely dull, uninvolving, and far too old for high school. Even if there were any resemblance between the two, Bracey’s hulking, uncharismatic performance would make him a poor fit for Marsden, whose wry, quicksilver charm may be his defining attribute as an actor. (“Somehow, you have gotten even better-looking,” Monaghan tells Marsden at one point, earning the film’s biggest and truest laugh.)

It’s gotten to the point where every new Sparks movie feels less like a standalone work than a minor variation on its predecessors (this year’s model of an attractive but unreliable automobile), and Hoffman (“The Last Station,” “Gambit”) is hardly the helmer to break the mold. At times there seems to be a weird visual disconnect between foreground and background, as if the characters had been digitally superimposed over a series of carefully processed Louisiana backdrops; the results feel not just artificial, but thoroughly disposable. And insofar as “The Best of Me” is unlikely to be hailed as the best of anything, audiences may as well console themselves by looking ahead to the star-crossed lovers of “The Longest Ride” and “The Choice,” two new Sparks adaptations already in the works.

Popular on Variety

Film Review: 'The Best of Me'

Reviewed at the Grove, Los Angeles, Oct. 15, 2014. MPAA Rating: PG-13. Running time: 118 MIN.

Production: A Relativity Media release and presentation of a Relativity Media, Di Novi Pictures, Nicholas Sparks production. Produced by Denise Di Novi, Alison Greenspan, Sparks, Ryan Kavanaugh, Theresa Park. Executive producers, Jared D. Underwood, Andrew C. Robinson. Co-producers, Kenneth Halsband, D. Scott Lumpkin.

Crew: Directed by Michael Hoffman. Screenplay, Will Fetters, J. Mills Goodloe, based on the novel by Nicholas Sparks. Camera (Technicolor, widescreen, Arri Alexa digital), Oliver Stapleton; editor, Matt Chesse; music, Aaron Zigman; music supervisor, Bob Bowen; production designer, Patrizia von Brandenstein; art director, Raymond Pumilia; set decorator, Tim Cohn; set designer, Jessica Stumpf; costume designer, Ruth E. Carter; sound (Dolby Digital), Michael B. Koff; re-recording mixers, Lora Hirschberg, Colette D. Dahanne; special effects coordinator, David Nash; visual effects supervisor, Raymond Gieringer; visual effects producer, Sean Nowlan; visual effects, Comen VFX, Prime Focus, Raynault VFX; stunt coordinator, Steven Ritzi; line producer, Patrick Peach; assistant director, Eric Fox Hays; casting, Ronna Kress.

With: Michelle Monaghan, James Marsden, Luke Bracey, Liana Liberato, Caroline Goodall, Gerald McRaney, Sean Bridgers, Sebastian Arcelus.

More Film

  • Q A_Joker_Lawrence-Sher_CKK-Jordanki_fot-Maria-Kowalska_11

    'Joker’ Cinematographer on Joaquin Phoenix’s Transformative Performance

    TORUN, Poland – “Joker” cinematographer Lawrence Sher received a rockstar welcome at the EnergaCamerimage Intl. Film Festival on Monday as attendees struggled to squeeze into a standing-room only conference room for a lively and in-depth Q&A session on the making of the box office sensation. Sher appeared equally excited to be at the event. “Obviously [...]

  • Igor Drljaca, Agata Smoluch Del Sorbo

    Verve Signs 'Disappearance at Clifton Hill' Director Albert Shin (EXCLUSIVE)

    Verve has signed Albert Shin, the director of the buzzy new thriller “Disappearance at Clifton Hill,” Variety has learned. Distribution rights for the film were recently acquired by IFC Midnight and the movie is expected to open in February. “Disappearance at Clifton Hill” debuted at this year’s Toronto International Film Festival. It centers on a [...]

  • John Bailey

    John Bailey Urges Cinematographers to Embrace Story Over Technology

    It’s safe to say John Bailey does not miss the trappings of the president’s office at the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences. Speaking at a retrospective celebrating his five decades of cinematography work at Poland’s EnergaCamerimage festival, where Bailey will be honored with a lifetime achievement award this week, he told an audience [...]

  • Justin Bieber Cupid Movie

    Justin Bieber Debuts First Look at 'Cupid' Movie

    Beware of cupid’s arrow. Justin Bieber unveiled a first-look photo for “Cupid,” his upcoming animated movie from Mythos Studios. The image sees a cartooned Bieber, who will voice the god of love, on the side of a cliff with the sun setting in the background. “Cupid” will tell the story of the eponymous mythical being [...]

  • Robert De Niro

    Robert De Niro to Receive SAG Life Achievement Award

    Robert De Niro will be honored with a SAG life achievement award. The legendary actor, who currently stars in Netflix’s “The Irishman” and Warner Bros.’ “Joker,” will receive the performers’ union’s top accolade at the 26th annual SAG Awards on Jan. 19 at the Shrine Auditorium in Los Angeles. The award is given annually to [...]

  • Ella Balinska, Kristen Stewart and Naomi

    Film Review: 'Charlie's Angels'

    Most reboots are meaningless (time to rev that franchise back up!). But the new “Charlie’s Angels,” whether it turns out to be a glittering hit or the latest expensive package to get tossed by the audience onto the trash heap of franchise fatigue, feels like a generational rite of passage. The original “Charlie’s Angels,” which [...]

  • Jay Pharaoh2016 MTV Video Music Awards,

    Jay Pharoah Joins Cast of Universal's 'All My Life' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Jay Pharoah has joined the cast of Universal’s drama “All My Life.” Actors Marielle Scott and Kyle Allen will also appear in the film alongside the previously announced cast of Jessica Rothe and Harry Shum Jr. Directed by Marc Meyers, “All My Life” is inspired by the true story of Jenn Carter and her husband, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content